CLAT Exam  >  CLAT Questions  >  Principle 1 – An offer is the final expressio... Start Learning for Free
Principle 1 – An offer is the final expression of willingness by the offeror to be bound by his offer, should the other party choose to accept it.
Principle 2 – An invitation to offer merely invites others to make offers that one may or may not accept. It is not an offer in itself.
Principle 3 – Acceptance needs to be communicated to the offeror.
Facts – Lockhart writes to his closest friend and aide, Helga, ―I wish to sell my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons.‖
He then sends a letter to Sirius – ―Sirius, I have been meaning to sell my book, the one that chronicles our adolescent experiments in love and other adventures. What do you think?‖
He also writes to Harry – ―Harry, I am your biggest fan. Would you like to buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons?‖ and to Ron ―Ron, I see that you are in need of advice on matters of the heart. Why don‘t you buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons? Willing to offer a discount of 20%.‖
Harry sees the letter, makes a mental note of Lockhart‘s message, and throws the letter in the dustbin. He intends to buy the book, and makes a reminder note to write back to Lockhart and send him a sum of 200 Galleons.
Ron receives the letter and immediately writes back to Lockhart saying that he would like to buy the book. He posts the letter, the letter reaches Lockhart, but he then decides not to offer the discount or even sell the book to Ron.
Question:Has Lockhart made Sirius an offer?

a)Yes, by informing Sirius of the desire to sell,he makes an offer to sell the book.
b)No, this is not an offer. He has merely asked Sirius what he thinks of Lockhart‘s desire to sell the book.
c)Can‘t say if this is an offer or invitation to offer.
d)None of the above.
Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?
Most Upvoted Answer
Principle 1 – An offer is the final expression of willingness by the o...
The answer is B because Lockhart didn't tell him any offer for the book he merely asked his opinion on selling his book , no price or anything hence it is not an offer 
Free Test
Community Answer
Principle 1 – An offer is the final expression of willingness by the o...
Understanding the Nature of Offer
In the context of contract law, it is crucial to distinguish between an offer and an invitation to offer. Lockhart's communication with Sirius serves as a perfect example of this distinction.
Invitation to Offer vs. Offer
- Definition of Offer: An offer is a clear expression of willingness to enter into a contract, which, upon acceptance, creates a binding agreement.
- Definition of Invitation to Offer: An invitation to offer seeks to elicit offers from others; it is not intended to create a binding agreement on its own.
Analysis of Lockhart's Letter to Sirius
- Content of the Letter: Lockhart writes to Sirius, "What do you think?" This phrase indicates that he is not asserting a willingness to be bound by an offer to sell the book.
- Lack of Commitment: By merely asking for Sirius's opinion, Lockhart does not communicate a definite offer. Instead, he invites Sirius to express his interest or make an offer.
Conclusion
- Correct Answer: Therefore, the correct interpretation of Lockhart's communication to Sirius is option B: No, this is not an offer. He has merely asked Sirius what he thinks of Lockhart's desire to sell the book.
In summary, Lockhart has not made an offer to Sirius, as the language used does not convey a clear willingness to be bound by contractual terms.
Explore Courses for CLAT exam

Top Courses for CLAT

Question Description
Principle 1 – An offer is the final expression of willingness by the offeror to be bound by his offer, should the other party choose to accept it.Principle 2 – An invitation to offer merely invites others to make offers that one may or may not accept. It is not an offer in itself.Principle 3 – Acceptance needs to be communicated to the offeror.Facts – Lockhart writes to his closest friend and aide, Helga, ―I wish to sell my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons.‖He then sends a letter to Sirius – ―Sirius, I have been meaning to sell my book, the one that chronicles our adolescent experiments in love and other adventures. What do you think?‖He also writes to Harry – ―Harry, I am your biggest fan. Would you like to buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons?‖ and to Ron ―Ron, I see that you are in need of advice on matters of the heart. Why don‘t you buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons? Willing to offer a discount of 20%.‖Harry sees the letter, makes a mental note of Lockhart‘s message, and throws the letter in the dustbin. He intends to buy the book, and makes a reminder note to write back to Lockhart and send him a sum of 200 Galleons.Ron receives the letter and immediately writes back to Lockhart saying that he would like to buy the book. He posts the letter, the letter reaches Lockhart, but he then decides not to offer the discount or even sell the book to Ron.Question:Has Lockhart made Sirius an offer?a)Yes, by informing Sirius of the desire to sell,he makes an offer to sell the book.b)No, this is not an offer. He has merely asked Sirius what he thinks of Lockhart‘s desire to sell the book.c)Can‘t say if this is an offer or invitation to offer.d)None of the above.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? for CLAT 2025 is part of CLAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CLAT exam syllabus. Information about Principle 1 – An offer is the final expression of willingness by the offeror to be bound by his offer, should the other party choose to accept it.Principle 2 – An invitation to offer merely invites others to make offers that one may or may not accept. It is not an offer in itself.Principle 3 – Acceptance needs to be communicated to the offeror.Facts – Lockhart writes to his closest friend and aide, Helga, ―I wish to sell my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons.‖He then sends a letter to Sirius – ―Sirius, I have been meaning to sell my book, the one that chronicles our adolescent experiments in love and other adventures. What do you think?‖He also writes to Harry – ―Harry, I am your biggest fan. Would you like to buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons?‖ and to Ron ―Ron, I see that you are in need of advice on matters of the heart. Why don‘t you buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons? Willing to offer a discount of 20%.‖Harry sees the letter, makes a mental note of Lockhart‘s message, and throws the letter in the dustbin. He intends to buy the book, and makes a reminder note to write back to Lockhart and send him a sum of 200 Galleons.Ron receives the letter and immediately writes back to Lockhart saying that he would like to buy the book. He posts the letter, the letter reaches Lockhart, but he then decides not to offer the discount or even sell the book to Ron.Question:Has Lockhart made Sirius an offer?a)Yes, by informing Sirius of the desire to sell,he makes an offer to sell the book.b)No, this is not an offer. He has merely asked Sirius what he thinks of Lockhart‘s desire to sell the book.c)Can‘t say if this is an offer or invitation to offer.d)None of the above.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for CLAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Principle 1 – An offer is the final expression of willingness by the offeror to be bound by his offer, should the other party choose to accept it.Principle 2 – An invitation to offer merely invites others to make offers that one may or may not accept. It is not an offer in itself.Principle 3 – Acceptance needs to be communicated to the offeror.Facts – Lockhart writes to his closest friend and aide, Helga, ―I wish to sell my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons.‖He then sends a letter to Sirius – ―Sirius, I have been meaning to sell my book, the one that chronicles our adolescent experiments in love and other adventures. What do you think?‖He also writes to Harry – ―Harry, I am your biggest fan. Would you like to buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons?‖ and to Ron ―Ron, I see that you are in need of advice on matters of the heart. Why don‘t you buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons? Willing to offer a discount of 20%.‖Harry sees the letter, makes a mental note of Lockhart‘s message, and throws the letter in the dustbin. He intends to buy the book, and makes a reminder note to write back to Lockhart and send him a sum of 200 Galleons.Ron receives the letter and immediately writes back to Lockhart saying that he would like to buy the book. He posts the letter, the letter reaches Lockhart, but he then decides not to offer the discount or even sell the book to Ron.Question:Has Lockhart made Sirius an offer?a)Yes, by informing Sirius of the desire to sell,he makes an offer to sell the book.b)No, this is not an offer. He has merely asked Sirius what he thinks of Lockhart‘s desire to sell the book.c)Can‘t say if this is an offer or invitation to offer.d)None of the above.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for Principle 1 – An offer is the final expression of willingness by the offeror to be bound by his offer, should the other party choose to accept it.Principle 2 – An invitation to offer merely invites others to make offers that one may or may not accept. It is not an offer in itself.Principle 3 – Acceptance needs to be communicated to the offeror.Facts – Lockhart writes to his closest friend and aide, Helga, ―I wish to sell my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons.‖He then sends a letter to Sirius – ―Sirius, I have been meaning to sell my book, the one that chronicles our adolescent experiments in love and other adventures. What do you think?‖He also writes to Harry – ―Harry, I am your biggest fan. Would you like to buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons?‖ and to Ron ―Ron, I see that you are in need of advice on matters of the heart. Why don‘t you buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons? Willing to offer a discount of 20%.‖Harry sees the letter, makes a mental note of Lockhart‘s message, and throws the letter in the dustbin. He intends to buy the book, and makes a reminder note to write back to Lockhart and send him a sum of 200 Galleons.Ron receives the letter and immediately writes back to Lockhart saying that he would like to buy the book. He posts the letter, the letter reaches Lockhart, but he then decides not to offer the discount or even sell the book to Ron.Question:Has Lockhart made Sirius an offer?a)Yes, by informing Sirius of the desire to sell,he makes an offer to sell the book.b)No, this is not an offer. He has merely asked Sirius what he thinks of Lockhart‘s desire to sell the book.c)Can‘t say if this is an offer or invitation to offer.d)None of the above.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for CLAT. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for CLAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of Principle 1 – An offer is the final expression of willingness by the offeror to be bound by his offer, should the other party choose to accept it.Principle 2 – An invitation to offer merely invites others to make offers that one may or may not accept. It is not an offer in itself.Principle 3 – Acceptance needs to be communicated to the offeror.Facts – Lockhart writes to his closest friend and aide, Helga, ―I wish to sell my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons.‖He then sends a letter to Sirius – ―Sirius, I have been meaning to sell my book, the one that chronicles our adolescent experiments in love and other adventures. What do you think?‖He also writes to Harry – ―Harry, I am your biggest fan. Would you like to buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons?‖ and to Ron ―Ron, I see that you are in need of advice on matters of the heart. Why don‘t you buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons? Willing to offer a discount of 20%.‖Harry sees the letter, makes a mental note of Lockhart‘s message, and throws the letter in the dustbin. He intends to buy the book, and makes a reminder note to write back to Lockhart and send him a sum of 200 Galleons.Ron receives the letter and immediately writes back to Lockhart saying that he would like to buy the book. He posts the letter, the letter reaches Lockhart, but he then decides not to offer the discount or even sell the book to Ron.Question:Has Lockhart made Sirius an offer?a)Yes, by informing Sirius of the desire to sell,he makes an offer to sell the book.b)No, this is not an offer. He has merely asked Sirius what he thinks of Lockhart‘s desire to sell the book.c)Can‘t say if this is an offer or invitation to offer.d)None of the above.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of Principle 1 – An offer is the final expression of willingness by the offeror to be bound by his offer, should the other party choose to accept it.Principle 2 – An invitation to offer merely invites others to make offers that one may or may not accept. It is not an offer in itself.Principle 3 – Acceptance needs to be communicated to the offeror.Facts – Lockhart writes to his closest friend and aide, Helga, ―I wish to sell my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons.‖He then sends a letter to Sirius – ―Sirius, I have been meaning to sell my book, the one that chronicles our adolescent experiments in love and other adventures. What do you think?‖He also writes to Harry – ―Harry, I am your biggest fan. Would you like to buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons?‖ and to Ron ―Ron, I see that you are in need of advice on matters of the heart. Why don‘t you buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons? Willing to offer a discount of 20%.‖Harry sees the letter, makes a mental note of Lockhart‘s message, and throws the letter in the dustbin. He intends to buy the book, and makes a reminder note to write back to Lockhart and send him a sum of 200 Galleons.Ron receives the letter and immediately writes back to Lockhart saying that he would like to buy the book. He posts the letter, the letter reaches Lockhart, but he then decides not to offer the discount or even sell the book to Ron.Question:Has Lockhart made Sirius an offer?a)Yes, by informing Sirius of the desire to sell,he makes an offer to sell the book.b)No, this is not an offer. He has merely asked Sirius what he thinks of Lockhart‘s desire to sell the book.c)Can‘t say if this is an offer or invitation to offer.d)None of the above.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for Principle 1 – An offer is the final expression of willingness by the offeror to be bound by his offer, should the other party choose to accept it.Principle 2 – An invitation to offer merely invites others to make offers that one may or may not accept. It is not an offer in itself.Principle 3 – Acceptance needs to be communicated to the offeror.Facts – Lockhart writes to his closest friend and aide, Helga, ―I wish to sell my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons.‖He then sends a letter to Sirius – ―Sirius, I have been meaning to sell my book, the one that chronicles our adolescent experiments in love and other adventures. What do you think?‖He also writes to Harry – ―Harry, I am your biggest fan. Would you like to buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons?‖ and to Ron ―Ron, I see that you are in need of advice on matters of the heart. Why don‘t you buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons? Willing to offer a discount of 20%.‖Harry sees the letter, makes a mental note of Lockhart‘s message, and throws the letter in the dustbin. He intends to buy the book, and makes a reminder note to write back to Lockhart and send him a sum of 200 Galleons.Ron receives the letter and immediately writes back to Lockhart saying that he would like to buy the book. He posts the letter, the letter reaches Lockhart, but he then decides not to offer the discount or even sell the book to Ron.Question:Has Lockhart made Sirius an offer?a)Yes, by informing Sirius of the desire to sell,he makes an offer to sell the book.b)No, this is not an offer. He has merely asked Sirius what he thinks of Lockhart‘s desire to sell the book.c)Can‘t say if this is an offer or invitation to offer.d)None of the above.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of Principle 1 – An offer is the final expression of willingness by the offeror to be bound by his offer, should the other party choose to accept it.Principle 2 – An invitation to offer merely invites others to make offers that one may or may not accept. It is not an offer in itself.Principle 3 – Acceptance needs to be communicated to the offeror.Facts – Lockhart writes to his closest friend and aide, Helga, ―I wish to sell my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons.‖He then sends a letter to Sirius – ―Sirius, I have been meaning to sell my book, the one that chronicles our adolescent experiments in love and other adventures. What do you think?‖He also writes to Harry – ―Harry, I am your biggest fan. Would you like to buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons?‖ and to Ron ―Ron, I see that you are in need of advice on matters of the heart. Why don‘t you buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons? Willing to offer a discount of 20%.‖Harry sees the letter, makes a mental note of Lockhart‘s message, and throws the letter in the dustbin. He intends to buy the book, and makes a reminder note to write back to Lockhart and send him a sum of 200 Galleons.Ron receives the letter and immediately writes back to Lockhart saying that he would like to buy the book. He posts the letter, the letter reaches Lockhart, but he then decides not to offer the discount or even sell the book to Ron.Question:Has Lockhart made Sirius an offer?a)Yes, by informing Sirius of the desire to sell,he makes an offer to sell the book.b)No, this is not an offer. He has merely asked Sirius what he thinks of Lockhart‘s desire to sell the book.c)Can‘t say if this is an offer or invitation to offer.d)None of the above.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice Principle 1 – An offer is the final expression of willingness by the offeror to be bound by his offer, should the other party choose to accept it.Principle 2 – An invitation to offer merely invites others to make offers that one may or may not accept. It is not an offer in itself.Principle 3 – Acceptance needs to be communicated to the offeror.Facts – Lockhart writes to his closest friend and aide, Helga, ―I wish to sell my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons.‖He then sends a letter to Sirius – ―Sirius, I have been meaning to sell my book, the one that chronicles our adolescent experiments in love and other adventures. What do you think?‖He also writes to Harry – ―Harry, I am your biggest fan. Would you like to buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons?‖ and to Ron ―Ron, I see that you are in need of advice on matters of the heart. Why don‘t you buy my book, A Cauldron Full of Hot Strong Love, for 200 Galleons? Willing to offer a discount of 20%.‖Harry sees the letter, makes a mental note of Lockhart‘s message, and throws the letter in the dustbin. He intends to buy the book, and makes a reminder note to write back to Lockhart and send him a sum of 200 Galleons.Ron receives the letter and immediately writes back to Lockhart saying that he would like to buy the book. He posts the letter, the letter reaches Lockhart, but he then decides not to offer the discount or even sell the book to Ron.Question:Has Lockhart made Sirius an offer?a)Yes, by informing Sirius of the desire to sell,he makes an offer to sell the book.b)No, this is not an offer. He has merely asked Sirius what he thinks of Lockhart‘s desire to sell the book.c)Can‘t say if this is an offer or invitation to offer.d)None of the above.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice CLAT tests.
Explore Courses for CLAT exam

Top Courses for CLAT

Explore Courses
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev