GMAT Exam  >  GMAT Questions  >  Some philosophers explain visual perception b... Start Learning for Free
Some philosophers explain visual perception by suggestion that when we visually perceive an object, a mental image of that object forms in our mind. However, this hypothesis cannot be correct, since it would require an inner self visually perceiving the newly formed mental image; this would in turn require that he inner self have a mental image of that mental image and so on. But such an infinite regress is absurd.

Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its pattern of reasoning to the argument above?
  • a)
    According to some linguists, many of the world's languages can be tracked back to a common source known as indo-European. However, Indo-European cannot be the earliest language for if it were, then there would be no language from which it was derived. But this is highly unlikely, given the overwhelming evidence that humans spoke long before the advent of Indo-European.
  • b)
    The claim that any scientific theory is adequate as long as it agrees with all the empirical data cannot be correct For there are an infinite number of theories all of which account equally well for the empirical data, and they cannot all be true at the same time.
  • c)
    Some historians claim that no theory is ever genuinely new; no matter how clever a theory is, there is always a precedent theory that contains its gist. But if this were true, then every theory would have a precedent theory contains its gist, and this precedent theory would have a precedent theory, and so on, without end. Since this is clearly impossible, the historians' claim must be false.
  • d)
    Some engineers define a structure's foundation as that part of the structure that supports the rest of the structure. This definition is unfortunate, however, because it evokes the suggestion that the foundation itself does not have any support, which, of course, is absurd.
  • e)
    Some people claim that the first library was the library of Alexandria, which for many centuries contained the largest collection of books in the world. However, Alexandria's collection was itself put together from smaller collections, small libraries in themselves. It follows that the library of Alexandria was not the first in the world.
Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?
Verified Answer
Some philosophers explain visual perception by suggestion that when we...
(A) According to some linguists, many of the world's languages can be tracked back to a common source known as Indo-European. However, Indo-European cannot be the earliest language for if it were, then there would be no language from which it was derived. But this is highly unlikely, given the overwhelming evidence that humans spoke long before the advent of Indo-European. This argument does not follow the same pattern of reasoning as the given argument. It presents a counter-argument based on the premise that if Indo-European were the earliest language, there would be no language from which it was derived. It does not involve an infinite regress.
(B) The claim that any scientific theory is adequate as long as it agrees with all the empirical data cannot be correct. For there are an infinite number of theories all of which account equally well for the empirical data, and they cannot all be true at the same time. This argument follows a similar pattern of reasoning. It claims that the given claim is incorrect because it would lead to a problem with an infinite number of theories, which cannot all be true at the same time. It involves an infinite regress-like problem, similar to the given argument.
(C) Some historians claim that no theory is ever genuinely new; no matter how clever a theory is, there is always a precedent theory that contains its gist. But if this were true, then every theory would have a precedent theory that contains its gist, and this precedent theory would have a precedent theory, and so on, without end. Since this is clearly impossible, the historians' claim must be false. This argument follows a similar pattern of reasoning. It argues against the historians' claim by pointing out that it would lead to an infinite regress, which is deemed impossible. It involves the same type of reasoning as the given argument.
(D) Some engineers define a structure's foundation as that part of the structure that supports the rest of the structure. This definition is unfortunate, however, because it evokes the suggestion that the foundation itself does not have any support, which, of course, is absurd. This argument does not follow the same pattern of reasoning. It presents a definition and claims that it evokes an absurd suggestion, without involving an infinite regress.
(E) Some people claim that the first library was the library of Alexandria, which for many centuries contained the largest collection of books in the world. However, Alexandria's collection was itself put together from smaller collections, small libraries in themselves. It follows that the library of Alexandria was not the first in the world. This argument does not follow the same pattern of reasoning. It presents evidence that challenges the claim about the first library by pointing out that Alexandria's collection was compiled from smaller collections. It does not involve an infinite regress.
Based on the evaluation, the argument that is most similar in its pattern of reasoning to the given argument is (C) Some historians claim that no theory is ever genuinely new; no matter how clever a theory is, there is always a precedent theory that contains its gist. But if this were true, then every theory would have a precedent theory that contains its gist, and this precedent theory would have a precedent theory, and so on, without end. Since this is clearly impossible, the historians' claim must be false.
View all questions of this test
Most Upvoted Answer
Some philosophers explain visual perception by suggestion that when we...
(A) According to some linguists, many of the world's languages can be tracked back to a common source known as Indo-European. However, Indo-European cannot be the earliest language for if it were, then there would be no language from which it was derived. But this is highly unlikely, given the overwhelming evidence that humans spoke long before the advent of Indo-European. This argument does not follow the same pattern of reasoning as the given argument. It presents a counter-argument based on the premise that if Indo-European were the earliest language, there would be no language from which it was derived. It does not involve an infinite regress.
(B) The claim that any scientific theory is adequate as long as it agrees with all the empirical data cannot be correct. For there are an infinite number of theories all of which account equally well for the empirical data, and they cannot all be true at the same time. This argument follows a similar pattern of reasoning. It claims that the given claim is incorrect because it would lead to a problem with an infinite number of theories, which cannot all be true at the same time. It involves an infinite regress-like problem, similar to the given argument.
(C) Some historians claim that no theory is ever genuinely new; no matter how clever a theory is, there is always a precedent theory that contains its gist. But if this were true, then every theory would have a precedent theory that contains its gist, and this precedent theory would have a precedent theory, and so on, without end. Since this is clearly impossible, the historians' claim must be false. This argument follows a similar pattern of reasoning. It argues against the historians' claim by pointing out that it would lead to an infinite regress, which is deemed impossible. It involves the same type of reasoning as the given argument.
(D) Some engineers define a structure's foundation as that part of the structure that supports the rest of the structure. This definition is unfortunate, however, because it evokes the suggestion that the foundation itself does not have any support, which, of course, is absurd. This argument does not follow the same pattern of reasoning. It presents a definition and claims that it evokes an absurd suggestion, without involving an infinite regress.
(E) Some people claim that the first library was the library of Alexandria, which for many centuries contained the largest collection of books in the world. However, Alexandria's collection was itself put together from smaller collections, small libraries in themselves. It follows that the library of Alexandria was not the first in the world. This argument does not follow the same pattern of reasoning. It presents evidence that challenges the claim about the first library by pointing out that Alexandria's collection was compiled from smaller collections. It does not involve an infinite regress.
Based on the evaluation, the argument that is most similar in its pattern of reasoning to the given argument is (C) Some historians claim that no theory is ever genuinely new; no matter how clever a theory is, there is always a precedent theory that contains its gist. But if this were true, then every theory would have a precedent theory that contains its gist, and this precedent theory would have a precedent theory, and so on, without end. Since this is clearly impossible, the historians' claim must be false.
Explore Courses for GMAT exam

Similar GMAT Doubts

Window 1: Appraisal LetterDear Mr. and Mrs. Brown:We again want to thank you for choosing to work with the experts at Coin and Gem to settle your mother’s estate. After careful review of the coin collection in question, we found a total of 187 coins. Each coin has been appraised, packaged, and marked according to its grade.Each coin was ranked on a scale of 1 to 70 according to the Sheldon Scale of coin grading. We estimate the total value of the collection to be about $27,000. Most of the value resides in a few very rare American coins, which are in mint condition.We would be happy to further assist you in deciding how to handle this aspect of your mother’s estate. Please contact us with any questions or concerns you may have.Attached is a detailed appraisal that inventories each coin, its condition, and its value.Sincerely yours,Charles Barker, Owner and Appraisal ExpertCoin and GemWindow 2: Inventory Appraisal: Very Fine and Mint PiecesWindow 3: Letter of RecommendationDear Mr. and Mrs. Brown:We highly recommend that the Extremely Fine and Mint pieces valued more than $350.00 each be sold at auction, with a reserve price that falls only slightly below their appraised value. Collectors will pay dearly for rare pieces in mint condition, especially if they will complete a collection.The remaining pieces of high value, 80 coins valued at $100.00 to $300.00 each, should be handled by a broker and sold individually. We would be more than willing to handle the sale of these pieces, at a commission of 2.7%.Finally, I recommend that the coins you have many of—like the wheat penny, which have a relatively low sale value—be sold off in lots. You will receive more for these coins from a prospector who wants to look through the lot for a specific coin of value than you would by selling them individually.Let us know of any way we can assist you in this matter.Sincerely,Charles Barker, Owner and Appraisal ExpertCoin and GemQ: Consider each of the following statements. Does the information in the three sources support the inference as stated?

Top Courses for GMAT

Some philosophers explain visual perception by suggestion that when we visually perceive an object, a mental image of that object forms in our mind. However, this hypothesis cannot be correct, since it would require an inner self visually perceiving the newly formed mental image; this would in turn require that he inner self have a mental image of that mental image and so on. But such an infinite regress is absurd.Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its pattern of reasoning to the argument above?a)According to some linguists, many of the worlds languages can be tracked back to a common source known as indo-European. However, Indo-European cannot be the earliest language for if it were, then there would be no language from which it was derived. But this is highly unlikely, given the overwhelming evidence that humans spoke long before the advent of Indo-European.b)The claim that any scientific theory is adequate as long as it agrees with all the empirical data cannot be correct For there are an infinite number of theories all of which account equally well for the empirical data, and they cannot all be true at the same time.c)Some historians claim that no theory is ever genuinely new; no matter how clever a theory is, there is always a precedent theory that contains its gist. But if this were true, then every theory would have a precedent theory contains its gist, and this precedent theory would have a precedent theory, and so on, without end. Since this is clearly impossible, the historians claim must be false.d)Some engineers define a structures foundation as that part of the structure that supports the rest of the structure. This definition is unfortunate, however, because it evokes the suggestion that the foundation itself does not have any support, which, of course, is absurd.e)Some people claim that the first library was the library of Alexandria, which for many centuries contained the largest collection of books in the world. However, Alexandrias collection was itself put together from smaller collections, small libraries in themselves. It follows that the library of Alexandria was not the first in the world.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?
Question Description
Some philosophers explain visual perception by suggestion that when we visually perceive an object, a mental image of that object forms in our mind. However, this hypothesis cannot be correct, since it would require an inner self visually perceiving the newly formed mental image; this would in turn require that he inner self have a mental image of that mental image and so on. But such an infinite regress is absurd.Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its pattern of reasoning to the argument above?a)According to some linguists, many of the worlds languages can be tracked back to a common source known as indo-European. However, Indo-European cannot be the earliest language for if it were, then there would be no language from which it was derived. But this is highly unlikely, given the overwhelming evidence that humans spoke long before the advent of Indo-European.b)The claim that any scientific theory is adequate as long as it agrees with all the empirical data cannot be correct For there are an infinite number of theories all of which account equally well for the empirical data, and they cannot all be true at the same time.c)Some historians claim that no theory is ever genuinely new; no matter how clever a theory is, there is always a precedent theory that contains its gist. But if this were true, then every theory would have a precedent theory contains its gist, and this precedent theory would have a precedent theory, and so on, without end. Since this is clearly impossible, the historians claim must be false.d)Some engineers define a structures foundation as that part of the structure that supports the rest of the structure. This definition is unfortunate, however, because it evokes the suggestion that the foundation itself does not have any support, which, of course, is absurd.e)Some people claim that the first library was the library of Alexandria, which for many centuries contained the largest collection of books in the world. However, Alexandrias collection was itself put together from smaller collections, small libraries in themselves. It follows that the library of Alexandria was not the first in the world.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? for GMAT 2025 is part of GMAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the GMAT exam syllabus. Information about Some philosophers explain visual perception by suggestion that when we visually perceive an object, a mental image of that object forms in our mind. However, this hypothesis cannot be correct, since it would require an inner self visually perceiving the newly formed mental image; this would in turn require that he inner self have a mental image of that mental image and so on. But such an infinite regress is absurd.Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its pattern of reasoning to the argument above?a)According to some linguists, many of the worlds languages can be tracked back to a common source known as indo-European. However, Indo-European cannot be the earliest language for if it were, then there would be no language from which it was derived. But this is highly unlikely, given the overwhelming evidence that humans spoke long before the advent of Indo-European.b)The claim that any scientific theory is adequate as long as it agrees with all the empirical data cannot be correct For there are an infinite number of theories all of which account equally well for the empirical data, and they cannot all be true at the same time.c)Some historians claim that no theory is ever genuinely new; no matter how clever a theory is, there is always a precedent theory that contains its gist. But if this were true, then every theory would have a precedent theory contains its gist, and this precedent theory would have a precedent theory, and so on, without end. Since this is clearly impossible, the historians claim must be false.d)Some engineers define a structures foundation as that part of the structure that supports the rest of the structure. This definition is unfortunate, however, because it evokes the suggestion that the foundation itself does not have any support, which, of course, is absurd.e)Some people claim that the first library was the library of Alexandria, which for many centuries contained the largest collection of books in the world. However, Alexandrias collection was itself put together from smaller collections, small libraries in themselves. It follows that the library of Alexandria was not the first in the world.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for GMAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Some philosophers explain visual perception by suggestion that when we visually perceive an object, a mental image of that object forms in our mind. However, this hypothesis cannot be correct, since it would require an inner self visually perceiving the newly formed mental image; this would in turn require that he inner self have a mental image of that mental image and so on. But such an infinite regress is absurd.Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its pattern of reasoning to the argument above?a)According to some linguists, many of the worlds languages can be tracked back to a common source known as indo-European. However, Indo-European cannot be the earliest language for if it were, then there would be no language from which it was derived. But this is highly unlikely, given the overwhelming evidence that humans spoke long before the advent of Indo-European.b)The claim that any scientific theory is adequate as long as it agrees with all the empirical data cannot be correct For there are an infinite number of theories all of which account equally well for the empirical data, and they cannot all be true at the same time.c)Some historians claim that no theory is ever genuinely new; no matter how clever a theory is, there is always a precedent theory that contains its gist. But if this were true, then every theory would have a precedent theory contains its gist, and this precedent theory would have a precedent theory, and so on, without end. Since this is clearly impossible, the historians claim must be false.d)Some engineers define a structures foundation as that part of the structure that supports the rest of the structure. This definition is unfortunate, however, because it evokes the suggestion that the foundation itself does not have any support, which, of course, is absurd.e)Some people claim that the first library was the library of Alexandria, which for many centuries contained the largest collection of books in the world. However, Alexandrias collection was itself put together from smaller collections, small libraries in themselves. It follows that the library of Alexandria was not the first in the world.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for Some philosophers explain visual perception by suggestion that when we visually perceive an object, a mental image of that object forms in our mind. However, this hypothesis cannot be correct, since it would require an inner self visually perceiving the newly formed mental image; this would in turn require that he inner self have a mental image of that mental image and so on. But such an infinite regress is absurd.Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its pattern of reasoning to the argument above?a)According to some linguists, many of the worlds languages can be tracked back to a common source known as indo-European. However, Indo-European cannot be the earliest language for if it were, then there would be no language from which it was derived. But this is highly unlikely, given the overwhelming evidence that humans spoke long before the advent of Indo-European.b)The claim that any scientific theory is adequate as long as it agrees with all the empirical data cannot be correct For there are an infinite number of theories all of which account equally well for the empirical data, and they cannot all be true at the same time.c)Some historians claim that no theory is ever genuinely new; no matter how clever a theory is, there is always a precedent theory that contains its gist. But if this were true, then every theory would have a precedent theory contains its gist, and this precedent theory would have a precedent theory, and so on, without end. Since this is clearly impossible, the historians claim must be false.d)Some engineers define a structures foundation as that part of the structure that supports the rest of the structure. This definition is unfortunate, however, because it evokes the suggestion that the foundation itself does not have any support, which, of course, is absurd.e)Some people claim that the first library was the library of Alexandria, which for many centuries contained the largest collection of books in the world. However, Alexandrias collection was itself put together from smaller collections, small libraries in themselves. It follows that the library of Alexandria was not the first in the world.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for GMAT. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for GMAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of Some philosophers explain visual perception by suggestion that when we visually perceive an object, a mental image of that object forms in our mind. However, this hypothesis cannot be correct, since it would require an inner self visually perceiving the newly formed mental image; this would in turn require that he inner self have a mental image of that mental image and so on. But such an infinite regress is absurd.Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its pattern of reasoning to the argument above?a)According to some linguists, many of the worlds languages can be tracked back to a common source known as indo-European. However, Indo-European cannot be the earliest language for if it were, then there would be no language from which it was derived. But this is highly unlikely, given the overwhelming evidence that humans spoke long before the advent of Indo-European.b)The claim that any scientific theory is adequate as long as it agrees with all the empirical data cannot be correct For there are an infinite number of theories all of which account equally well for the empirical data, and they cannot all be true at the same time.c)Some historians claim that no theory is ever genuinely new; no matter how clever a theory is, there is always a precedent theory that contains its gist. But if this were true, then every theory would have a precedent theory contains its gist, and this precedent theory would have a precedent theory, and so on, without end. Since this is clearly impossible, the historians claim must be false.d)Some engineers define a structures foundation as that part of the structure that supports the rest of the structure. This definition is unfortunate, however, because it evokes the suggestion that the foundation itself does not have any support, which, of course, is absurd.e)Some people claim that the first library was the library of Alexandria, which for many centuries contained the largest collection of books in the world. However, Alexandrias collection was itself put together from smaller collections, small libraries in themselves. It follows that the library of Alexandria was not the first in the world.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of Some philosophers explain visual perception by suggestion that when we visually perceive an object, a mental image of that object forms in our mind. However, this hypothesis cannot be correct, since it would require an inner self visually perceiving the newly formed mental image; this would in turn require that he inner self have a mental image of that mental image and so on. But such an infinite regress is absurd.Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its pattern of reasoning to the argument above?a)According to some linguists, many of the worlds languages can be tracked back to a common source known as indo-European. However, Indo-European cannot be the earliest language for if it were, then there would be no language from which it was derived. But this is highly unlikely, given the overwhelming evidence that humans spoke long before the advent of Indo-European.b)The claim that any scientific theory is adequate as long as it agrees with all the empirical data cannot be correct For there are an infinite number of theories all of which account equally well for the empirical data, and they cannot all be true at the same time.c)Some historians claim that no theory is ever genuinely new; no matter how clever a theory is, there is always a precedent theory that contains its gist. But if this were true, then every theory would have a precedent theory contains its gist, and this precedent theory would have a precedent theory, and so on, without end. Since this is clearly impossible, the historians claim must be false.d)Some engineers define a structures foundation as that part of the structure that supports the rest of the structure. This definition is unfortunate, however, because it evokes the suggestion that the foundation itself does not have any support, which, of course, is absurd.e)Some people claim that the first library was the library of Alexandria, which for many centuries contained the largest collection of books in the world. However, Alexandrias collection was itself put together from smaller collections, small libraries in themselves. It follows that the library of Alexandria was not the first in the world.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for Some philosophers explain visual perception by suggestion that when we visually perceive an object, a mental image of that object forms in our mind. However, this hypothesis cannot be correct, since it would require an inner self visually perceiving the newly formed mental image; this would in turn require that he inner self have a mental image of that mental image and so on. But such an infinite regress is absurd.Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its pattern of reasoning to the argument above?a)According to some linguists, many of the worlds languages can be tracked back to a common source known as indo-European. However, Indo-European cannot be the earliest language for if it were, then there would be no language from which it was derived. But this is highly unlikely, given the overwhelming evidence that humans spoke long before the advent of Indo-European.b)The claim that any scientific theory is adequate as long as it agrees with all the empirical data cannot be correct For there are an infinite number of theories all of which account equally well for the empirical data, and they cannot all be true at the same time.c)Some historians claim that no theory is ever genuinely new; no matter how clever a theory is, there is always a precedent theory that contains its gist. But if this were true, then every theory would have a precedent theory contains its gist, and this precedent theory would have a precedent theory, and so on, without end. Since this is clearly impossible, the historians claim must be false.d)Some engineers define a structures foundation as that part of the structure that supports the rest of the structure. This definition is unfortunate, however, because it evokes the suggestion that the foundation itself does not have any support, which, of course, is absurd.e)Some people claim that the first library was the library of Alexandria, which for many centuries contained the largest collection of books in the world. However, Alexandrias collection was itself put together from smaller collections, small libraries in themselves. It follows that the library of Alexandria was not the first in the world.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of Some philosophers explain visual perception by suggestion that when we visually perceive an object, a mental image of that object forms in our mind. However, this hypothesis cannot be correct, since it would require an inner self visually perceiving the newly formed mental image; this would in turn require that he inner self have a mental image of that mental image and so on. But such an infinite regress is absurd.Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its pattern of reasoning to the argument above?a)According to some linguists, many of the worlds languages can be tracked back to a common source known as indo-European. However, Indo-European cannot be the earliest language for if it were, then there would be no language from which it was derived. But this is highly unlikely, given the overwhelming evidence that humans spoke long before the advent of Indo-European.b)The claim that any scientific theory is adequate as long as it agrees with all the empirical data cannot be correct For there are an infinite number of theories all of which account equally well for the empirical data, and they cannot all be true at the same time.c)Some historians claim that no theory is ever genuinely new; no matter how clever a theory is, there is always a precedent theory that contains its gist. But if this were true, then every theory would have a precedent theory contains its gist, and this precedent theory would have a precedent theory, and so on, without end. Since this is clearly impossible, the historians claim must be false.d)Some engineers define a structures foundation as that part of the structure that supports the rest of the structure. This definition is unfortunate, however, because it evokes the suggestion that the foundation itself does not have any support, which, of course, is absurd.e)Some people claim that the first library was the library of Alexandria, which for many centuries contained the largest collection of books in the world. However, Alexandrias collection was itself put together from smaller collections, small libraries in themselves. It follows that the library of Alexandria was not the first in the world.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice Some philosophers explain visual perception by suggestion that when we visually perceive an object, a mental image of that object forms in our mind. However, this hypothesis cannot be correct, since it would require an inner self visually perceiving the newly formed mental image; this would in turn require that he inner self have a mental image of that mental image and so on. But such an infinite regress is absurd.Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its pattern of reasoning to the argument above?a)According to some linguists, many of the worlds languages can be tracked back to a common source known as indo-European. However, Indo-European cannot be the earliest language for if it were, then there would be no language from which it was derived. But this is highly unlikely, given the overwhelming evidence that humans spoke long before the advent of Indo-European.b)The claim that any scientific theory is adequate as long as it agrees with all the empirical data cannot be correct For there are an infinite number of theories all of which account equally well for the empirical data, and they cannot all be true at the same time.c)Some historians claim that no theory is ever genuinely new; no matter how clever a theory is, there is always a precedent theory that contains its gist. But if this were true, then every theory would have a precedent theory contains its gist, and this precedent theory would have a precedent theory, and so on, without end. Since this is clearly impossible, the historians claim must be false.d)Some engineers define a structures foundation as that part of the structure that supports the rest of the structure. This definition is unfortunate, however, because it evokes the suggestion that the foundation itself does not have any support, which, of course, is absurd.e)Some people claim that the first library was the library of Alexandria, which for many centuries contained the largest collection of books in the world. However, Alexandrias collection was itself put together from smaller collections, small libraries in themselves. It follows that the library of Alexandria was not the first in the world.Correct answer is option 'C'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice GMAT tests.
Explore Courses for GMAT exam

Top Courses for GMAT

Explore Courses
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev