CLAT Exam  >  CLAT Questions  >  PRINCIPLE 1:If a man murders a woman, he is t... Start Learning for Free
PRINCIPLE 1: If a man murders a woman, he is to be held guilty for murder.
PRINCIPLE 2: If a woman murders a man, she is not guilty of murder.
PRINCIPLE 3: If a man murders another man, he is not liable for murder.
PRINCIPLE 4: If a woman murders another woman, she is not guilty of murder.
PRINCIPLE 5: If a man murders anyone below the age of 20 years, he is to be held liable for murder.
FACTS: Dino is a terrorist and is forever fleeing from the police. His sister, Diana lives away from him, since he is worried for her safety. She studies in a University in Bangalore, and her best friend is Deep falls in love with her. When the Police get to know of Dino’s sister, they try to establish contact with her, so that they can reach Dino through her. They try to ask Diana, but she can’t give any assistance to the Police since she herself does not know of her brother’s whereabouts. The police think that Diana is trying to evade their questions on purpose and decide to use Deep as a means to get her to talk. When Deep gets to know of this, he refuses to help since he loves Diana and does not want her to be harmed in any way. Now the Police are in a dilemma, but they discover that Deep has a younger brother called Deepak. They kidnap Deepak, when he is returning from school, and threaten Deep that if he does not comply with the Police, they will kill him. Deep thinks that they are merely kidding and still refuses to help the Police. Khunkar Singh, who is the Commissioner, is angered by the turn of events and shoots Deepak in frustration. When Deep gets to know of this, he completely loses his mind and sets out to avenge his brother’s death. He goes and shoots the Inspector, who fires in retaliation. Diana also appears on the spot and amongst all the shooting, gets injured by a bullet shot by the Inspector. She shoots the Inspector who dies on the spot. Dino also arrives to save his sister and when he sees Deep, he assumes that he was a police man in plain clothes and shot him dead.
Q. 
If the Inspector had shot Deep instead of Deepak, would he be liable for murder?
  • a)
    No, he would not be guilty as per law
  • b)
    Yes, shooting without a cause is an offence
  • c)
    No, the Inspector was frustrated since no one was giving him information
  • d)
    Yes, because Deep was innocent
Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?
Most Upvoted Answer
PRINCIPLE 1:If a man murders a woman, he is to be held guilty for murd...
Here we don't know whether inspector was male or female. If the inspector was male then a/c to principle 3 man murdering another man is not liable .
and if inspector was female then a/c to principle 2, a woman murdering a man is not guilty of murder.
IN both th cases he/she not guilty.
SO, option (A) should be right answer.
Free Test
Community Answer
PRINCIPLE 1:If a man murders a woman, he is to be held guilty for murd...
A is the correct option. According to the facts we don't know whether the inspector was male or female. If the inspector was male then a/c to principle 3 man murdering another man is not liable .
and if inspector was female then a/c to principle 2, a woman murdering a man is not guilty of murder.
IN both the cases he/she is not guilty.
Attention CLAT Students!
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed CLAT study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in CLAT.
Explore Courses for CLAT exam

Top Courses for CLAT

PRINCIPLE 1:If a man murders a woman, he is to be held guilty for murder.PRINCIPLE 2:If a woman murders a man, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 3:If a man murders another man, he is not liable for murder.PRINCIPLE 4:If a woman murders another woman, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 5:If a man murders anyone below the age of 20 years, he is to be held liable for murder.FACTS: Dino is a terrorist and is forever fleeing from the police. His sister, Diana lives away from him, since he is worried for her safety. She studies in a University in Bangalore, and her best friend is Deep falls in love with her. When the Police get to know of Dino’s sister, they try to establish contact with her, so that they can reach Dino through her. They try to ask Diana, but she can’t give any assistance to the Police since she herself does not know of her brother’s whereabouts. The police think that Diana is trying to evade their questions on purpose and decide to use Deep as a means to get her to talk. When Deep gets to know of this, he refuses to help since he loves Diana and does not want her to be harmed in any way. Now the Police are in a dilemma, but they discover that Deep has a younger brother called Deepak. They kidnap Deepak, when he is returning from school, and threaten Deep that if he does not comply with the Police, they will kill him. Deep thinks that they are merely kidding and still refuses to help the Police. Khunkar Singh, who is the Commissioner, is angered by the turn of events and shoots Deepak in frustration. When Deep gets to know of this, he completely loses his mind and sets out to avenge his brother’s death. He goes and shoots the Inspector, who fires in retaliation. Diana also appears on the spot and amongst all the shooting, gets injured by a bullet shot by the Inspector. She shoots the Inspector who dies on the spot. Dino also arrives to save his sister and when he sees Deep, he assumes that he was a police man in plain clothes and shot him dead.Q.If the Inspector had shot Deep instead of Deepak, would he be liable for murder?a)No, he would not be guilty as per lawb)Yes, shooting without a cause is an offencec)No, the Inspector was frustrated since no one was giving him informationd)Yes, because Deep was innocentCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?
