CLAT Exam > CLAT Questions > X went Y's house and forgot his bag which con...
Start Learning for Free
X went Y's house and forgot his bag which contained 1kg sweets.Y's children consumed the sweets. Decide the liability of Y? (a) Y is bound to pay the price of sweets to X. (b) Y is not bound to pay anything. (c) Y is bound to pay half the price of sweets. (d) Y would not have to pay anything because X loves Y's children. ?
Most Upvoted Answer
X went Y's house and forgot his bag which contained 1kg sweets.Y's chi...
Liability of Y in the Situation
Scenario: X forgot his bag at Y's house, which contained 1kg of sweets, and Y's children consumed the sweets.
Evaluation of Options:
In conclusion, the liability of Y in this situation would depend on factors such as duty of care, negligence, and the specific circumstances of the incident. It is important to carefully evaluate these aspects before determining Y's responsibility in relation to the consumed sweets.
Scenario: X forgot his bag at Y's house, which contained 1kg of sweets, and Y's children consumed the sweets.
- Legal Responsibility: In this scenario, the liability of Y can be analyzed based on legal principles.
- Duty of Care: As the sweets were consumed by Y's children, it is important to consider whether Y had a duty of care towards X's belongings.
- Reasonable Care: Generally, individuals are expected to take reasonable care of the belongings of others that are in their possession.
- No Negligence: If Y did not intentionally or negligently allow the children to consume the sweets, it may be argued that Y should not be held liable.
- Relationship between X and Y: The relationship between X and Y can also be a factor in determining liability.
Evaluation of Options:
- (a) Y is bound to pay the price of sweets to X: This option may be applicable if Y failed to fulfill the duty of care and was negligent in the situation.
- (b) Y is not bound to pay anything: If Y took reasonable care and did not act negligently, this option may be appropriate.
- (c) Y is bound to pay half the price of sweets: This option could be considered if there was shared responsibility in the situation.
- (d) Y would not have to pay anything because X loves Y's children: Emotional factors should generally not influence legal liability, so this option may not be legally justified.
In conclusion, the liability of Y in this situation would depend on factors such as duty of care, negligence, and the specific circumstances of the incident. It is important to carefully evaluate these aspects before determining Y's responsibility in relation to the consumed sweets.
Community Answer
X went Y's house and forgot his bag which contained 1kg sweets.Y's chi...
Due to the ambiguous nature of question and no legal principle, two options have the equal opportunity to be right, option A and B. But the CLAT committee has marked only option B as correct.
|
Explore Courses for CLAT exam
|
|
Top Courses for CLATView all
X went Y's house and forgot his bag which contained 1kg sweets.Y's children consumed the sweets. Decide the liability of Y? (a) Y is bound to pay the price of sweets to X. (b) Y is not bound to pay anything. (c) Y is bound to pay half the price of sweets. (d) Y would not have to pay anything because X loves Y's children. ?
Question Description
X went Y's house and forgot his bag which contained 1kg sweets.Y's children consumed the sweets. Decide the liability of Y? (a) Y is bound to pay the price of sweets to X. (b) Y is not bound to pay anything. (c) Y is bound to pay half the price of sweets. (d) Y would not have to pay anything because X loves Y's children. ? for CLAT 2025 is part of CLAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CLAT exam syllabus. Information about X went Y's house and forgot his bag which contained 1kg sweets.Y's children consumed the sweets. Decide the liability of Y? (a) Y is bound to pay the price of sweets to X. (b) Y is not bound to pay anything. (c) Y is bound to pay half the price of sweets. (d) Y would not have to pay anything because X loves Y's children. ? covers all topics & solutions for CLAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for X went Y's house and forgot his bag which contained 1kg sweets.Y's children consumed the sweets. Decide the liability of Y? (a) Y is bound to pay the price of sweets to X. (b) Y is not bound to pay anything. (c) Y is bound to pay half the price of sweets. (d) Y would not have to pay anything because X loves Y's children. ?.
X went Y's house and forgot his bag which contained 1kg sweets.Y's children consumed the sweets. Decide the liability of Y? (a) Y is bound to pay the price of sweets to X. (b) Y is not bound to pay anything. (c) Y is bound to pay half the price of sweets. (d) Y would not have to pay anything because X loves Y's children. ? for CLAT 2025 is part of CLAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CLAT exam syllabus. Information about X went Y's house and forgot his bag which contained 1kg sweets.Y's children consumed the sweets. Decide the liability of Y? (a) Y is bound to pay the price of sweets to X. (b) Y is not bound to pay anything. (c) Y is bound to pay half the price of sweets. (d) Y would not have to pay anything because X loves Y's children. ? covers all topics & solutions for CLAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for X went Y's house and forgot his bag which contained 1kg sweets.Y's children consumed the sweets. Decide the liability of Y? (a) Y is bound to pay the price of sweets to X. (b) Y is not bound to pay anything. (c) Y is bound to pay half the price of sweets. (d) Y would not have to pay anything because X loves Y's children. ?.
Solutions for X went Y's house and forgot his bag which contained 1kg sweets.Y's children consumed the sweets. Decide the liability of Y? (a) Y is bound to pay the price of sweets to X. (b) Y is not bound to pay anything. (c) Y is bound to pay half the price of sweets. (d) Y would not have to pay anything because X loves Y's children. ? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for CLAT.
Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for CLAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of X went Y's house and forgot his bag which contained 1kg sweets.Y's children consumed the sweets. Decide the liability of Y? (a) Y is bound to pay the price of sweets to X. (b) Y is not bound to pay anything. (c) Y is bound to pay half the price of sweets. (d) Y would not have to pay anything because X loves Y's children. ? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of
X went Y's house and forgot his bag which contained 1kg sweets.Y's children consumed the sweets. Decide the liability of Y? (a) Y is bound to pay the price of sweets to X. (b) Y is not bound to pay anything. (c) Y is bound to pay half the price of sweets. (d) Y would not have to pay anything because X loves Y's children. ?, a detailed solution for X went Y's house and forgot his bag which contained 1kg sweets.Y's children consumed the sweets. Decide the liability of Y? (a) Y is bound to pay the price of sweets to X. (b) Y is not bound to pay anything. (c) Y is bound to pay half the price of sweets. (d) Y would not have to pay anything because X loves Y's children. ? has been provided alongside types of X went Y's house and forgot his bag which contained 1kg sweets.Y's children consumed the sweets. Decide the liability of Y? (a) Y is bound to pay the price of sweets to X. (b) Y is not bound to pay anything. (c) Y is bound to pay half the price of sweets. (d) Y would not have to pay anything because X loves Y's children. ? theory, EduRev gives you an
ample number of questions to practice X went Y's house and forgot his bag which contained 1kg sweets.Y's children consumed the sweets. Decide the liability of Y? (a) Y is bound to pay the price of sweets to X. (b) Y is not bound to pay anything. (c) Y is bound to pay half the price of sweets. (d) Y would not have to pay anything because X loves Y's children. ? tests, examples and also practice CLAT tests.
|
|
Explore Courses for CLAT exam
|
|
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
|
© EduRev
|
Education Revolution
|
|
Signup to see your scores
go up within 7 days!
Access 1000+ FREE Docs, Videos and Tests
Takes less than 10 seconds to signup