CLAT Exam > CLAT Questions > X sells by auction to Y, a horse which X know...
Start Learning for Free
X sells by auction to Y, a horse which X knows to be of unsound state of mind. X says nothing to Y about horse's unsound state of mind. Give the answer
(a) X can be held liable for fraud
(b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation
(c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about mental state of the horse
(d) X cannot be be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things?
(a) X can be held liable for fraud
(b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation
(c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about mental state of the horse
(d) X cannot be be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things?
Most Upvoted Answer
X sells by auction to Y, a horse which X knows to be of unsound state ...
Understanding the Scenario
In this scenario, X sells a horse to Y, fully aware of the horse's unsound mental state but chooses to remain silent about it. The key legal issues revolve around whether X can be held liable for fraud or misrepresentation.
Key Legal Concepts
- Fraud: Fraud generally involves a deliberate deception to secure unfair or unlawful gain. In this case, X's silence about the horse's mental state can be considered fraudulent if it is proven that X intended to deceive Y.
- Misrepresentation: Misrepresentation occurs when a false statement is made that induces the other party to enter into a contract. Silence can constitute misrepresentation in certain circumstances, especially when there is a duty to disclose.
Analysis of Options
- (a) X can be held liable for fraud: If it can be shown that X's intention was to deceive Y by withholding critical information, this option is valid.
- (b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation: Because X had knowledge of an important defect (the horse's unsound mind) that Y was not aware of, this option is also plausible.
- (c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about the mental state of the horse: This argument is weak since silence in the face of a known defect can still be actionable.
- (d) X cannot be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things: This perspective overlooks the duty of the seller to disclose known defects that could materially affect the buyer's decision.
Conclusion
Based on the legal principles of fraud and misrepresentation, X can potentially be held liable for either or both due to the knowledge of the horse's unsound state of mind and the failure to disclose this critical information to Y.
In this scenario, X sells a horse to Y, fully aware of the horse's unsound mental state but chooses to remain silent about it. The key legal issues revolve around whether X can be held liable for fraud or misrepresentation.
Key Legal Concepts
- Fraud: Fraud generally involves a deliberate deception to secure unfair or unlawful gain. In this case, X's silence about the horse's mental state can be considered fraudulent if it is proven that X intended to deceive Y.
- Misrepresentation: Misrepresentation occurs when a false statement is made that induces the other party to enter into a contract. Silence can constitute misrepresentation in certain circumstances, especially when there is a duty to disclose.
Analysis of Options
- (a) X can be held liable for fraud: If it can be shown that X's intention was to deceive Y by withholding critical information, this option is valid.
- (b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation: Because X had knowledge of an important defect (the horse's unsound mind) that Y was not aware of, this option is also plausible.
- (c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about the mental state of the horse: This argument is weak since silence in the face of a known defect can still be actionable.
- (d) X cannot be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things: This perspective overlooks the duty of the seller to disclose known defects that could materially affect the buyer's decision.
Conclusion
Based on the legal principles of fraud and misrepresentation, X can potentially be held liable for either or both due to the knowledge of the horse's unsound state of mind and the failure to disclose this critical information to Y.
|
Explore Courses for CLAT exam
|
|
Similar CLAT Doubts
Top Courses for CLATView all
X sells by auction to Y, a horse which X knows to be of unsound state of mind. X says nothing to Y about horse's unsound state of mind. Give the answer(a) X can be held liable for fraud(b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation (c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about mental state of the horse(d) X cannot be be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things?
Question Description
X sells by auction to Y, a horse which X knows to be of unsound state of mind. X says nothing to Y about horse's unsound state of mind. Give the answer(a) X can be held liable for fraud(b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation (c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about mental state of the horse(d) X cannot be be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things? for CLAT 2025 is part of CLAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CLAT exam syllabus. Information about X sells by auction to Y, a horse which X knows to be of unsound state of mind. X says nothing to Y about horse's unsound state of mind. Give the answer(a) X can be held liable for fraud(b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation (c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about mental state of the horse(d) X cannot be be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things? covers all topics & solutions for CLAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for X sells by auction to Y, a horse which X knows to be of unsound state of mind. X says nothing to Y about horse's unsound state of mind. Give the answer(a) X can be held liable for fraud(b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation (c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about mental state of the horse(d) X cannot be be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things?.
X sells by auction to Y, a horse which X knows to be of unsound state of mind. X says nothing to Y about horse's unsound state of mind. Give the answer(a) X can be held liable for fraud(b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation (c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about mental state of the horse(d) X cannot be be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things? for CLAT 2025 is part of CLAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CLAT exam syllabus. Information about X sells by auction to Y, a horse which X knows to be of unsound state of mind. X says nothing to Y about horse's unsound state of mind. Give the answer(a) X can be held liable for fraud(b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation (c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about mental state of the horse(d) X cannot be be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things? covers all topics & solutions for CLAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for X sells by auction to Y, a horse which X knows to be of unsound state of mind. X says nothing to Y about horse's unsound state of mind. Give the answer(a) X can be held liable for fraud(b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation (c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about mental state of the horse(d) X cannot be be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things?.
Solutions for X sells by auction to Y, a horse which X knows to be of unsound state of mind. X says nothing to Y about horse's unsound state of mind. Give the answer(a) X can be held liable for fraud(b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation (c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about mental state of the horse(d) X cannot be be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for CLAT.
Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for CLAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of X sells by auction to Y, a horse which X knows to be of unsound state of mind. X says nothing to Y about horse's unsound state of mind. Give the answer(a) X can be held liable for fraud(b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation (c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about mental state of the horse(d) X cannot be be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of
X sells by auction to Y, a horse which X knows to be of unsound state of mind. X says nothing to Y about horse's unsound state of mind. Give the answer(a) X can be held liable for fraud(b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation (c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about mental state of the horse(d) X cannot be be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things?, a detailed solution for X sells by auction to Y, a horse which X knows to be of unsound state of mind. X says nothing to Y about horse's unsound state of mind. Give the answer(a) X can be held liable for fraud(b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation (c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about mental state of the horse(d) X cannot be be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things? has been provided alongside types of X sells by auction to Y, a horse which X knows to be of unsound state of mind. X says nothing to Y about horse's unsound state of mind. Give the answer(a) X can be held liable for fraud(b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation (c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about mental state of the horse(d) X cannot be be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things? theory, EduRev gives you an
ample number of questions to practice X sells by auction to Y, a horse which X knows to be of unsound state of mind. X says nothing to Y about horse's unsound state of mind. Give the answer(a) X can be held liable for fraud(b) X can be held liable for misrepresentation (c) X cannot be held liable, because he did not say anything positive about mental state of the horse(d) X cannot be be held liable because it is the buyer who must be aware of the things? tests, examples and also practice CLAT tests.
|
|
Explore Courses for CLAT exam
|
|
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
|
© EduRev
|
Education Revolution
|
|
Signup to see your scores
go up within 7 days!
Access 1000+ FREE Docs, Videos and Tests
Takes less than 10 seconds to signup