Humanities/Arts Exam  >  Humanities/Arts Questions  >  Principle: When a person consented to an act ... Start Learning for Free
Principle: When a person consented to an act to be done by another, he cannot claim any damages resulting from doing that act, provided the act done is the same for which consent is given.
Facts: 'P' submitted a written consent to a surgeon 'S' for undergoing a surgical operation for removal of appendicitis. The surgeon while doing surgery also removed the gall bladder of 'A':
  • a)
    'P' can claim damages from 'S'.
  • b)
    'P' is not bound to pay expenses of the surgery.
  • c)
    'P' is required to pay expenses for surgery for Appendicitis but not for Gall Bladder.
  • d)
    'P' cannot claim damages from 'S'.
Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?
Most Upvoted Answer
Principle: When a person consented to an act to be done by another, he...
A written consent for surgery was given by 'P' to surgeon 'S'. The consent was given only for the act of removal of appendicitis. However, 'S' also removes the gall bladder of 'A' for which no consent was given. This act was therefore carried out without the permission and approval of 'P'. In this case, 'S' acted sans valid consent. There is disobedience to the right of the patient's autonomy. (Ram Bihari Lal v Dr.J.N.Srivastave. AIR 1985 MP 150).
Free Test
Community Answer
Principle: When a person consented to an act to be done by another, he...
Explanation:

Consent and Damages:
- When a person consents to an act to be done by another, they cannot claim damages resulting from that act, provided the act done is the same for which consent is given.
- In this case, P gave written consent to the surgeon S for undergoing a surgical operation for the removal of appendicitis.

Surgeon's Actions:
- While performing the surgery for appendicitis, the surgeon also removed the gall bladder of P without obtaining separate consent for this additional procedure.

Claiming Damages:
- Since the surgeon did not have consent to remove the gall bladder, P can claim damages from S for this unauthorized procedure.
- Even though P consented to the initial surgery for appendicitis, the removal of the gall bladder was not part of that consent.

Conclusion:
- Therefore, in this case, P can claim damages from the surgeon S for the unauthorized removal of the gall bladder during the surgery.
Explore Courses for Humanities/Arts exam

Top Courses for Humanities/Arts

Question Description
Principle: When a person consented to an act to be done by another, he cannot claim any damages resulting from doing that act, provided the act done is the same for which consent is given.Facts: P submitted a written consent to a surgeon S for undergoing a surgical operation for removal of appendicitis. The surgeon while doing surgery also removed the gall bladder of A:a)P can claim damages from S.b)P is not bound to pay expenses of the surgery.c)P is required to pay expenses for surgery for Appendicitis but not for Gall Bladder.d)P cannot claim damages from S.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? for Humanities/Arts 2025 is part of Humanities/Arts preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the Humanities/Arts exam syllabus. Information about Principle: When a person consented to an act to be done by another, he cannot claim any damages resulting from doing that act, provided the act done is the same for which consent is given.Facts: P submitted a written consent to a surgeon S for undergoing a surgical operation for removal of appendicitis. The surgeon while doing surgery also removed the gall bladder of A:a)P can claim damages from S.b)P is not bound to pay expenses of the surgery.c)P is required to pay expenses for surgery for Appendicitis but not for Gall Bladder.d)P cannot claim damages from S.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for Humanities/Arts 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Principle: When a person consented to an act to be done by another, he cannot claim any damages resulting from doing that act, provided the act done is the same for which consent is given.Facts: P submitted a written consent to a surgeon S for undergoing a surgical operation for removal of appendicitis. The surgeon while doing surgery also removed the gall bladder of A:a)P can claim damages from S.b)P is not bound to pay expenses of the surgery.c)P is required to pay expenses for surgery for Appendicitis but not for Gall Bladder.d)P cannot claim damages from S.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for Principle: When a person consented to an act to be done by another, he cannot claim any damages resulting from doing that act, provided the act done is the same for which consent is given.Facts: P submitted a written consent to a surgeon S for undergoing a surgical operation for removal of appendicitis. The surgeon while doing surgery also removed the gall bladder of A:a)P can claim damages from S.b)P is not bound to pay expenses of the surgery.c)P is required to pay expenses for surgery for Appendicitis but not for Gall Bladder.d)P cannot claim damages from S.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for Humanities/Arts. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for Humanities/Arts Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of Principle: When a person consented to an act to be done by another, he cannot claim any damages resulting from doing that act, provided the act done is the same for which consent is given.Facts: P submitted a written consent to a surgeon S for undergoing a surgical operation for removal of appendicitis. The surgeon while doing surgery also removed the gall bladder of A:a)P can claim damages from S.b)P is not bound to pay expenses of the surgery.c)P is required to pay expenses for surgery for Appendicitis but not for Gall Bladder.d)P cannot claim damages from S.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of Principle: When a person consented to an act to be done by another, he cannot claim any damages resulting from doing that act, provided the act done is the same for which consent is given.Facts: P submitted a written consent to a surgeon S for undergoing a surgical operation for removal of appendicitis. The surgeon while doing surgery also removed the gall bladder of A:a)P can claim damages from S.b)P is not bound to pay expenses of the surgery.c)P is required to pay expenses for surgery for Appendicitis but not for Gall Bladder.d)P cannot claim damages from S.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for Principle: When a person consented to an act to be done by another, he cannot claim any damages resulting from doing that act, provided the act done is the same for which consent is given.Facts: P submitted a written consent to a surgeon S for undergoing a surgical operation for removal of appendicitis. The surgeon while doing surgery also removed the gall bladder of A:a)P can claim damages from S.b)P is not bound to pay expenses of the surgery.c)P is required to pay expenses for surgery for Appendicitis but not for Gall Bladder.d)P cannot claim damages from S.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of Principle: When a person consented to an act to be done by another, he cannot claim any damages resulting from doing that act, provided the act done is the same for which consent is given.Facts: P submitted a written consent to a surgeon S for undergoing a surgical operation for removal of appendicitis. The surgeon while doing surgery also removed the gall bladder of A:a)P can claim damages from S.b)P is not bound to pay expenses of the surgery.c)P is required to pay expenses for surgery for Appendicitis but not for Gall Bladder.d)P cannot claim damages from S.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice Principle: When a person consented to an act to be done by another, he cannot claim any damages resulting from doing that act, provided the act done is the same for which consent is given.Facts: P submitted a written consent to a surgeon S for undergoing a surgical operation for removal of appendicitis. The surgeon while doing surgery also removed the gall bladder of A:a)P can claim damages from S.b)P is not bound to pay expenses of the surgery.c)P is required to pay expenses for surgery for Appendicitis but not for Gall Bladder.d)P cannot claim damages from S.Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice Humanities/Arts tests.
Explore Courses for Humanities/Arts exam

Top Courses for Humanities/Arts

Explore Courses
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev