CLAT Exam > CLAT Questions > Directions: Read the following passage and an...
Start Learning for Free
Directions: Read the following passage and answer the question.
"Did you continue firing?"
"Yes," replied the general.
There was an audible gasp that echoed through this crowded room in response to that single word. His Lordship waited for silence to be restored, sitting with eyes lowered, hands clasped tightly on the long table that separated the Committee from everyone else. The folds of his black robe pinched against the table's edge as he hunched forward, leaning heavily on his elbows, asking in a voice strained thin by incredulity:
"If the crowd was going to disperse, why did you not stop firing?"
"I thought it my duty to go on firing until it dispersed. If I fired a little, the effect would not be sufficient. If I had fired a little I should be wrong in firing at all."
"What reason had you to suppose that if you had ordered the assembly to leave the Bagh they would not have done so without the necessity of your firing, continued firing for a length of time?"
"Yes, I think it is quite possible that I could have dispersed them perhaps even without firing."
"Why did you not adopt that course" His Lordship asked, shaking his head, more in wonder than horror, as he asked the question.
"I could not disperse them for some time," the General answered, speaking slowly, sounding distracted as he stared over the heads of the judges, "then they would all come back and laugh at me, and I considered I would be making myself a fool."
A wave of startled comment greeted this remark, and the clamour became so loud that His Lordship was obliged to rap his gavel before continuing his interrogation.
"You know that the casualties were something between four hundred and five hundred."
"Yes I have seen it in the papers. I divided all my rounds by five--" He paused and touched his fingertips to his lips, staring vacantly at the ceiling, mumbling, "I am in doubt whether by five or six--to arrive at the number."
"I understood that the shooting that took place was individual shooting, and it was not volley shooting?"
"No, there was no volley shooting."
"The crowd was very dense?"
"It was very dense."
"It was unlikely that a man shooting into the crowd will miss?"
"No, according to the circumstances of the case," the General replied, shaking his head, sounding bewildered. "They were running, and I noticed only a certain number of men were hit. In the centre of the section, the crowd was very dense and therefore if a man directed his fire well he should not miss."
[This is an extract from Stanley Wolpert's fictionalised account entitled Massacre at Jallianwala Bagh, published by Penguin Books India, 1988. The extract is from a section entitled Lahore: November 19, 1919 and deals with the Committee of Inquiry into the Amritsar massacre which condemned the conduct of General Reginald Dyer.]
"Yes," replied the general.
There was an audible gasp that echoed through this crowded room in response to that single word. His Lordship waited for silence to be restored, sitting with eyes lowered, hands clasped tightly on the long table that separated the Committee from everyone else. The folds of his black robe pinched against the table's edge as he hunched forward, leaning heavily on his elbows, asking in a voice strained thin by incredulity:
"If the crowd was going to disperse, why did you not stop firing?"
"I thought it my duty to go on firing until it dispersed. If I fired a little, the effect would not be sufficient. If I had fired a little I should be wrong in firing at all."
"What reason had you to suppose that if you had ordered the assembly to leave the Bagh they would not have done so without the necessity of your firing, continued firing for a length of time?"
"Yes, I think it is quite possible that I could have dispersed them perhaps even without firing."
"Why did you not adopt that course" His Lordship asked, shaking his head, more in wonder than horror, as he asked the question.
"I could not disperse them for some time," the General answered, speaking slowly, sounding distracted as he stared over the heads of the judges, "then they would all come back and laugh at me, and I considered I would be making myself a fool."
A wave of startled comment greeted this remark, and the clamour became so loud that His Lordship was obliged to rap his gavel before continuing his interrogation.
"You know that the casualties were something between four hundred and five hundred."
"Yes I have seen it in the papers. I divided all my rounds by five--" He paused and touched his fingertips to his lips, staring vacantly at the ceiling, mumbling, "I am in doubt whether by five or six--to arrive at the number."
"I understood that the shooting that took place was individual shooting, and it was not volley shooting?"
"No, there was no volley shooting."
"The crowd was very dense?"
"It was very dense."
"It was unlikely that a man shooting into the crowd will miss?"
"No, according to the circumstances of the case," the General replied, shaking his head, sounding bewildered. "They were running, and I noticed only a certain number of men were hit. In the centre of the section, the crowd was very dense and therefore if a man directed his fire well he should not miss."
[This is an extract from Stanley Wolpert's fictionalised account entitled Massacre at Jallianwala Bagh, published by Penguin Books India, 1988. The extract is from a section entitled Lahore: November 19, 1919 and deals with the Committee of Inquiry into the Amritsar massacre which condemned the conduct of General Reginald Dyer.]
Q. Based on the information in the passage, why did the general think it was his responsibility to persist in firing?
- a)Because refraining from firing would have led to the crowd dispersing as desired.
- b)Because he believed that only a substantial level of force would elicit a response from the crowd.
- c)Because the crowd was exceptionally determined and unwilling to vacate the area.
- d)Because he had received explicit orders from his superiors, leaving no alternative but to continue firing.
Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?
Most Upvoted Answer
Directions: Read the following passage and answer the question."D...
General's Responsibility to Persist in Firing
The general's rationale for continuing to fire into the crowd during the Amritsar massacre is rooted in his belief about the necessity of using substantial force to achieve the desired outcome of dispersing the crowd. Here’s a breakdown of the factors influencing his decision:
Perception of Duty
- The general viewed his actions as a duty, believing that only sustained and significant firing would effectively disperse the crowd.
- He expressed that firing "a little" would not be sufficient, and any minimal response would render him ineffective and wrong for initiating any fire at all.
Fear of Losing Control
- He feared that if he stopped firing too early, the crowd would simply regroup and return, undermining his authority and making him appear foolish.
- This fear of losing control over the situation reinforced his belief that continuous firing was necessary to maintain order and assert his dominance.
Understanding of Crowd Dynamics
- The general acknowledged the density of the crowd, indicating that he believed a well-directed shot would hit its target due to the close proximity of individuals.
- His comments suggest that he considered the physical conditions of the crowd to necessitate a more aggressive approach to achieve dispersal.
Conclusion
- The general's mindset reflects a conviction that only through persistent and forceful action could he achieve the outcome he desired. Therefore, option 'B' accurately captures his belief that substantial force was essential to elicit the necessary response from the crowd.
The general's rationale for continuing to fire into the crowd during the Amritsar massacre is rooted in his belief about the necessity of using substantial force to achieve the desired outcome of dispersing the crowd. Here’s a breakdown of the factors influencing his decision:
Perception of Duty
- The general viewed his actions as a duty, believing that only sustained and significant firing would effectively disperse the crowd.
- He expressed that firing "a little" would not be sufficient, and any minimal response would render him ineffective and wrong for initiating any fire at all.
Fear of Losing Control
- He feared that if he stopped firing too early, the crowd would simply regroup and return, undermining his authority and making him appear foolish.
- This fear of losing control over the situation reinforced his belief that continuous firing was necessary to maintain order and assert his dominance.
Understanding of Crowd Dynamics
- The general acknowledged the density of the crowd, indicating that he believed a well-directed shot would hit its target due to the close proximity of individuals.
- His comments suggest that he considered the physical conditions of the crowd to necessitate a more aggressive approach to achieve dispersal.
Conclusion
- The general's mindset reflects a conviction that only through persistent and forceful action could he achieve the outcome he desired. Therefore, option 'B' accurately captures his belief that substantial force was essential to elicit the necessary response from the crowd.
Free Test
FREE
| Start Free Test |
Community Answer
Directions: Read the following passage and answer the question."D...
Option 2 is indeed the correct answer. The general's intent to disperse the crowd is evident in his statement: "If I fired a little, the effect would not be sufficient. If I had fired a little, I should be wrong in firing at all." This indicates that the general believed that the crowd would not disperse adequately if only a single shot or a few shots were fired. Consequently, he deemed it necessary to employ a higher degree of force in the form of continuous firing.
|
Explore Courses for CLAT exam
|
|
Similar CLAT Doubts
Top Courses for CLATView all
Directions: Read the following passage and answer the question."Did you continue firing?""Yes," replied the general.There was an audible gasp that echoed through this crowded room in response to that single word. His Lordship waited for silence to be restored, sitting with eyes lowered, hands clasped tightly on the long table that separated the Committee from everyone else. The folds of his black robe pinched against the tables edge as he hunched forward, leaning heavily on his elbows, asking in a voice strained thin by incredulity:"If the crowd was going to disperse, why did you not stop firing?""I thought it my duty to go on firing until it dispersed. If I fired a little, the effect would not be sufficient. If I had fired a little I should be wrong in firing at all.""What reason had you to suppose that if you had ordered the assembly to leave the Bagh they would not have done so without the necessity of your firing, continued firing for a length of time?""Yes, I think it is quite possible that I could have dispersed them perhaps even without firing.""Why did you not adopt that course" His Lordship asked, shaking his head, more in wonder than horror, as he asked the question."I could not disperse them for some time," the General answered, speaking slowly, sounding distracted as he stared over the heads of the judges, "then they would all come back and laugh at me, and I considered I would be making myself a fool."A wave of startled comment greeted this remark, and the clamour became so loud that His Lordship was obliged to rap his gavel before continuing his interrogation."You know that the casualties were something between four hundred and five hundred.""Yes I have seen it in the papers. I divided all my rounds by five--" He paused and touched his fingertips to his lips, staring vacantly at the ceiling, mumbling, "I am in doubt whether by five or six--to arrive at the number.""I understood that the shooting that took place was individual shooting, and it was not volley shooting?""No, there was no volley shooting.""The crowd was very dense?""It was very dense.""It was unlikely that a man shooting into the crowd will miss?""No, according to the circumstances of the case," the General replied, shaking his head, sounding bewildered. "They were running, and I noticed only a certain number of men were hit. In the centre of the section, the crowd was very dense and therefore if a man directed his fire well he should not miss."[This is an extract from Stanley Wolperts fictionalised account entitled Massacre at Jallianwala Bagh, published by Penguin Books India, 1988. The extract is from a section entitled Lahore: November 19, 1919 and deals with the Committee of Inquiry into the Amritsar massacre which condemned the conduct of General Reginald Dyer.]Q.Based on the information in the passage, why did the general think it was his responsibility to persist in firing?a)Because refraining from firing would have led to the crowd dispersing as desired.b)Because he believed that only a substantial level of force would elicit a response from the crowd.c)Because the crowd was exceptionally determined and unwilling to vacate the area.d)Because he had received explicit orders from his superiors, leaving no alternative but to continue firing.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?
Question Description
Directions: Read the following passage and answer the question."Did you continue firing?""Yes," replied the general.There was an audible gasp that echoed through this crowded room in response to that single word. His Lordship waited for silence to be restored, sitting with eyes lowered, hands clasped tightly on the long table that separated the Committee from everyone else. The folds of his black robe pinched against the tables edge as he hunched forward, leaning heavily on his elbows, asking in a voice strained thin by incredulity:"If the crowd was going to disperse, why did you not stop firing?""I thought it my duty to go on firing until it dispersed. If I fired a little, the effect would not be sufficient. If I had fired a little I should be wrong in firing at all.""What reason had you to suppose that if you had ordered the assembly to leave the Bagh they would not have done so without the necessity of your firing, continued firing for a length of time?""Yes, I think it is quite possible that I could have dispersed them perhaps even without firing.""Why did you not adopt that course" His Lordship asked, shaking his head, more in wonder than horror, as he asked the question."I could not disperse them for some time," the General answered, speaking slowly, sounding distracted as he stared over the heads of the judges, "then they would all come back and laugh at me, and I considered I would be making myself a fool."A wave of startled comment greeted this remark, and the clamour became so loud that His Lordship was obliged to rap his gavel before continuing his interrogation."You know that the casualties were something between four hundred and five hundred.""Yes I have seen it in the papers. I divided all my rounds by five--" He paused and touched his fingertips to his lips, staring vacantly at the ceiling, mumbling, "I am in doubt whether by five or six--to arrive at the number.""I understood that the shooting that took place was individual shooting, and it was not volley shooting?""No, there was no volley shooting.""The crowd was very dense?""It was very dense.""It was unlikely that a man shooting into the crowd will miss?""No, according to the circumstances of the case," the General replied, shaking his head, sounding bewildered. "They were running, and I noticed only a certain number of men were hit. In the centre of the section, the crowd was very dense and therefore if a man directed his fire well he should not miss."[This is an extract from Stanley Wolperts fictionalised account entitled Massacre at Jallianwala Bagh, published by Penguin Books India, 1988. The extract is from a section entitled Lahore: November 19, 1919 and deals with the Committee of Inquiry into the Amritsar massacre which condemned the conduct of General Reginald Dyer.]Q.Based on the information in the passage, why did the general think it was his responsibility to persist in firing?a)Because refraining from firing would have led to the crowd dispersing as desired.b)Because he believed that only a substantial level of force would elicit a response from the crowd.c)Because the crowd was exceptionally determined and unwilling to vacate the area.d)Because he had received explicit orders from his superiors, leaving no alternative but to continue firing.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? for CLAT 2025 is part of CLAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CLAT exam syllabus. Information about Directions: Read the following passage and answer the question."Did you continue firing?""Yes," replied the general.There was an audible gasp that echoed through this crowded room in response to that single word. His Lordship waited for silence to be restored, sitting with eyes lowered, hands clasped tightly on the long table that separated the Committee from everyone else. The folds of his black robe pinched against the tables edge as he hunched forward, leaning heavily on his elbows, asking in a voice strained thin by incredulity:"If the crowd was going to disperse, why did you not stop firing?""I thought it my duty to go on firing until it dispersed. If I fired a little, the effect would not be sufficient. If I had fired a little I should be wrong in firing at all.""What reason had you to suppose that if you had ordered the assembly to leave the Bagh they would not have done so without the necessity of your firing, continued firing for a length of time?""Yes, I think it is quite possible that I could have dispersed them perhaps even without firing.""Why did you not adopt that course" His Lordship asked, shaking his head, more in wonder than horror, as he asked the question."I could not disperse them for some time," the General answered, speaking slowly, sounding distracted as he stared over the heads of the judges, "then they would all come back and laugh at me, and I considered I would be making myself a fool."A wave of startled comment greeted this remark, and the clamour became so loud that His Lordship was obliged to rap his gavel before continuing his interrogation."You know that the casualties were something between four hundred and five hundred.""Yes I have seen it in the papers. I divided all my rounds by five--" He paused and touched his fingertips to his lips, staring vacantly at the ceiling, mumbling, "I am in doubt whether by five or six--to arrive at the number.""I understood that the shooting that took place was individual shooting, and it was not volley shooting?""No, there was no volley shooting.""The crowd was very dense?""It was very dense.""It was unlikely that a man shooting into the crowd will miss?""No, according to the circumstances of the case," the General replied, shaking his head, sounding bewildered. "They were running, and I noticed only a certain number of men were hit. In the centre of the section, the crowd was very dense and therefore if a man directed his fire well he should not miss."[This is an extract from Stanley Wolperts fictionalised account entitled Massacre at Jallianwala Bagh, published by Penguin Books India, 1988. The extract is from a section entitled Lahore: November 19, 1919 and deals with the Committee of Inquiry into the Amritsar massacre which condemned the conduct of General Reginald Dyer.]Q.Based on the information in the passage, why did the general think it was his responsibility to persist in firing?a)Because refraining from firing would have led to the crowd dispersing as desired.b)Because he believed that only a substantial level of force would elicit a response from the crowd.c)Because the crowd was exceptionally determined and unwilling to vacate the area.d)Because he had received explicit orders from his superiors, leaving no alternative but to continue firing.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for CLAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Directions: Read the following passage and answer the question."Did you continue firing?""Yes," replied the general.There was an audible gasp that echoed through this crowded room in response to that single word. His Lordship waited for silence to be restored, sitting with eyes lowered, hands clasped tightly on the long table that separated the Committee from everyone else. The folds of his black robe pinched against the tables edge as he hunched forward, leaning heavily on his elbows, asking in a voice strained thin by incredulity:"If the crowd was going to disperse, why did you not stop firing?""I thought it my duty to go on firing until it dispersed. If I fired a little, the effect would not be sufficient. If I had fired a little I should be wrong in firing at all.""What reason had you to suppose that if you had ordered the assembly to leave the Bagh they would not have done so without the necessity of your firing, continued firing for a length of time?""Yes, I think it is quite possible that I could have dispersed them perhaps even without firing.""Why did you not adopt that course" His Lordship asked, shaking his head, more in wonder than horror, as he asked the question."I could not disperse them for some time," the General answered, speaking slowly, sounding distracted as he stared over the heads of the judges, "then they would all come back and laugh at me, and I considered I would be making myself a fool."A wave of startled comment greeted this remark, and the clamour became so loud that His Lordship was obliged to rap his gavel before continuing his interrogation."You know that the casualties were something between four hundred and five hundred.""Yes I have seen it in the papers. I divided all my rounds by five--" He paused and touched his fingertips to his lips, staring vacantly at the ceiling, mumbling, "I am in doubt whether by five or six--to arrive at the number.""I understood that the shooting that took place was individual shooting, and it was not volley shooting?""No, there was no volley shooting.""The crowd was very dense?""It was very dense.""It was unlikely that a man shooting into the crowd will miss?""No, according to the circumstances of the case," the General replied, shaking his head, sounding bewildered. "They were running, and I noticed only a certain number of men were hit. In the centre of the section, the crowd was very dense and therefore if a man directed his fire well he should not miss."[This is an extract from Stanley Wolperts fictionalised account entitled Massacre at Jallianwala Bagh, published by Penguin Books India, 1988. The extract is from a section entitled Lahore: November 19, 1919 and deals with the Committee of Inquiry into the Amritsar massacre which condemned the conduct of General Reginald Dyer.]Q.Based on the information in the passage, why did the general think it was his responsibility to persist in firing?a)Because refraining from firing would have led to the crowd dispersing as desired.b)Because he believed that only a substantial level of force would elicit a response from the crowd.c)Because the crowd was exceptionally determined and unwilling to vacate the area.d)Because he had received explicit orders from his superiors, leaving no alternative but to continue firing.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?.
Directions: Read the following passage and answer the question."Did you continue firing?""Yes," replied the general.There was an audible gasp that echoed through this crowded room in response to that single word. His Lordship waited for silence to be restored, sitting with eyes lowered, hands clasped tightly on the long table that separated the Committee from everyone else. The folds of his black robe pinched against the tables edge as he hunched forward, leaning heavily on his elbows, asking in a voice strained thin by incredulity:"If the crowd was going to disperse, why did you not stop firing?""I thought it my duty to go on firing until it dispersed. If I fired a little, the effect would not be sufficient. If I had fired a little I should be wrong in firing at all.""What reason had you to suppose that if you had ordered the assembly to leave the Bagh they would not have done so without the necessity of your firing, continued firing for a length of time?""Yes, I think it is quite possible that I could have dispersed them perhaps even without firing.""Why did you not adopt that course" His Lordship asked, shaking his head, more in wonder than horror, as he asked the question."I could not disperse them for some time," the General answered, speaking slowly, sounding distracted as he stared over the heads of the judges, "then they would all come back and laugh at me, and I considered I would be making myself a fool."A wave of startled comment greeted this remark, and the clamour became so loud that His Lordship was obliged to rap his gavel before continuing his interrogation."You know that the casualties were something between four hundred and five hundred.""Yes I have seen it in the papers. I divided all my rounds by five--" He paused and touched his fingertips to his lips, staring vacantly at the ceiling, mumbling, "I am in doubt whether by five or six--to arrive at the number.""I understood that the shooting that took place was individual shooting, and it was not volley shooting?""No, there was no volley shooting.""The crowd was very dense?""It was very dense.""It was unlikely that a man shooting into the crowd will miss?""No, according to the circumstances of the case," the General replied, shaking his head, sounding bewildered. "They were running, and I noticed only a certain number of men were hit. In the centre of the section, the crowd was very dense and therefore if a man directed his fire well he should not miss."[This is an extract from Stanley Wolperts fictionalised account entitled Massacre at Jallianwala Bagh, published by Penguin Books India, 1988. The extract is from a section entitled Lahore: November 19, 1919 and deals with the Committee of Inquiry into the Amritsar massacre which condemned the conduct of General Reginald Dyer.]Q.Based on the information in the passage, why did the general think it was his responsibility to persist in firing?a)Because refraining from firing would have led to the crowd dispersing as desired.b)Because he believed that only a substantial level of force would elicit a response from the crowd.c)Because the crowd was exceptionally determined and unwilling to vacate the area.d)Because he had received explicit orders from his superiors, leaving no alternative but to continue firing.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? for CLAT 2025 is part of CLAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CLAT exam syllabus. Information about Directions: Read the following passage and answer the question."Did you continue firing?""Yes," replied the general.There was an audible gasp that echoed through this crowded room in response to that single word. His Lordship waited for silence to be restored, sitting with eyes lowered, hands clasped tightly on the long table that separated the Committee from everyone else. The folds of his black robe pinched against the tables edge as he hunched forward, leaning heavily on his elbows, asking in a voice strained thin by incredulity:"If the crowd was going to disperse, why did you not stop firing?""I thought it my duty to go on firing until it dispersed. If I fired a little, the effect would not be sufficient. If I had fired a little I should be wrong in firing at all.""What reason had you to suppose that if you had ordered the assembly to leave the Bagh they would not have done so without the necessity of your firing, continued firing for a length of time?""Yes, I think it is quite possible that I could have dispersed them perhaps even without firing.""Why did you not adopt that course" His Lordship asked, shaking his head, more in wonder than horror, as he asked the question."I could not disperse them for some time," the General answered, speaking slowly, sounding distracted as he stared over the heads of the judges, "then they would all come back and laugh at me, and I considered I would be making myself a fool."A wave of startled comment greeted this remark, and the clamour became so loud that His Lordship was obliged to rap his gavel before continuing his interrogation."You know that the casualties were something between four hundred and five hundred.""Yes I have seen it in the papers. I divided all my rounds by five--" He paused and touched his fingertips to his lips, staring vacantly at the ceiling, mumbling, "I am in doubt whether by five or six--to arrive at the number.""I understood that the shooting that took place was individual shooting, and it was not volley shooting?""No, there was no volley shooting.""The crowd was very dense?""It was very dense.""It was unlikely that a man shooting into the crowd will miss?""No, according to the circumstances of the case," the General replied, shaking his head, sounding bewildered. "They were running, and I noticed only a certain number of men were hit. In the centre of the section, the crowd was very dense and therefore if a man directed his fire well he should not miss."[This is an extract from Stanley Wolperts fictionalised account entitled Massacre at Jallianwala Bagh, published by Penguin Books India, 1988. The extract is from a section entitled Lahore: November 19, 1919 and deals with the Committee of Inquiry into the Amritsar massacre which condemned the conduct of General Reginald Dyer.]Q.Based on the information in the passage, why did the general think it was his responsibility to persist in firing?a)Because refraining from firing would have led to the crowd dispersing as desired.b)Because he believed that only a substantial level of force would elicit a response from the crowd.c)Because the crowd was exceptionally determined and unwilling to vacate the area.d)Because he had received explicit orders from his superiors, leaving no alternative but to continue firing.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for CLAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Directions: Read the following passage and answer the question."Did you continue firing?""Yes," replied the general.There was an audible gasp that echoed through this crowded room in response to that single word. His Lordship waited for silence to be restored, sitting with eyes lowered, hands clasped tightly on the long table that separated the Committee from everyone else. The folds of his black robe pinched against the tables edge as he hunched forward, leaning heavily on his elbows, asking in a voice strained thin by incredulity:"If the crowd was going to disperse, why did you not stop firing?""I thought it my duty to go on firing until it dispersed. If I fired a little, the effect would not be sufficient. If I had fired a little I should be wrong in firing at all.""What reason had you to suppose that if you had ordered the assembly to leave the Bagh they would not have done so without the necessity of your firing, continued firing for a length of time?""Yes, I think it is quite possible that I could have dispersed them perhaps even without firing.""Why did you not adopt that course" His Lordship asked, shaking his head, more in wonder than horror, as he asked the question."I could not disperse them for some time," the General answered, speaking slowly, sounding distracted as he stared over the heads of the judges, "then they would all come back and laugh at me, and I considered I would be making myself a fool."A wave of startled comment greeted this remark, and the clamour became so loud that His Lordship was obliged to rap his gavel before continuing his interrogation."You know that the casualties were something between four hundred and five hundred.""Yes I have seen it in the papers. I divided all my rounds by five--" He paused and touched his fingertips to his lips, staring vacantly at the ceiling, mumbling, "I am in doubt whether by five or six--to arrive at the number.""I understood that the shooting that took place was individual shooting, and it was not volley shooting?""No, there was no volley shooting.""The crowd was very dense?""It was very dense.""It was unlikely that a man shooting into the crowd will miss?""No, according to the circumstances of the case," the General replied, shaking his head, sounding bewildered. "They were running, and I noticed only a certain number of men were hit. In the centre of the section, the crowd was very dense and therefore if a man directed his fire well he should not miss."[This is an extract from Stanley Wolperts fictionalised account entitled Massacre at Jallianwala Bagh, published by Penguin Books India, 1988. The extract is from a section entitled Lahore: November 19, 1919 and deals with the Committee of Inquiry into the Amritsar massacre which condemned the conduct of General Reginald Dyer.]Q.Based on the information in the passage, why did the general think it was his responsibility to persist in firing?a)Because refraining from firing would have led to the crowd dispersing as desired.b)Because he believed that only a substantial level of force would elicit a response from the crowd.c)Because the crowd was exceptionally determined and unwilling to vacate the area.d)Because he had received explicit orders from his superiors, leaving no alternative but to continue firing.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for Directions: Read the following passage and answer the question."Did you continue firing?""Yes," replied the general.There was an audible gasp that echoed through this crowded room in response to that single word. His Lordship waited for silence to be restored, sitting with eyes lowered, hands clasped tightly on the long table that separated the Committee from everyone else. The folds of his black robe pinched against the tables edge as he hunched forward, leaning heavily on his elbows, asking in a voice strained thin by incredulity:"If the crowd was going to disperse, why did you not stop firing?""I thought it my duty to go on firing until it dispersed. If I fired a little, the effect would not be sufficient. If I had fired a little I should be wrong in firing at all.""What reason had you to suppose that if you had ordered the assembly to leave the Bagh they would not have done so without the necessity of your firing, continued firing for a length of time?""Yes, I think it is quite possible that I could have dispersed them perhaps even without firing.""Why did you not adopt that course" His Lordship asked, shaking his head, more in wonder than horror, as he asked the question."I could not disperse them for some time," the General answered, speaking slowly, sounding distracted as he stared over the heads of the judges, "then they would all come back and laugh at me, and I considered I would be making myself a fool."A wave of startled comment greeted this remark, and the clamour became so loud that His Lordship was obliged to rap his gavel before continuing his interrogation."You know that the casualties were something between four hundred and five hundred.""Yes I have seen it in the papers. I divided all my rounds by five--" He paused and touched his fingertips to his lips, staring vacantly at the ceiling, mumbling, "I am in doubt whether by five or six--to arrive at the number.""I understood that the shooting that took place was individual shooting, and it was not volley shooting?""No, there was no volley shooting.""The crowd was very dense?""It was very dense.""It was unlikely that a man shooting into the crowd will miss?""No, according to the circumstances of the case," the General replied, shaking his head, sounding bewildered. "They were running, and I noticed only a certain number of men were hit. In the centre of the section, the crowd was very dense and therefore if a man directed his fire well he should not miss."[This is an extract from Stanley Wolperts fictionalised account entitled Massacre at Jallianwala Bagh, published by Penguin Books India, 1988. The extract is from a section entitled Lahore: November 19, 1919 and deals with the Committee of Inquiry into the Amritsar massacre which condemned the conduct of General Reginald Dyer.]Q.Based on the information in the passage, why did the general think it was his responsibility to persist in firing?a)Because refraining from firing would have led to the crowd dispersing as desired.b)Because he believed that only a substantial level of force would elicit a response from the crowd.c)Because the crowd was exceptionally determined and unwilling to vacate the area.d)Because he had received explicit orders from his superiors, leaving no alternative but to continue firing.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for CLAT.
Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for CLAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of Directions: Read the following passage and answer the question."Did you continue firing?""Yes," replied the general.There was an audible gasp that echoed through this crowded room in response to that single word. His Lordship waited for silence to be restored, sitting with eyes lowered, hands clasped tightly on the long table that separated the Committee from everyone else. The folds of his black robe pinched against the tables edge as he hunched forward, leaning heavily on his elbows, asking in a voice strained thin by incredulity:"If the crowd was going to disperse, why did you not stop firing?""I thought it my duty to go on firing until it dispersed. If I fired a little, the effect would not be sufficient. If I had fired a little I should be wrong in firing at all.""What reason had you to suppose that if you had ordered the assembly to leave the Bagh they would not have done so without the necessity of your firing, continued firing for a length of time?""Yes, I think it is quite possible that I could have dispersed them perhaps even without firing.""Why did you not adopt that course" His Lordship asked, shaking his head, more in wonder than horror, as he asked the question."I could not disperse them for some time," the General answered, speaking slowly, sounding distracted as he stared over the heads of the judges, "then they would all come back and laugh at me, and I considered I would be making myself a fool."A wave of startled comment greeted this remark, and the clamour became so loud that His Lordship was obliged to rap his gavel before continuing his interrogation."You know that the casualties were something between four hundred and five hundred.""Yes I have seen it in the papers. I divided all my rounds by five--" He paused and touched his fingertips to his lips, staring vacantly at the ceiling, mumbling, "I am in doubt whether by five or six--to arrive at the number.""I understood that the shooting that took place was individual shooting, and it was not volley shooting?""No, there was no volley shooting.""The crowd was very dense?""It was very dense.""It was unlikely that a man shooting into the crowd will miss?""No, according to the circumstances of the case," the General replied, shaking his head, sounding bewildered. "They were running, and I noticed only a certain number of men were hit. In the centre of the section, the crowd was very dense and therefore if a man directed his fire well he should not miss."[This is an extract from Stanley Wolperts fictionalised account entitled Massacre at Jallianwala Bagh, published by Penguin Books India, 1988. The extract is from a section entitled Lahore: November 19, 1919 and deals with the Committee of Inquiry into the Amritsar massacre which condemned the conduct of General Reginald Dyer.]Q.Based on the information in the passage, why did the general think it was his responsibility to persist in firing?a)Because refraining from firing would have led to the crowd dispersing as desired.b)Because he believed that only a substantial level of force would elicit a response from the crowd.c)Because the crowd was exceptionally determined and unwilling to vacate the area.d)Because he had received explicit orders from his superiors, leaving no alternative but to continue firing.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of
Directions: Read the following passage and answer the question."Did you continue firing?""Yes," replied the general.There was an audible gasp that echoed through this crowded room in response to that single word. His Lordship waited for silence to be restored, sitting with eyes lowered, hands clasped tightly on the long table that separated the Committee from everyone else. The folds of his black robe pinched against the tables edge as he hunched forward, leaning heavily on his elbows, asking in a voice strained thin by incredulity:"If the crowd was going to disperse, why did you not stop firing?""I thought it my duty to go on firing until it dispersed. If I fired a little, the effect would not be sufficient. If I had fired a little I should be wrong in firing at all.""What reason had you to suppose that if you had ordered the assembly to leave the Bagh they would not have done so without the necessity of your firing, continued firing for a length of time?""Yes, I think it is quite possible that I could have dispersed them perhaps even without firing.""Why did you not adopt that course" His Lordship asked, shaking his head, more in wonder than horror, as he asked the question."I could not disperse them for some time," the General answered, speaking slowly, sounding distracted as he stared over the heads of the judges, "then they would all come back and laugh at me, and I considered I would be making myself a fool."A wave of startled comment greeted this remark, and the clamour became so loud that His Lordship was obliged to rap his gavel before continuing his interrogation."You know that the casualties were something between four hundred and five hundred.""Yes I have seen it in the papers. I divided all my rounds by five--" He paused and touched his fingertips to his lips, staring vacantly at the ceiling, mumbling, "I am in doubt whether by five or six--to arrive at the number.""I understood that the shooting that took place was individual shooting, and it was not volley shooting?""No, there was no volley shooting.""The crowd was very dense?""It was very dense.""It was unlikely that a man shooting into the crowd will miss?""No, according to the circumstances of the case," the General replied, shaking his head, sounding bewildered. "They were running, and I noticed only a certain number of men were hit. In the centre of the section, the crowd was very dense and therefore if a man directed his fire well he should not miss."[This is an extract from Stanley Wolperts fictionalised account entitled Massacre at Jallianwala Bagh, published by Penguin Books India, 1988. The extract is from a section entitled Lahore: November 19, 1919 and deals with the Committee of Inquiry into the Amritsar massacre which condemned the conduct of General Reginald Dyer.]Q.Based on the information in the passage, why did the general think it was his responsibility to persist in firing?a)Because refraining from firing would have led to the crowd dispersing as desired.b)Because he believed that only a substantial level of force would elicit a response from the crowd.c)Because the crowd was exceptionally determined and unwilling to vacate the area.d)Because he had received explicit orders from his superiors, leaving no alternative but to continue firing.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for Directions: Read the following passage and answer the question."Did you continue firing?""Yes," replied the general.There was an audible gasp that echoed through this crowded room in response to that single word. His Lordship waited for silence to be restored, sitting with eyes lowered, hands clasped tightly on the long table that separated the Committee from everyone else. The folds of his black robe pinched against the tables edge as he hunched forward, leaning heavily on his elbows, asking in a voice strained thin by incredulity:"If the crowd was going to disperse, why did you not stop firing?""I thought it my duty to go on firing until it dispersed. If I fired a little, the effect would not be sufficient. If I had fired a little I should be wrong in firing at all.""What reason had you to suppose that if you had ordered the assembly to leave the Bagh they would not have done so without the necessity of your firing, continued firing for a length of time?""Yes, I think it is quite possible that I could have dispersed them perhaps even without firing.""Why did you not adopt that course" His Lordship asked, shaking his head, more in wonder than horror, as he asked the question."I could not disperse them for some time," the General answered, speaking slowly, sounding distracted as he stared over the heads of the judges, "then they would all come back and laugh at me, and I considered I would be making myself a fool."A wave of startled comment greeted this remark, and the clamour became so loud that His Lordship was obliged to rap his gavel before continuing his interrogation."You know that the casualties were something between four hundred and five hundred.""Yes I have seen it in the papers. I divided all my rounds by five--" He paused and touched his fingertips to his lips, staring vacantly at the ceiling, mumbling, "I am in doubt whether by five or six--to arrive at the number.""I understood that the shooting that took place was individual shooting, and it was not volley shooting?""No, there was no volley shooting.""The crowd was very dense?""It was very dense.""It was unlikely that a man shooting into the crowd will miss?""No, according to the circumstances of the case," the General replied, shaking his head, sounding bewildered. "They were running, and I noticed only a certain number of men were hit. In the centre of the section, the crowd was very dense and therefore if a man directed his fire well he should not miss."[This is an extract from Stanley Wolperts fictionalised account entitled Massacre at Jallianwala Bagh, published by Penguin Books India, 1988. The extract is from a section entitled Lahore: November 19, 1919 and deals with the Committee of Inquiry into the Amritsar massacre which condemned the conduct of General Reginald Dyer.]Q.Based on the information in the passage, why did the general think it was his responsibility to persist in firing?a)Because refraining from firing would have led to the crowd dispersing as desired.b)Because he believed that only a substantial level of force would elicit a response from the crowd.c)Because the crowd was exceptionally determined and unwilling to vacate the area.d)Because he had received explicit orders from his superiors, leaving no alternative but to continue firing.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of Directions: Read the following passage and answer the question."Did you continue firing?""Yes," replied the general.There was an audible gasp that echoed through this crowded room in response to that single word. His Lordship waited for silence to be restored, sitting with eyes lowered, hands clasped tightly on the long table that separated the Committee from everyone else. The folds of his black robe pinched against the tables edge as he hunched forward, leaning heavily on his elbows, asking in a voice strained thin by incredulity:"If the crowd was going to disperse, why did you not stop firing?""I thought it my duty to go on firing until it dispersed. If I fired a little, the effect would not be sufficient. If I had fired a little I should be wrong in firing at all.""What reason had you to suppose that if you had ordered the assembly to leave the Bagh they would not have done so without the necessity of your firing, continued firing for a length of time?""Yes, I think it is quite possible that I could have dispersed them perhaps even without firing.""Why did you not adopt that course" His Lordship asked, shaking his head, more in wonder than horror, as he asked the question."I could not disperse them for some time," the General answered, speaking slowly, sounding distracted as he stared over the heads of the judges, "then they would all come back and laugh at me, and I considered I would be making myself a fool."A wave of startled comment greeted this remark, and the clamour became so loud that His Lordship was obliged to rap his gavel before continuing his interrogation."You know that the casualties were something between four hundred and five hundred.""Yes I have seen it in the papers. I divided all my rounds by five--" He paused and touched his fingertips to his lips, staring vacantly at the ceiling, mumbling, "I am in doubt whether by five or six--to arrive at the number.""I understood that the shooting that took place was individual shooting, and it was not volley shooting?""No, there was no volley shooting.""The crowd was very dense?""It was very dense.""It was unlikely that a man shooting into the crowd will miss?""No, according to the circumstances of the case," the General replied, shaking his head, sounding bewildered. "They were running, and I noticed only a certain number of men were hit. In the centre of the section, the crowd was very dense and therefore if a man directed his fire well he should not miss."[This is an extract from Stanley Wolperts fictionalised account entitled Massacre at Jallianwala Bagh, published by Penguin Books India, 1988. The extract is from a section entitled Lahore: November 19, 1919 and deals with the Committee of Inquiry into the Amritsar massacre which condemned the conduct of General Reginald Dyer.]Q.Based on the information in the passage, why did the general think it was his responsibility to persist in firing?a)Because refraining from firing would have led to the crowd dispersing as desired.b)Because he believed that only a substantial level of force would elicit a response from the crowd.c)Because the crowd was exceptionally determined and unwilling to vacate the area.d)Because he had received explicit orders from his superiors, leaving no alternative but to continue firing.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an
ample number of questions to practice Directions: Read the following passage and answer the question."Did you continue firing?""Yes," replied the general.There was an audible gasp that echoed through this crowded room in response to that single word. His Lordship waited for silence to be restored, sitting with eyes lowered, hands clasped tightly on the long table that separated the Committee from everyone else. The folds of his black robe pinched against the tables edge as he hunched forward, leaning heavily on his elbows, asking in a voice strained thin by incredulity:"If the crowd was going to disperse, why did you not stop firing?""I thought it my duty to go on firing until it dispersed. If I fired a little, the effect would not be sufficient. If I had fired a little I should be wrong in firing at all.""What reason had you to suppose that if you had ordered the assembly to leave the Bagh they would not have done so without the necessity of your firing, continued firing for a length of time?""Yes, I think it is quite possible that I could have dispersed them perhaps even without firing.""Why did you not adopt that course" His Lordship asked, shaking his head, more in wonder than horror, as he asked the question."I could not disperse them for some time," the General answered, speaking slowly, sounding distracted as he stared over the heads of the judges, "then they would all come back and laugh at me, and I considered I would be making myself a fool."A wave of startled comment greeted this remark, and the clamour became so loud that His Lordship was obliged to rap his gavel before continuing his interrogation."You know that the casualties were something between four hundred and five hundred.""Yes I have seen it in the papers. I divided all my rounds by five--" He paused and touched his fingertips to his lips, staring vacantly at the ceiling, mumbling, "I am in doubt whether by five or six--to arrive at the number.""I understood that the shooting that took place was individual shooting, and it was not volley shooting?""No, there was no volley shooting.""The crowd was very dense?""It was very dense.""It was unlikely that a man shooting into the crowd will miss?""No, according to the circumstances of the case," the General replied, shaking his head, sounding bewildered. "They were running, and I noticed only a certain number of men were hit. In the centre of the section, the crowd was very dense and therefore if a man directed his fire well he should not miss."[This is an extract from Stanley Wolperts fictionalised account entitled Massacre at Jallianwala Bagh, published by Penguin Books India, 1988. The extract is from a section entitled Lahore: November 19, 1919 and deals with the Committee of Inquiry into the Amritsar massacre which condemned the conduct of General Reginald Dyer.]Q.Based on the information in the passage, why did the general think it was his responsibility to persist in firing?a)Because refraining from firing would have led to the crowd dispersing as desired.b)Because he believed that only a substantial level of force would elicit a response from the crowd.c)Because the crowd was exceptionally determined and unwilling to vacate the area.d)Because he had received explicit orders from his superiors, leaving no alternative but to continue firing.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice CLAT tests.
|
|
Explore Courses for CLAT exam
|
|
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
|
© EduRev
|
Education Revolution
|
|
Signup to see your scores
go up within 7 days!
Access 1000+ FREE Docs, Videos and Tests
Takes less than 10 seconds to signup