What are the drawbacks of Thomson's & Rutherford's Model of atom?
According to JJ Thomson’s atomic model.
An atom is a positively charged sphere. Electrons are set within the sphere.
An atom is electrically neutral.
Drawbacks of J J Thomson:
In J J Thomson plum pudding model no separation between electrons and protons as they are hold together inside the atom which is not possible and leads to un-stability of the atom. But atom is existing stable.
Rutherford’s atomic Model of atom:
In order to get more information about the structure of atom Ernest Ruther ford has conducted alpha ray scattering experiment. From the experiment he proved that nucleus is positively charged and it is present at the center of the atom.
At yellow spotted region the Alpha particles were deflected and reflected. The deflection and reflection is due to the repulsion between fast moving alpha particles and positively charged nucleus
Drawbacks of Rutherford’s atomic model:
1. According to Rutherford’s atomic model an electron continuously revolving around the nucleus in circular orbits but according electromagnetic theory any charged particle revolving will emit radiation and lose energy so that it should lose energy and fell into nucleus. If electron loses energy then it fell into nucleus this causes atom collapse. But this not happened, atom very much stable. This is one drawback of Rutherford’s atomic model.
2. This theory does not explain anything about the arrangement of electrons.
This question is part of UPSC exam. View all Class 9 courses
What are the drawbacks of Thomson's & Rutherford's Model of atom?
Drawbacks of Rutherford model of an atom are .
1. an electron moving in a circular orbit is not said to be stable .
2. when electron move it radiates energy
3. an electron go on acceleration and finally fall into nucleus .
so this can't said to be stable ,it is unstable
What are the drawbacks of Thomson's & Rutherford's Model of atom?
Thomson's atomic model, also known as the plum pudding model or the raisin bun model, has several drawbacks:
1. Lack of a dense nucleus: Thomson's model proposed that the positive charge and electrons were evenly distributed throughout the atom, resembling a plum pudding or a raisin bun. However, later experiments, such as the gold foil experiment by Ernest Rutherford, showed that the positive charge is concentrated in a small, dense nucleus at the center of the atom. Thomson's model failed to account for this.
2. Failure to explain the stability of the atom: Thomson's model did not address why electrons, which are negatively charged particles, do not simply collapse into the positively charged nucleus. It did not provide an explanation for the stability of the atom or the existence of different energy levels for electrons.
3. Lack of atomic structure: The plum pudding model did not propose the existence of specific energy levels or orbitals for electrons. It did not explain how electrons are arranged around the nucleus or why certain energy levels are filled before others. It also did not account for the concept of electron shells.
4. Inability to explain spectral lines: Thomson's model was unable to explain the observed spectral lines in atomic emission or absorption spectra. These lines are a result of transitions between specific energy levels of electrons, which were not accounted for in the plum pudding model.
5. Failure to explain isotopes: Thomson's model did not account for the existence of isotopes, which are atoms of the same element with different numbers of neutrons. It did not provide an explanation for the variation in atomic mass observed in different samples of the same element.
Overall, while Thomson's atomic model was a significant step in understanding atomic structure, it had several drawbacks and was eventually replaced by more accurate models, such as Rutherford's nuclear model and Bohr's model of the atom.
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed Class 9 study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in Class 9.