Question Description
PRINCIPLE 1:If a man murders a woman, he is to be held guilty for murder.PRINCIPLE 2:If a woman murders a man, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 3:If a man murders another man, he is not liable for murder.PRINCIPLE 4:If a woman murders another woman, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 5:If a man murders anyone below the age of 20 years, he is to be held liable for murder.FACTS: Dino is a terrorist and is forever fleeing from the police. His sister, Diana lives away from him, since he is worried for her safety. She studies in a University in Bangalore, and her best friend is Deep falls in love with her. When the Police get to know of Dino’s sister, they try to establish contact with her, so that they can reach Dino through her. They try to ask Diana, but she can’t give any assistance to the Police since she herself does not know of her brother’s whereabouts. The police think that Diana is trying to evade their questions on purpose and decide to use Deep as a means to get her to talk. When Deep gets to know of this, he refuses to help since he loves Diana and does not want her to be harmed in any way. Now the Police are in a dilemma, but they discover that Deep has a younger brother called Deepak. They kidnap Deepak, when he is returning from school, and threaten Deep that if he does not comply with the Police, they will kill him. Deep thinks that they are merely kidding and still refuses to help the Police. Khunkar Singh, who is the Commissioner, is angered by the turn of events and shoots Deepak in frustration. When Deep gets to know of this, he completely loses his mind and sets out to avenge his brother’s death. He goes and shoots the Inspector, who fires in retaliation. Diana also appears on the spot and amongst all the shooting, gets injured by a bullet shot by the Inspector. She shoots the Inspector who dies on the spot. Dino also arrives to save his sister and when he sees Deep, he assumes that he was a police man in plain clothes and shot him dead.Q.If the Inspector had shot Deep instead of Deepak, would he be liable for murder?a)No, he would not be guilty as per lawb)Yes, shooting without a cause is an offencec)No, the Inspector was frustrated since no one was giving him informationd)Yes, because Deep was innocentCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? for CLAT 2024 is part of CLAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CLAT exam syllabus. Information about PRINCIPLE 1:If a man murders a woman, he is to be held guilty for murder.PRINCIPLE 2:If a woman murders a man, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 3:If a man murders another man, he is not liable for murder.PRINCIPLE 4:If a woman murders another woman, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 5:If a man murders anyone below the age of 20 years, he is to be held liable for murder.FACTS: Dino is a terrorist and is forever fleeing from the police. His sister, Diana lives away from him, since he is worried for her safety. She studies in a University in Bangalore, and her best friend is Deep falls in love with her. When the Police get to know of Dino’s sister, they try to establish contact with her, so that they can reach Dino through her. They try to ask Diana, but she can’t give any assistance to the Police since she herself does not know of her brother’s whereabouts. The police think that Diana is trying to evade their questions on purpose and decide to use Deep as a means to get her to talk. When Deep gets to know of this, he refuses to help since he loves Diana and does not want her to be harmed in any way. Now the Police are in a dilemma, but they discover that Deep has a younger brother called Deepak. They kidnap Deepak, when he is returning from school, and threaten Deep that if he does not comply with the Police, they will kill him. Deep thinks that they are merely kidding and still refuses to help the Police. Khunkar Singh, who is the Commissioner, is angered by the turn of events and shoots Deepak in frustration. When Deep gets to know of this, he completely loses his mind and sets out to avenge his brother’s death. He goes and shoots the Inspector, who fires in retaliation. Diana also appears on the spot and amongst all the shooting, gets injured by a bullet shot by the Inspector. She shoots the Inspector who dies on the spot. Dino also arrives to save his sister and when he sees Deep, he assumes that he was a police man in plain clothes and shot him dead.Q.If the Inspector had shot Deep instead of Deepak, would he be liable for murder?a)No, he would not be guilty as per lawb)Yes, shooting without a cause is an offencec)No, the Inspector was frustrated since no one was giving him informationd)Yes, because Deep was innocentCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for CLAT 2024 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for PRINCIPLE 1:If a man murders a woman, he is to be held guilty for murder.PRINCIPLE 2:If a woman murders a man, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 3:If a man murders another man, he is not liable for murder.PRINCIPLE 4:If a woman murders another woman, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 5:If a man murders anyone below the age of 20 years, he is to be held liable for murder.FACTS: Dino is a terrorist and is forever fleeing from the police. His sister, Diana lives away from him, since he is worried for her safety. She studies in a University in Bangalore, and her best friend is Deep falls in love with her. When the Police get to know of Dino’s sister, they try to establish contact with her, so that they can reach Dino through her. They try to ask Diana, but she can’t give any assistance to the Police since she herself does not know of her brother’s whereabouts. The police think that Diana is trying to evade their questions on purpose and decide to use Deep as a means to get her to talk. When Deep gets to know of this, he refuses to help since he loves Diana and does not want her to be harmed in any way. Now the Police are in a dilemma, but they discover that Deep has a younger brother called Deepak. They kidnap Deepak, when he is returning from school, and threaten Deep that if he does not comply with the Police, they will kill him. Deep thinks that they are merely kidding and still refuses to help the Police. Khunkar Singh, who is the Commissioner, is angered by the turn of events and shoots Deepak in frustration. When Deep gets to know of this, he completely loses his mind and sets out to avenge his brother’s death. He goes and shoots the Inspector, who fires in retaliation. Diana also appears on the spot and amongst all the shooting, gets injured by a bullet shot by the Inspector. She shoots the Inspector who dies on the spot. Dino also arrives to save his sister and when he sees Deep, he assumes that he was a police man in plain clothes and shot him dead.Q.If the Inspector had shot Deep instead of Deepak, would he be liable for murder?a)No, he would not be guilty as per lawb)Yes, shooting without a cause is an offencec)No, the Inspector was frustrated since no one was giving him informationd)Yes, because Deep was innocentCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for PRINCIPLE 1:If a man murders a woman, he is to be held guilty for murder.PRINCIPLE 2:If a woman murders a man, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 3:If a man murders another man, he is not liable for murder.PRINCIPLE 4:If a woman murders another woman, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 5:If a man murders anyone below the age of 20 years, he is to be held liable for murder.FACTS: Dino is a terrorist and is forever fleeing from the police. His sister, Diana lives away from him, since he is worried for her safety. She studies in a University in Bangalore, and her best friend is Deep falls in love with her. When the Police get to know of Dino’s sister, they try to establish contact with her, so that they can reach Dino through her. They try to ask Diana, but she can’t give any assistance to the Police since she herself does not know of her brother’s whereabouts. The police think that Diana is trying to evade their questions on purpose and decide to use Deep as a means to get her to talk. When Deep gets to know of this, he refuses to help since he loves Diana and does not want her to be harmed in any way. Now the Police are in a dilemma, but they discover that Deep has a younger brother called Deepak. They kidnap Deepak, when he is returning from school, and threaten Deep that if he does not comply with the Police, they will kill him. Deep thinks that they are merely kidding and still refuses to help the Police. Khunkar Singh, who is the Commissioner, is angered by the turn of events and shoots Deepak in frustration. When Deep gets to know of this, he completely loses his mind and sets out to avenge his brother’s death. He goes and shoots the Inspector, who fires in retaliation. Diana also appears on the spot and amongst all the shooting, gets injured by a bullet shot by the Inspector. She shoots the Inspector who dies on the spot. Dino also arrives to save his sister and when he sees Deep, he assumes that he was a police man in plain clothes and shot him dead.Q.If the Inspector had shot Deep instead of Deepak, would he be liable for murder?a)No, he would not be guilty as per lawb)Yes, shooting without a cause is an offencec)No, the Inspector was frustrated since no one was giving him informationd)Yes, because Deep was innocentCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for CLAT. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for CLAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of PRINCIPLE 1:If a man murders a woman, he is to be held guilty for murder.PRINCIPLE 2:If a woman murders a man, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 3:If a man murders another man, he is not liable for murder.PRINCIPLE 4:If a woman murders another woman, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 5:If a man murders anyone below the age of 20 years, he is to be held liable for murder.FACTS: Dino is a terrorist and is forever fleeing from the police. His sister, Diana lives away from him, since he is worried for her safety. She studies in a University in Bangalore, and her best friend is Deep falls in love with her. When the Police get to know of Dino’s sister, they try to establish contact with her, so that they can reach Dino through her. They try to ask Diana, but she can’t give any assistance to the Police since she herself does not know of her brother’s whereabouts. The police think that Diana is trying to evade their questions on purpose and decide to use Deep as a means to get her to talk. When Deep gets to know of this, he refuses to help since he loves Diana and does not want her to be harmed in any way. Now the Police are in a dilemma, but they discover that Deep has a younger brother called Deepak. They kidnap Deepak, when he is returning from school, and threaten Deep that if he does not comply with the Police, they will kill him. Deep thinks that they are merely kidding and still refuses to help the Police. Khunkar Singh, who is the Commissioner, is angered by the turn of events and shoots Deepak in frustration. When Deep gets to know of this, he completely loses his mind and sets out to avenge his brother’s death. He goes and shoots the Inspector, who fires in retaliation. Diana also appears on the spot and amongst all the shooting, gets injured by a bullet shot by the Inspector. She shoots the Inspector who dies on the spot. Dino also arrives to save his sister and when he sees Deep, he assumes that he was a police man in plain clothes and shot him dead.Q.If the Inspector had shot Deep instead of Deepak, would he be liable for murder?a)No, he would not be guilty as per lawb)Yes, shooting without a cause is an offencec)No, the Inspector was frustrated since no one was giving him informationd)Yes, because Deep was innocentCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of PRINCIPLE 1:If a man murders a woman, he is to be held guilty for murder.PRINCIPLE 2:If a woman murders a man, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 3:If a man murders another man, he is not liable for murder.PRINCIPLE 4:If a woman murders another woman, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 5:If a man murders anyone below the age of 20 years, he is to be held liable for murder.FACTS: Dino is a terrorist and is forever fleeing from the police. His sister, Diana lives away from him, since he is worried for her safety. She studies in a University in Bangalore, and her best friend is Deep falls in love with her. When the Police get to know of Dino’s sister, they try to establish contact with her, so that they can reach Dino through her. They try to ask Diana, but she can’t give any assistance to the Police since she herself does not know of her brother’s whereabouts. The police think that Diana is trying to evade their questions on purpose and decide to use Deep as a means to get her to talk. When Deep gets to know of this, he refuses to help since he loves Diana and does not want her to be harmed in any way. Now the Police are in a dilemma, but they discover that Deep has a younger brother called Deepak. They kidnap Deepak, when he is returning from school, and threaten Deep that if he does not comply with the Police, they will kill him. Deep thinks that they are merely kidding and still refuses to help the Police. Khunkar Singh, who is the Commissioner, is angered by the turn of events and shoots Deepak in frustration. When Deep gets to know of this, he completely loses his mind and sets out to avenge his brother’s death. He goes and shoots the Inspector, who fires in retaliation. Diana also appears on the spot and amongst all the shooting, gets injured by a bullet shot by the Inspector. She shoots the Inspector who dies on the spot. Dino also arrives to save his sister and when he sees Deep, he assumes that he was a police man in plain clothes and shot him dead.Q.If the Inspector had shot Deep instead of Deepak, would he be liable for murder?a)No, he would not be guilty as per lawb)Yes, shooting without a cause is an offencec)No, the Inspector was frustrated since no one was giving him informationd)Yes, because Deep was innocentCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for PRINCIPLE 1:If a man murders a woman, he is to be held guilty for murder.PRINCIPLE 2:If a woman murders a man, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 3:If a man murders another man, he is not liable for murder.PRINCIPLE 4:If a woman murders another woman, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 5:If a man murders anyone below the age of 20 years, he is to be held liable for murder.FACTS: Dino is a terrorist and is forever fleeing from the police. His sister, Diana lives away from him, since he is worried for her safety. She studies in a University in Bangalore, and her best friend is Deep falls in love with her. When the Police get to know of Dino’s sister, they try to establish contact with her, so that they can reach Dino through her. They try to ask Diana, but she can’t give any assistance to the Police since she herself does not know of her brother’s whereabouts. The police think that Diana is trying to evade their questions on purpose and decide to use Deep as a means to get her to talk. When Deep gets to know of this, he refuses to help since he loves Diana and does not want her to be harmed in any way. Now the Police are in a dilemma, but they discover that Deep has a younger brother called Deepak. They kidnap Deepak, when he is returning from school, and threaten Deep that if he does not comply with the Police, they will kill him. Deep thinks that they are merely kidding and still refuses to help the Police. Khunkar Singh, who is the Commissioner, is angered by the turn of events and shoots Deepak in frustration. When Deep gets to know of this, he completely loses his mind and sets out to avenge his brother’s death. He goes and shoots the Inspector, who fires in retaliation. Diana also appears on the spot and amongst all the shooting, gets injured by a bullet shot by the Inspector. She shoots the Inspector who dies on the spot. Dino also arrives to save his sister and when he sees Deep, he assumes that he was a police man in plain clothes and shot him dead.Q.If the Inspector had shot Deep instead of Deepak, would he be liable for murder?a)No, he would not be guilty as per lawb)Yes, shooting without a cause is an offencec)No, the Inspector was frustrated since no one was giving him informationd)Yes, because Deep was innocentCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of PRINCIPLE 1:If a man murders a woman, he is to be held guilty for murder.PRINCIPLE 2:If a woman murders a man, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 3:If a man murders another man, he is not liable for murder.PRINCIPLE 4:If a woman murders another woman, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 5:If a man murders anyone below the age of 20 years, he is to be held liable for murder.FACTS: Dino is a terrorist and is forever fleeing from the police. His sister, Diana lives away from him, since he is worried for her safety. She studies in a University in Bangalore, and her best friend is Deep falls in love with her. When the Police get to know of Dino’s sister, they try to establish contact with her, so that they can reach Dino through her. They try to ask Diana, but she can’t give any assistance to the Police since she herself does not know of her brother’s whereabouts. The police think that Diana is trying to evade their questions on purpose and decide to use Deep as a means to get her to talk. When Deep gets to know of this, he refuses to help since he loves Diana and does not want her to be harmed in any way. Now the Police are in a dilemma, but they discover that Deep has a younger brother called Deepak. They kidnap Deepak, when he is returning from school, and threaten Deep that if he does not comply with the Police, they will kill him. Deep thinks that they are merely kidding and still refuses to help the Police. Khunkar Singh, who is the Commissioner, is angered by the turn of events and shoots Deepak in frustration. When Deep gets to know of this, he completely loses his mind and sets out to avenge his brother’s death. He goes and shoots the Inspector, who fires in retaliation. Diana also appears on the spot and amongst all the shooting, gets injured by a bullet shot by the Inspector. She shoots the Inspector who dies on the spot. Dino also arrives to save his sister and when he sees Deep, he assumes that he was a police man in plain clothes and shot him dead.Q.If the Inspector had shot Deep instead of Deepak, would he be liable for murder?a)No, he would not be guilty as per lawb)Yes, shooting without a cause is an offencec)No, the Inspector was frustrated since no one was giving him informationd)Yes, because Deep was innocentCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice PRINCIPLE 1:If a man murders a woman, he is to be held guilty for murder.PRINCIPLE 2:If a woman murders a man, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 3:If a man murders another man, he is not liable for murder.PRINCIPLE 4:If a woman murders another woman, she is not guilty of murder.PRINCIPLE 5:If a man murders anyone below the age of 20 years, he is to be held liable for murder.FACTS: Dino is a terrorist and is forever fleeing from the police. His sister, Diana lives away from him, since he is worried for her safety. She studies in a University in Bangalore, and her best friend is Deep falls in love with her. When the Police get to know of Dino’s sister, they try to establish contact with her, so that they can reach Dino through her. They try to ask Diana, but she can’t give any assistance to the Police since she herself does not know of her brother’s whereabouts. The police think that Diana is trying to evade their questions on purpose and decide to use Deep as a means to get her to talk. When Deep gets to know of this, he refuses to help since he loves Diana and does not want her to be harmed in any way. Now the Police are in a dilemma, but they discover that Deep has a younger brother called Deepak. They kidnap Deepak, when he is returning from school, and threaten Deep that if he does not comply with the Police, they will kill him. Deep thinks that they are merely kidding and still refuses to help the Police. Khunkar Singh, who is the Commissioner, is angered by the turn of events and shoots Deepak in frustration. When Deep gets to know of this, he completely loses his mind and sets out to avenge his brother’s death. He goes and shoots the Inspector, who fires in retaliation. Diana also appears on the spot and amongst all the shooting, gets injured by a bullet shot by the Inspector. She shoots the Inspector who dies on the spot. Dino also arrives to save his sister and when he sees Deep, he assumes that he was a police man in plain clothes and shot him dead.Q.If the Inspector had shot Deep instead of Deepak, would he be liable for murder?a)No, he would not be guilty as per lawb)Yes, shooting without a cause is an offencec)No, the Inspector was frustrated since no one was giving him informationd)Yes, because Deep was innocentCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice CLAT tests.
Explore Courses for CLAT exam

Top Courses for CLAT

Explore Courses
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev