What is a significant concern regarding the current creamy layer threshold of ₹8 lakh for OBC reservations?a) It only benefits families with high incomesb) It has been revised too frequentlyc) It is too low to provide any benefitsd) It excludes many families facing economic disadvantagesCorrect answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?

Question

Answer

Significant Concern Regarding the Creamy Layer Threshold
The creamy layer threshold of ₹8 lakh for Other Backward Classes (OBC) reservations is a pressing issue in the context of social equity and economic justice.
Exclusion of Economically Disadvantaged Families
- The primary concern is that the current threshold of ₹8 lakh may exclude many families who are economically disadvantaged but do not fall within the specified income limit.
- Families earning just below this threshold may still struggle with basic needs such as education, healthcare, and housing, which are essential for upward mobility.
Context of Economic Disparity
- Economic disparities in India are significant, and a threshold of ₹8 lakh does not account for regional variations in the cost of living.
- In urban areas, this income may not suffice for a comfortable living, while in rural areas, it may provide some stability. Thus, the threshold is not uniformly applicable across different contexts.
Impact on Reservation Benefits
- By limiting the benefits of OBC reservations to those below the ₹8 lakh threshold, many deserving candidates who face economic hardships are denied opportunities in education and employment.
- This exclusion undermines the very purpose of reservations, which is to uplift economically and socially disadvantaged groups.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the ₹8 lakh creamy layer threshold for OBC reservations is criticized for excluding numerous families grappling with economic disadvantages. A reevaluation of this threshold is essential to ensure that the benefits of reservations genuinely reach those in need.

Answer

The current creamy layer threshold of ₹8 lakh is criticized for excluding many families who, despite earning above this limit, still face significant economic disadvantages. This highlights the need for a more nuanced approach that considers various socio-economic factors beyond just income.

Answer

Understanding the Creamy Layer Concept
The 'creamy layer' refers to a segment within the Other Backward Classes (OBC) category that is deemed to be socially and economically advanced. The threshold of ₹8 lakh is used to determine eligibility for OBC reservations in education and government jobs.
Significance of the ₹8 Lakh Threshold
- This threshold is crucial because it aims to ensure that the benefits of reservation reach those who genuinely need them.
- However, at ₹8 lakh, many economically disadvantaged families might still be excluded from these benefits.
Concerns Regarding the Current Threshold
- Exclusion of Needy Families: Many families earning just below the threshold may face significant financial challenges. This includes expenses related to education, healthcare, and daily living.
- Rising Cost of Living: The economic landscape has changed, with inflation and rising living costs. A family earning ₹8 lakh may struggle to meet basic needs in urban areas, making the threshold seem inadequate.
- Variability in Income: Income levels can fluctuate, and a family earning just above the threshold might not be financially secure. This discrepancy creates a gap where many deserving families do not receive the benefits intended for them.
Conclusion
The current creamy layer threshold of ₹8 lakh is often criticized for excluding many families that face economic disadvantages. While the intention is to target the genuinely needy, the threshold fails to account for the diverse realities of economic challenges faced by families across different regions. Re-evaluating this limit could ensure a more equitable distribution of reservation benefits.

Top Courses for Bank ExamsView all

SBI PO Prelims & Mains Preparation

IBPS PO Prelims & Mains Preparation

Crash Course for Banking Exams

RBI Grade B Phase 1 Preparation

General Awareness

Top Courses for Bank Exams

Top Courses for Bank Exams

Related Content

Schools

Competitive Examinations

Quick Access Links

Technical Exams