CLAT Exam  >  CLAT Questions  >  Passage - 1Fundamental rights guaranteed by t... Start Learning for Free
Passage - 1
Fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution are, in the absence of specific constitutional provisions, mainly enforceable against "the State". The definition of 'the State' in article 12 being an "inclusive" one, courts have ruled that where there is pervasive or predominant governmental control or significant involvement in its activity, such bodies, entities and organizations fall within the definition of "the State".
Article 14 is one of the most important Articles of the Indian constitution and it is also regarded as part of the golden triangle of the Constitution along with Article 19 and 21 .In India, this right is very important because there has been a widespread socio-economic difference which has been in existence from a long time. People have been discriminated on the basis of their gender or the religion they follow, therefore Article 14 was included in the Constitution to remove such inequalities and bring all the people under the equal protection of the law. Another important point about this Article is that it not only imposes a duty on the State to abstain from discriminating people but it also puts a positive duty to
take such action by which the inequalities can be bridged between the people. Article 19(1)(a) refers to "freedom of speech and expression". Article 21 refers to right to life.
Following Constitutional principles are need to be taken into perspective while dealing with questions:
1. Fundamental rights shall be made applicable only to the legislative or administrative actions of the state and not the private actions.
2. The State includes the Government and Parliament of India and the Government and the Legislature of each of the States and all local or other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India.
3. State means Parliament of India, State Legislatures, Government of India, State Governments and local authorities wherein the Government exercises voting right or right to appoint the management committee.
4. State shall provide and ensure fundamental right to free and compulsory education to all children of the age of six to fourteen years.
5. State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of sex, religion and place of birth.
6. Fundamental right of equality before the law means treating equals equally and unequal's unequally.
7. Any law or administrative action of the state which takes away or abridges fundamental right guaranteed to the citizen, to the extent of contravention, shall be void.
8. Kavita Madhukar, daughter of famous freedom fighter Late Raghu Madhukar, runs a chain of private unaided schools in the State of Madhya Bharat. Madhukar Vidyalaya introduces a new compulsory subject in the curriculum named 'Sex Education and Maternity Care' for all the girls above the age of 11 years. Child rights activist, Veena Dave challenges the new curriculum as violative of fundamental right of compulsory education and discriminates on basis of sex. 
Q. If State of Madhya Bharat enacts legislation granting an option to all the students above the age of eleven years to choose for subject of 'Sex Education and Maternity Care', whether the same can be held in violation of fundamental right?
  • a)
    Yes, as granting an option to students below the age of fourteen years amounts to violation of right of compulsory education.
  • b)
    No, as right to free and compulsory education does not mean compulsorily teaching all the subjects to the students.
  • c)
    No, as right to free and compulsory education is not applicable to the students above the age of fourteen years.
  • d)
    Yes, as allowing access to male children to the course of 'Sex Education and maternity care', which is of no relevance to them, amounts to treating unequal's equally.
Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?
Verified Answer
Passage - 1Fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution are, in t...
The question asks you to apply the idea of the passage to a given situation. You will have to assimilate the inference and look at the facts of the case and evaluate the answer choices. Correct Answer is (b)
Right to free and compulsory education does not bar the State from granting an option to choose a new subject. Further, granting such an option to all students does not violate equality before law.
Incorrect Answers
None of the other options sets out views that are consistent with those of the author in the passage above.
View all questions of this test
Most Upvoted Answer
Passage - 1Fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution are, in t...
The question asks you to apply the idea of the passage to a given situation. You will have to assimilate the inference and look at the facts of the case and evaluate the answer choices. Correct Answer is (b)
Right to free and compulsory education does not bar the State from granting an option to choose a new subject. Further, granting such an option to all students does not violate equality before law.
Incorrect Answers
None of the other options sets out views that are consistent with those of the author in the passage above.
Attention CLAT Students!
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed CLAT study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in CLAT.
Explore Courses for CLAT exam

Top Courses for CLAT

Passage - 1Fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution are, in the absence of specific constitutional provisions, mainly enforceable against "the State". The definition of the State in article 12 being an "inclusive" one, courts have ruled that where there is pervasive or predominant governmental control or significant involvement in its activity, such bodies, entities and organizations fall within the definition of "the State".Article 14 is one of the most important Articles of the Indian constitution and it is also regarded as part of the golden triangle of the Constitution along with Article 19 and 21 .In India, this right is very important because there has been a widespread socio-economic difference which has been in existence from a long time. People have been discriminated on the basis of their gender or the religion they follow, therefore Article 14 was included in the Constitution to remove such inequalities and bring all the people under the equal protection of the law. Another important point about this Article is that it not only imposes a duty on the State to abstain from discriminating people but it also puts a positive duty totake such action by which the inequalities can be bridged between the people. Article 19(1)(a) refers to "freedom of speech and expression". Article 21 refers to right to life.Following Constitutional principles are need to be taken into perspective while dealing with questions:1. Fundamental rights shall be made applicable only to the legislative or administrative actions of the state and not the private actions.2. The State includes the Government and Parliament of India and the Government and the Legislature of each of the States and all local or other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India.3. State means Parliament of India, State Legislatures, Government of India, State Governments and local authorities wherein the Government exercises voting right or right to appoint the management committee.4. State shall provide and ensure fundamental right to free and compulsory education to all children of the age of six to fourteen years.5. State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of sex, religion and place of birth.6. Fundamental right of equality before the law means treating equals equally and unequals unequally.7. Any law or administrative action of the state which takes away or abridges fundamental right guaranteed to the citizen, to the extent of contravention, shall be void.8. Kavita Madhukar, daughter of famous freedom fighter Late Raghu Madhukar, runs a chain of private unaided schools in the State of Madhya Bharat. Madhukar Vidyalaya introduces a new compulsory subject in the curriculum named Sex Education and Maternity Care for all the girls above the age of 11 years. Child rights activist, Veena Dave challenges the new curriculum as violative of fundamental right of compulsory education and discriminates on basis of sex.Q.If State of Madhya Bharat enacts legislation granting an option to all the students above the age of eleven years to choose for subject of Sex Education and Maternity Care, whether the same can be held in violation of fundamental right?a)Yes, as granting an option to students below the age of fourteen years amounts to violation of right of compulsory education.b)No, as right to free and compulsory education does not mean compulsorily teaching all the subjects to the students.c)No, as right to free and compulsory education is not applicable to the students above the age of fourteen years.d)Yes, as allowing access to male children to the course of Sex Education and maternity care, which is of no relevance to them, amounts to treating unequals equally.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?
Question Description
Passage - 1Fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution are, in the absence of specific constitutional provisions, mainly enforceable against "the State". The definition of the State in article 12 being an "inclusive" one, courts have ruled that where there is pervasive or predominant governmental control or significant involvement in its activity, such bodies, entities and organizations fall within the definition of "the State".Article 14 is one of the most important Articles of the Indian constitution and it is also regarded as part of the golden triangle of the Constitution along with Article 19 and 21 .In India, this right is very important because there has been a widespread socio-economic difference which has been in existence from a long time. People have been discriminated on the basis of their gender or the religion they follow, therefore Article 14 was included in the Constitution to remove such inequalities and bring all the people under the equal protection of the law. Another important point about this Article is that it not only imposes a duty on the State to abstain from discriminating people but it also puts a positive duty totake such action by which the inequalities can be bridged between the people. Article 19(1)(a) refers to "freedom of speech and expression". Article 21 refers to right to life.Following Constitutional principles are need to be taken into perspective while dealing with questions:1. Fundamental rights shall be made applicable only to the legislative or administrative actions of the state and not the private actions.2. The State includes the Government and Parliament of India and the Government and the Legislature of each of the States and all local or other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India.3. State means Parliament of India, State Legislatures, Government of India, State Governments and local authorities wherein the Government exercises voting right or right to appoint the management committee.4. State shall provide and ensure fundamental right to free and compulsory education to all children of the age of six to fourteen years.5. State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of sex, religion and place of birth.6. Fundamental right of equality before the law means treating equals equally and unequals unequally.7. Any law or administrative action of the state which takes away or abridges fundamental right guaranteed to the citizen, to the extent of contravention, shall be void.8. Kavita Madhukar, daughter of famous freedom fighter Late Raghu Madhukar, runs a chain of private unaided schools in the State of Madhya Bharat. Madhukar Vidyalaya introduces a new compulsory subject in the curriculum named Sex Education and Maternity Care for all the girls above the age of 11 years. Child rights activist, Veena Dave challenges the new curriculum as violative of fundamental right of compulsory education and discriminates on basis of sex.Q.If State of Madhya Bharat enacts legislation granting an option to all the students above the age of eleven years to choose for subject of Sex Education and Maternity Care, whether the same can be held in violation of fundamental right?a)Yes, as granting an option to students below the age of fourteen years amounts to violation of right of compulsory education.b)No, as right to free and compulsory education does not mean compulsorily teaching all the subjects to the students.c)No, as right to free and compulsory education is not applicable to the students above the age of fourteen years.d)Yes, as allowing access to male children to the course of Sex Education and maternity care, which is of no relevance to them, amounts to treating unequals equally.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? for CLAT 2024 is part of CLAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CLAT exam syllabus. Information about Passage - 1Fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution are, in the absence of specific constitutional provisions, mainly enforceable against "the State". The definition of the State in article 12 being an "inclusive" one, courts have ruled that where there is pervasive or predominant governmental control or significant involvement in its activity, such bodies, entities and organizations fall within the definition of "the State".Article 14 is one of the most important Articles of the Indian constitution and it is also regarded as part of the golden triangle of the Constitution along with Article 19 and 21 .In India, this right is very important because there has been a widespread socio-economic difference which has been in existence from a long time. People have been discriminated on the basis of their gender or the religion they follow, therefore Article 14 was included in the Constitution to remove such inequalities and bring all the people under the equal protection of the law. Another important point about this Article is that it not only imposes a duty on the State to abstain from discriminating people but it also puts a positive duty totake such action by which the inequalities can be bridged between the people. Article 19(1)(a) refers to "freedom of speech and expression". Article 21 refers to right to life.Following Constitutional principles are need to be taken into perspective while dealing with questions:1. Fundamental rights shall be made applicable only to the legislative or administrative actions of the state and not the private actions.2. The State includes the Government and Parliament of India and the Government and the Legislature of each of the States and all local or other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India.3. State means Parliament of India, State Legislatures, Government of India, State Governments and local authorities wherein the Government exercises voting right or right to appoint the management committee.4. State shall provide and ensure fundamental right to free and compulsory education to all children of the age of six to fourteen years.5. State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of sex, religion and place of birth.6. Fundamental right of equality before the law means treating equals equally and unequals unequally.7. Any law or administrative action of the state which takes away or abridges fundamental right guaranteed to the citizen, to the extent of contravention, shall be void.8. Kavita Madhukar, daughter of famous freedom fighter Late Raghu Madhukar, runs a chain of private unaided schools in the State of Madhya Bharat. Madhukar Vidyalaya introduces a new compulsory subject in the curriculum named Sex Education and Maternity Care for all the girls above the age of 11 years. Child rights activist, Veena Dave challenges the new curriculum as violative of fundamental right of compulsory education and discriminates on basis of sex.Q.If State of Madhya Bharat enacts legislation granting an option to all the students above the age of eleven years to choose for subject of Sex Education and Maternity Care, whether the same can be held in violation of fundamental right?a)Yes, as granting an option to students below the age of fourteen years amounts to violation of right of compulsory education.b)No, as right to free and compulsory education does not mean compulsorily teaching all the subjects to the students.c)No, as right to free and compulsory education is not applicable to the students above the age of fourteen years.d)Yes, as allowing access to male children to the course of Sex Education and maternity care, which is of no relevance to them, amounts to treating unequals equally.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for CLAT 2024 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Passage - 1Fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution are, in the absence of specific constitutional provisions, mainly enforceable against "the State". The definition of the State in article 12 being an "inclusive" one, courts have ruled that where there is pervasive or predominant governmental control or significant involvement in its activity, such bodies, entities and organizations fall within the definition of "the State".Article 14 is one of the most important Articles of the Indian constitution and it is also regarded as part of the golden triangle of the Constitution along with Article 19 and 21 .In India, this right is very important because there has been a widespread socio-economic difference which has been in existence from a long time. People have been discriminated on the basis of their gender or the religion they follow, therefore Article 14 was included in the Constitution to remove such inequalities and bring all the people under the equal protection of the law. Another important point about this Article is that it not only imposes a duty on the State to abstain from discriminating people but it also puts a positive duty totake such action by which the inequalities can be bridged between the people. Article 19(1)(a) refers to "freedom of speech and expression". Article 21 refers to right to life.Following Constitutional principles are need to be taken into perspective while dealing with questions:1. Fundamental rights shall be made applicable only to the legislative or administrative actions of the state and not the private actions.2. The State includes the Government and Parliament of India and the Government and the Legislature of each of the States and all local or other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India.3. State means Parliament of India, State Legislatures, Government of India, State Governments and local authorities wherein the Government exercises voting right or right to appoint the management committee.4. State shall provide and ensure fundamental right to free and compulsory education to all children of the age of six to fourteen years.5. State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of sex, religion and place of birth.6. Fundamental right of equality before the law means treating equals equally and unequals unequally.7. Any law or administrative action of the state which takes away or abridges fundamental right guaranteed to the citizen, to the extent of contravention, shall be void.8. Kavita Madhukar, daughter of famous freedom fighter Late Raghu Madhukar, runs a chain of private unaided schools in the State of Madhya Bharat. Madhukar Vidyalaya introduces a new compulsory subject in the curriculum named Sex Education and Maternity Care for all the girls above the age of 11 years. Child rights activist, Veena Dave challenges the new curriculum as violative of fundamental right of compulsory education and discriminates on basis of sex.Q.If State of Madhya Bharat enacts legislation granting an option to all the students above the age of eleven years to choose for subject of Sex Education and Maternity Care, whether the same can be held in violation of fundamental right?a)Yes, as granting an option to students below the age of fourteen years amounts to violation of right of compulsory education.b)No, as right to free and compulsory education does not mean compulsorily teaching all the subjects to the students.c)No, as right to free and compulsory education is not applicable to the students above the age of fourteen years.d)Yes, as allowing access to male children to the course of Sex Education and maternity care, which is of no relevance to them, amounts to treating unequals equally.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for Passage - 1Fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution are, in the absence of specific constitutional provisions, mainly enforceable against "the State". The definition of the State in article 12 being an "inclusive" one, courts have ruled that where there is pervasive or predominant governmental control or significant involvement in its activity, such bodies, entities and organizations fall within the definition of "the State".Article 14 is one of the most important Articles of the Indian constitution and it is also regarded as part of the golden triangle of the Constitution along with Article 19 and 21 .In India, this right is very important because there has been a widespread socio-economic difference which has been in existence from a long time. People have been discriminated on the basis of their gender or the religion they follow, therefore Article 14 was included in the Constitution to remove such inequalities and bring all the people under the equal protection of the law. Another important point about this Article is that it not only imposes a duty on the State to abstain from discriminating people but it also puts a positive duty totake such action by which the inequalities can be bridged between the people. Article 19(1)(a) refers to "freedom of speech and expression". Article 21 refers to right to life.Following Constitutional principles are need to be taken into perspective while dealing with questions:1. Fundamental rights shall be made applicable only to the legislative or administrative actions of the state and not the private actions.2. The State includes the Government and Parliament of India and the Government and the Legislature of each of the States and all local or other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India.3. State means Parliament of India, State Legislatures, Government of India, State Governments and local authorities wherein the Government exercises voting right or right to appoint the management committee.4. State shall provide and ensure fundamental right to free and compulsory education to all children of the age of six to fourteen years.5. State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of sex, religion and place of birth.6. Fundamental right of equality before the law means treating equals equally and unequals unequally.7. Any law or administrative action of the state which takes away or abridges fundamental right guaranteed to the citizen, to the extent of contravention, shall be void.8. Kavita Madhukar, daughter of famous freedom fighter Late Raghu Madhukar, runs a chain of private unaided schools in the State of Madhya Bharat. Madhukar Vidyalaya introduces a new compulsory subject in the curriculum named Sex Education and Maternity Care for all the girls above the age of 11 years. Child rights activist, Veena Dave challenges the new curriculum as violative of fundamental right of compulsory education and discriminates on basis of sex.Q.If State of Madhya Bharat enacts legislation granting an option to all the students above the age of eleven years to choose for subject of Sex Education and Maternity Care, whether the same can be held in violation of fundamental right?a)Yes, as granting an option to students below the age of fourteen years amounts to violation of right of compulsory education.b)No, as right to free and compulsory education does not mean compulsorily teaching all the subjects to the students.c)No, as right to free and compulsory education is not applicable to the students above the age of fourteen years.d)Yes, as allowing access to male children to the course of Sex Education and maternity care, which is of no relevance to them, amounts to treating unequals equally.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for CLAT. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for CLAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of Passage - 1Fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution are, in the absence of specific constitutional provisions, mainly enforceable against "the State". The definition of the State in article 12 being an "inclusive" one, courts have ruled that where there is pervasive or predominant governmental control or significant involvement in its activity, such bodies, entities and organizations fall within the definition of "the State".Article 14 is one of the most important Articles of the Indian constitution and it is also regarded as part of the golden triangle of the Constitution along with Article 19 and 21 .In India, this right is very important because there has been a widespread socio-economic difference which has been in existence from a long time. People have been discriminated on the basis of their gender or the religion they follow, therefore Article 14 was included in the Constitution to remove such inequalities and bring all the people under the equal protection of the law. Another important point about this Article is that it not only imposes a duty on the State to abstain from discriminating people but it also puts a positive duty totake such action by which the inequalities can be bridged between the people. Article 19(1)(a) refers to "freedom of speech and expression". Article 21 refers to right to life.Following Constitutional principles are need to be taken into perspective while dealing with questions:1. Fundamental rights shall be made applicable only to the legislative or administrative actions of the state and not the private actions.2. The State includes the Government and Parliament of India and the Government and the Legislature of each of the States and all local or other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India.3. State means Parliament of India, State Legislatures, Government of India, State Governments and local authorities wherein the Government exercises voting right or right to appoint the management committee.4. State shall provide and ensure fundamental right to free and compulsory education to all children of the age of six to fourteen years.5. State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of sex, religion and place of birth.6. Fundamental right of equality before the law means treating equals equally and unequals unequally.7. Any law or administrative action of the state which takes away or abridges fundamental right guaranteed to the citizen, to the extent of contravention, shall be void.8. Kavita Madhukar, daughter of famous freedom fighter Late Raghu Madhukar, runs a chain of private unaided schools in the State of Madhya Bharat. Madhukar Vidyalaya introduces a new compulsory subject in the curriculum named Sex Education and Maternity Care for all the girls above the age of 11 years. Child rights activist, Veena Dave challenges the new curriculum as violative of fundamental right of compulsory education and discriminates on basis of sex.Q.If State of Madhya Bharat enacts legislation granting an option to all the students above the age of eleven years to choose for subject of Sex Education and Maternity Care, whether the same can be held in violation of fundamental right?a)Yes, as granting an option to students below the age of fourteen years amounts to violation of right of compulsory education.b)No, as right to free and compulsory education does not mean compulsorily teaching all the subjects to the students.c)No, as right to free and compulsory education is not applicable to the students above the age of fourteen years.d)Yes, as allowing access to male children to the course of Sex Education and maternity care, which is of no relevance to them, amounts to treating unequals equally.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of Passage - 1Fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution are, in the absence of specific constitutional provisions, mainly enforceable against "the State". The definition of the State in article 12 being an "inclusive" one, courts have ruled that where there is pervasive or predominant governmental control or significant involvement in its activity, such bodies, entities and organizations fall within the definition of "the State".Article 14 is one of the most important Articles of the Indian constitution and it is also regarded as part of the golden triangle of the Constitution along with Article 19 and 21 .In India, this right is very important because there has been a widespread socio-economic difference which has been in existence from a long time. People have been discriminated on the basis of their gender or the religion they follow, therefore Article 14 was included in the Constitution to remove such inequalities and bring all the people under the equal protection of the law. Another important point about this Article is that it not only imposes a duty on the State to abstain from discriminating people but it also puts a positive duty totake such action by which the inequalities can be bridged between the people. Article 19(1)(a) refers to "freedom of speech and expression". Article 21 refers to right to life.Following Constitutional principles are need to be taken into perspective while dealing with questions:1. Fundamental rights shall be made applicable only to the legislative or administrative actions of the state and not the private actions.2. The State includes the Government and Parliament of India and the Government and the Legislature of each of the States and all local or other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India.3. State means Parliament of India, State Legislatures, Government of India, State Governments and local authorities wherein the Government exercises voting right or right to appoint the management committee.4. State shall provide and ensure fundamental right to free and compulsory education to all children of the age of six to fourteen years.5. State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of sex, religion and place of birth.6. Fundamental right of equality before the law means treating equals equally and unequals unequally.7. Any law or administrative action of the state which takes away or abridges fundamental right guaranteed to the citizen, to the extent of contravention, shall