Can I include international case laws or judgments in the answers for ...
Introduction:
The UPSC Law Optional Subject Exam is a highly competitive examination conducted by the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) for candidates aspiring to become civil servants in India. One of the optional subjects for this exam is Law, which covers various legal topics and concepts. While the primary focus of the exam is on Indian laws and legal principles, including international case laws or judgments in the answers can provide a broader perspective and enhance the quality of the response.
Benefits of including international case laws or judgments:
Including international case laws or judgments in the answers for the UPSC Law Optional Subject Exam can have several benefits:
1. Global Perspective: International case laws or judgments provide a global perspective on legal issues and showcase the diverse approaches taken by different jurisdictions. This can help candidates understand the nuances and complexities of legal principles beyond the Indian context.
2. Comparative Analysis: By including international case laws or judgments, candidates can compare and contrast the legal principles and interpretations followed in different countries. This comparative analysis can enrich their understanding of the subject and enable them to provide more comprehensive and balanced answers.
3. Legal Precedence: International case laws or judgments can serve as persuasive authorities in Indian courts. Therefore, familiarity with relevant international precedents can strengthen the arguments presented in the answers and showcase a deeper understanding of the subject.
4. Recognition of Global Legal Standards: International case laws or judgments often reflect the recognition and implementation of global legal standards and principles. By including these in their answers, candidates can demonstrate their awareness of international legal frameworks and their commitment to upholding universally accepted norms.
Important Considerations:
While including international case laws or judgments in the answers, candidates should keep the following considerations in mind:
1. Relevance: The international case laws or judgments should be directly related to the topic or issue being discussed. Including irrelevant or tangential references may dilute the quality of the answer.
2. Accuracy: Candidates should ensure that the international case laws or judgments cited are accurate and correctly interpreted. Misquoting or misrepresenting foreign judgments can undermine the credibility of the response.
3. Supporting Indian Laws: While international case laws or judgments can provide valuable insights, it is essential to prioritize the application and understanding of Indian laws. Candidates should demonstrate a strong grasp of Indian legal principles and use international references to supplement their arguments rather than overshadowing them.
Conclusion:
Incorporating international case laws or judgments in the answers for the UPSC Law Optional Subject Exam can enhance the quality and depth of the responses. It provides a global perspective, allows for comparative analysis, showcases familiarity with legal precedents, and recognizes global legal standards. However, candidates should exercise caution and ensure that the references are relevant, accurate, and supportive of Indian legal principles.
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed UPSC study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in UPSC.