Discuss the contributions of foreign accounts in the reconstruction of...
The contributions of foreign accounts in the reconstruction of early Indian history:
- Indigenous literature can be supplemented by foreign account. The sources used to reconstruct the history of the Indo-Greeks are few and disparate, leading to much uncertainty about the precise state of the Indo-Greek kingdom and its chronology. Sources related to the Indo-Greeks can be classified into various categories ancient literary sources from both the West and the Indian world, archaeological sources from the general area of Northwestern India, and numismatical sources, which are abundant and well-preserved but often rather cryptic.
- The main Greco-Roman source on the Indo-Greeks is Justin, who in turn wrote, from Greek sources, at the time of Augustus Caesar. Justin tells the parts of Trogus’ history he finds particularly interesting at some length he connects them by short and simplified summaries of the rest of the material. Justin covers periods for which there are other and better sources, he has occasionally made provable mistakes. As Tarn and Develin both point out, Justin is not trying to write history in our sense of the word he is collecting instructive moral anecdotes.The geographer Strabo mentions India a few times in the course of his long dispute with Eratosthenes about the shape of Eurasia.
- Most of these are purely geographical claims, but he does mention that Eratosthenes’ sources say that some of the Greek kings conquered further than Alexander Strabo does not believe them on this, but modern historians do; nor does he believe that Menander and Demetrius son of Euthydemus conquered more tribes than Alexander. There is half a story about Bacteria (only) in one of the books of Polybius which has not come down to us intact. In the 1st century BCE, the geographer Isidorus of Charax mentions Parthians ruling over Greek populations and cities in Arachosia “Beyond is Arachosia. And the Parthians call this White India; there are the city of Biyt and the city of Pharsana and the city of Chorochoad and the city of Demetrias then Alexandropolis, the metropolis of Arachosia it is Greek, and by it flows the river Arachotus. As far as this place the land is under the rule of the Parthians.”According to Strabo, Greek advances temporarily went as far as the Sunga capital Pataliputra (today Patna) in eastern India.
- The 1st century CE Periplus of the Erythraean Sea describes numerous Greek buildings and fortifications in Barigaza, although mistakenly attributing them to Alexander, and testifies to the circulation of Indo-Greek coinage in the region: From ancient authors (Pliny, Arrian, Ptolemy and Strab), a list of provinces, satrapies, or simple regional designations, and Greek cities from within the Indo-Greek Kingdom can be discerned (though others have been lost), ranging from the Indus basin to the upper valley of the Ganges.
This question is part of UPSC exam. View all UPSC courses
Discuss the contributions of foreign accounts in the reconstruction of...
Contributions of Foreign Accounts in the Reconstruction of Early Indian History
Foreign accounts have played a significant role in the reconstruction of early Indian history. These accounts, written by travelers, traders, and historians from different parts of the world, provide valuable insights into various aspects of Indian civilization, culture, and political systems. By studying these foreign accounts, historians have been able to gather information about ancient India that complements and sometimes challenges the existing indigenous sources.
Understanding Ancient Indian Society and Culture
Foreign accounts have helped historians understand the social and cultural aspects of ancient India. Accounts from travelers like Megasthenes, Fa-Hien, and Hiuen Tsang provide detailed descriptions of Indian society, including the caste system, religious practices, and cultural traditions. These accounts have helped in reconstructing the social fabric of ancient India and understanding the interactions between different communities.
Political History and Dynastic Successions
Foreign accounts have also contributed to the reconstruction of political history in ancient India. The accounts of Greek historians like Herodotus and Arrian, as well as Chinese travelers, provide information about the political systems, dynastic successions, and military campaigns in ancient India. For example, the writings of Megasthenes offer insights into the administration of the Mauryan Empire under Chandragupta Maurya and his successors.
Trade and Economic Activities
Foreign accounts have shed light on the trade and economic activities of ancient India. Accounts from Greek and Roman traders provide valuable information about the maritime trade routes, commodities, and economic prosperity of ancient Indian cities like Pataliputra, Taxila, and Ujjain. These accounts have helped in understanding the economic significance of ancient India and its role in the global trade network.
Religious and Philosophical Traditions
Foreign accounts have also contributed to the understanding of religious and philosophical traditions in ancient India. The writings of Chinese travelers like Fa-Hien and Hiuen Tsang provide detailed accounts of Buddhist monasteries, rituals, and philosophical debates. These accounts have enriched the knowledge of Indian philosophy and the spread of Buddhism in different parts of Asia.
Challenges and Limitations
While foreign accounts have greatly contributed to the reconstruction of early Indian history, it is important to note that they also have limitations. These accounts often reflect the biases and perspectives of the authors, and some information may be exaggerated or distorted. Additionally, the language barrier and cultural differences between the authors and the Indian society they encountered could sometimes lead to misinterpretations or misunderstandings.
In conclusion, foreign accounts have been invaluable in the reconstruction of early Indian history. They have provided unique perspectives, enriched our understanding of ancient Indian society, politics, trade, and religion. However, historians must critically evaluate and corroborate these accounts with indigenous sources to ensure a comprehensive and accurate understanding of India's past.
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed UPSC study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in UPSC.