be void.8. Kavita Madhukar, daughter of famous freedom fighter Late Raghu Madhukar, runs a chain of private unaided schools in the State of Madhya Bharat. Madhukar Vidyalaya introduces a new compulsory subject in the curriculum named Sex Education and Maternity Care for all the girls above the age of 11 years. Child rights activist, Veena Dave challenges the new curriculum as violative of fundamental right of compulsory education and discriminates on basis of sex.Q.If State of Madhya Bharat enacts legislation granting an option to all the students above the age of eleven years to choose for subject of Sex Education and Maternity Care, whether the same can be held in violation of fundamental right?a)Yes, as granting an option to students below the age of fourteen years amounts to violation of right of compulsory education.b)No, as right to free and compulsory education does not mean compulsorily teaching all the subjects to the students.c)No, as right to free and compulsory education is not applicable to the students above the age of fourteen years.d)Yes, as allowing access to male children to the course of Sex Education and maternity care, which is of no relevance to them, amounts to treating unequals equally.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for Passage - 1Fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution are, in the absence of specific constitutional provisions, mainly enforceable against "the State". The definition of the State in article 12 being an "inclusive" one, courts have ruled that where there is pervasive or predominant governmental control or significant involvement in its activity, such bodies, entities and organizations fall within the definition of "the State".Article 14 is one of the most important Articles of the Indian constitution and it is also regarded as part of the golden triangle of the Constitution along with Article 19 and 21 .In India, this right is very important because there has been a widespread socio-economic difference which has been in existence from a long time. People have been discriminated on the basis of their gender or the religion they follow, therefore Article 14 was included in the Constitution to remove such inequalities and bring all the people under the equal protection of the law. Another important point about this Article is that it not only imposes a duty on the State to abstain from discriminating people but it also puts a positive duty totake such action by which the inequalities can be bridged between the people. Article 19(1)(a) refers to "freedom of speech and expression". Article 21 refers to right to life.Following Constitutional principles are need to be taken into perspective while dealing with questions:1. Fundamental rights shall be made applicable only to the legislative or administrative actions of the state and not the private actions.2. The State includes the Government and Parliament of India and the Government and the Legislature of each of the States and all local or other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India.3. State means Parliament of India, State Legislatures, Government of India, State Governments and local authorities wherein the Government exercises voting right or right to appoint the management committee.4. State shall provide and ensure fundamental right to free and compulsory education to all children of the age of six to fourteen years.5. State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of sex, religion and place of birth.6. Fundamental right of equality before the law means treating equals equally and unequals unequally.7. Any law or administrative action of the state which takes away or abridges fundamental right guaranteed to the citizen, to the extent of contravention, shall be void.8. Kavita Madhukar, daughter of famous freedom fighter Late Raghu Madhukar, runs a chain of private unaided schools in the State of Madhya Bharat. Madhukar Vidyalaya introduces a new compulsory subject in the curriculum named Sex Education and Maternity Care for all the girls above the age of 11 years. Child rights activist, Veena Dave challenges the new curriculum as violative of fundamental right of compulsory education and discriminates on basis of sex.Q.If State of Madhya Bharat enacts legislation granting an option to all the students above the age of eleven years to choose for subject of Sex Education and Maternity Care, whether the same can be held in violation of fundamental right?a)Yes, as granting an option to students below the age of fourteen years amounts to violation of right of compulsory education.b)No, as right to free and compulsory education does not mean compulsorily teaching all the subjects to the students.c)No, as right to free and compulsory education is not applicable to the students above the age of fourteen years.d)Yes, as allowing access to male children to the course of Sex Education and maternity care, which is of no relevance to them, amounts to treating unequals equally.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of Passage - 1Fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution are, in the absence of specific constitutional provisions, mainly enforceable against "the State". The definition of the State in article 12 being an "inclusive" one, courts have ruled that where there is pervasive or predominant governmental control or significant involvement in its activity, such bodies, entities and organizations fall within the definition of "the State".Article 14 is one of the most important Articles of the Indian constitution and it is also regarded as part of the golden triangle of the Constitution along with Article 19 and 21 .In India, this right is very important because there has been a widespread socio-economic difference which has been in existence from a long time. People have been discriminated on the basis of their gender or the religion they follow, therefore Article 14 was included in the Constitution to remove such inequalities and bring all the people under the equal protection of the law. Another important point about this Article is that it not only imposes a duty on the State to abstain from discriminating people but it also puts a positive duty totake such action by which the inequalities can be bridged between the people. Article 19(1)(a) refers to "freedom of speech and expression". Article 21 refers to right to life.Following Constitutional principles are need to be taken into perspective while dealing with questions:1. Fundamental rights shall be made applicable only to the legislative or administrative actions of the state and not the private actions.2. The State includes the Government and Parliament of India and the Government and the Legislature of each of the States and all local or other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India.3. State means Parliament of India, State Legislatures, Government of India, State Governments and local authorities wherein the Government exercises voting right or right to appoint the management committee.4. State shall provide and ensure fundamental right to free and compulsory education to all children of the age of six to fourteen years.5. State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of sex, religion and place of birth.6. Fundamental right of equality before the law means treating equals equally and unequals unequally.7. Any law or administrative action of the state which takes away or abridges fundamental right guaranteed to the citizen, to the extent of contravention, shall be void.8. Kavita Madhukar, daughter of famous freedom fighter Late Raghu Madhukar, runs a chain of private unaided schools in the State of Madhya Bharat. Madhukar Vidyalaya introduces a new compulsory subject in the curriculum named Sex Education and Maternity Care for all the girls above the age of 11 years. Child rights activist, Veena Dave challenges the new curriculum as violative of fundamental right of compulsory education and discriminates on basis of sex.Q.If State of Madhya Bharat enacts legislation granting an option to all the students above the age of eleven years to choose for subject of Sex Education and Maternity Care, whether the same can be held in violation of fundamental right?a)Yes, as granting an option to students below the age of fourteen years amounts to violation of right of compulsory education.b)No, as right to free and compulsory education does not mean compulsorily teaching all the subjects to the students.c)No, as right to free and compulsory education is not applicable to the students above the age of fourteen years.d)Yes, as allowing access to male children to the course of Sex Education and maternity care, which is of no relevance to them, amounts to treating unequals equally.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice Passage - 1Fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution are, in the absence of specific constitutional provisions, mainly enforceable against "the State". The definition of the State in article 12 being an "inclusive" one, courts have ruled that where there is pervasive or predominant governmental control or significant involvement in its activity, such bodies, entities and organizations fall within the definition of "the State".Article 14 is one of the most important Articles of the Indian constitution and it is also regarded as part of the golden triangle of the Constitution along with Article 19 and 21 .In India, this right is very important because there has been a widespread socio-economic difference which has been in existence from a long time. People have been discriminated on the basis of their gender or the religion they follow, therefore Article 14 was included in the Constitution to remove such inequalities and bring all the people under the equal protection of the law. Another important point about this Article is that it not only imposes a duty on the State to abstain from discriminating people but it also puts a positive duty totake such action by which the inequalities can be bridged between the people. Article 19(1)(a) refers to "freedom of speech and expression". Article 21 refers to right to life.Following Constitutional principles are need to be taken into perspective while dealing with questions:1. Fundamental rights shall be made applicable only to the legislative or administrative actions of the state and not the private actions.2. The State includes the Government and Parliament of India and the Government and the Legislature of each of the States and all local or other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India.3. State means Parliament of India, State Legislatures, Government of India, State Governments and local authorities wherein the Government exercises voting right or right to appoint the management committee.4. State shall provide and ensure fundamental right to free and compulsory education to all children of the age of six to fourteen years.5. State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of sex, religion and place of birth.6. Fundamental right of equality before the law means treating equals equally and unequals unequally.7. Any law or administrative action of the state which takes away or abridges fundamental right guaranteed to the citizen, to the extent of contravention, shall be void.8. Kavita Madhukar, daughter of famous freedom fighter Late Raghu Madhukar, runs a chain of private unaided schools in the State of Madhya Bharat. Madhukar Vidyalaya introduces a new compulsory subject in the curriculum named Sex Education and Maternity Care for all the girls above the age of 11 years. Child rights activist, Veena Dave challenges the new curriculum as violative of fundamental right of compulsory education and discriminates on basis of sex.Q.If State of Madhya Bharat enacts legislation granting an option to all the students above the age of eleven years to choose for subject of Sex Education and Maternity Care, whether the same can be held in violation of fundamental right?a)Yes, as granting an option to students below the age of fourteen years amounts to violation of right of compulsory education.b)No, as right to free and compulsory education does not mean compulsorily teaching all the subjects to the students.c)No, as right to free and compulsory education is not applicable to the students above the age of fourteen years.d)Yes, as allowing access to male children to the course of Sex Education and maternity care, which is of no relevance to them, amounts to treating unequals equally.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice CLAT tests.
Explore Courses for CLAT exam

Top Courses for CLAT

Explore Courses
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev