Comparison between Mrs. Packletide and Luna Bimberton
Background
Mrs. Packletide is a character from the short story "Mrs. Packletide's Tiger" by Saki, while Luna Bimberton is a character from the short story "The Luncheon" by W. Somerset Maugham. Both stories were written during the early 20th century and reflect the social norms and values of the time.
Personality
Mrs. Packletide is portrayed as a manipulative and selfish woman who is obsessed with social status. She is willing to go to great lengths, including the hunting and killing of a tiger, to achieve her goal of being the first woman in her social circle to ride in an airplane. Luna Bimberton, on the other hand, is portrayed as a vain and shallow woman who is more concerned with appearances than substance. She is more interested in attending high-profile events and being seen with the right people than in any actual intellectual pursuits.
Motivations
Mrs. Packletide's primary motivation is to achieve social status and recognition. She is willing to spend a large amount of money on the tiger hunt and to endure the disapproval of her peers to achieve her goal of riding in an airplane. Luna Bimberton's motivations are more superficial. She is motivated by the desire to be seen as fashionable and popular, and to attend the right events and be seen with the right people.
Social Status
Both characters are concerned with social status, but in different ways. Mrs. Packletide is obsessed with being seen as the first woman in her social circle to ride in an airplane and is willing to go to great lengths to achieve this goal. Luna Bimberton is more concerned with being seen as fashionable and popular and is willing to spend a large amount of money on a lunch with a famous author to achieve this goal.
Morality
Mrs. Packletide's actions in killing a tiger and then lying about it to her social circle are morally dubious. Luna Bimberton's actions in spending a large amount of money on a lunch to impress her social circle are less obviously immoral, but still reflect a certain shallowness and lack of substance.
In conclusion, while both Mrs. Packletide and Luna Bimberton are concerned with social status and recognition, their motivations, personalities, and actions differ significantly. Mrs. Packletide is more manipulative and willing to go to great lengths to achieve her goals, while Luna Bimberton is more superficial and concerned with appearances rather than substance.