CLAT Exam  >  CLAT Notes  >  Passage Based Questions for CLAT Preparation  >  Passage Based Questions: Legal Aptitude - 13

Passage Based Questions: Legal Aptitude - 13 | Passage Based Questions for CLAT Preparation PDF Download

Directions : Read the following passage and answer the questions.
In their traditional mould, a court adjudicates disputes between parties-and in that context examines the causes brought before them-where there were instances of violation of constitutional rights of the underprivileged .This was extended to apathy in enforcing environmental law. The court took on the task of examining causes. The PIL was born!
With time, the growth of this kind of intervention by the court gave birth to organisations whose objective was to file PILs to champion public causes. As intervention of the courts increased. PILs increasingly became at time a vehicle for “eminent” members of civil society to clothe their point of view in a constitutional garb and seek its enforcement as enforcement of pseudo-constitutional rights. Undeterred by the consequences of monumental failures of court monitored investigations such as the Jain Hawala case and the 2G case, petitions continue to be filled seeking court monitored investigations into all and sundry.
Left leaning economic philosophies which have been abandoned in their country of origin, and whose protagonists have lost at the hustings, are attempted to be fed into the system through judicial edict. Whether it be privatisation or nuclear power generation, creation of new highways, new ports or new airports- the court is asked to step in and prevent the elected executive from implementing its policies.
2009-2014 saw a dramatic rise in such PILs – as governance shrank, the remit of the court’s power seemed to grow, for nature abhors a vacuum. This intrusive jurisdiction had, at some point, to be tempered. The need for a course correction was apparent to those who dispassionately examined the working of the institution. And that is what has happened.
Justice is not a cloistered virtue, and the judgements of the court must be open to public debate. Criticising the judges and condemning the institution by ascribing motives to the judges and accusing them of lack of intellectual integrity is quite another matter. The Jain Hawala case judgements and the 2G judgements have exposed the dangers of court monitored investigations, where reputations are destroyed and businesses laid waste, only to end in mass acquittals. The coal allocation judgment and the Goa mining judgement have generously contributed to bringing down the GDP. Yet any suggestion that the judges, who dealt with those cases, acted out of anything other than the highest of motives is preposterous.

Question for Passage Based Questions: Legal Aptitude - 13
Try yourself:According to the passage the growth of the PILs(Public Interest Litigation) can be attributed to 
View Solution

Question for Passage Based Questions: Legal Aptitude - 13
Try yourself:According to the author the actions taken by the judges in the PIL cases are 
View Solution

Question for Passage Based Questions: Legal Aptitude - 13
Try yourself:According to the passage which statement expresses that PILs and court intervention has led to loss of businesses.
View Solution

Question for Passage Based Questions: Legal Aptitude - 13
Try yourself:According to the author which statement best expresses the main point of the passage 
View Solution

Question for Passage Based Questions: Legal Aptitude - 13
Try yourself:PIL(Public Interest Litigation) means that even people who are not directly party to a case can bring the matters of public interest to the court. A rival group manufacturing asbestos substitutes files a petition in the court against abestos making industrial unit outside city on the ground of hazardous material. What action will be appropriate?
View Solution

The document Passage Based Questions: Legal Aptitude - 13 | Passage Based Questions for CLAT Preparation is a part of the CLAT Course Passage Based Questions for CLAT Preparation.
All you need of CLAT at this link: CLAT
6 videos|295 docs

Top Courses for CLAT

6 videos|295 docs
Download as PDF
Explore Courses for CLAT exam

Top Courses for CLAT

Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev
Related Searches

Passage Based Questions: Legal Aptitude - 13 | Passage Based Questions for CLAT Preparation

,

Passage Based Questions: Legal Aptitude - 13 | Passage Based Questions for CLAT Preparation

,

shortcuts and tricks

,

practice quizzes

,

Viva Questions

,

Extra Questions

,

past year papers

,

pdf

,

Semester Notes

,

Important questions

,

study material

,

Objective type Questions

,

MCQs

,

Summary

,

Passage Based Questions: Legal Aptitude - 13 | Passage Based Questions for CLAT Preparation

,

Previous Year Questions with Solutions

,

mock tests for examination

,

Sample Paper

,

Exam

,

Free

,

video lectures

,

ppt

;