UPSC Exam  >  UPSC Notes  >  History Optional for UPSC (Notes)  >  Nature of Mughal State

Nature of Mughal State | History Optional for UPSC (Notes) PDF Download

Introduction

Nature of the Mughal State Shaped by Akbar:

  • Akbar played a crucial role in defining and shaping the Mughal state system.
  • He established a broad framework for the state, which continued with some variations in later periods.

Historians' Interpretations:

  • Different historians have offered various interpretations to explain the nature of the Mughal state.

War state 

War and Military Preparation in Medieval Times:

  • War was a common occurrence necessary for sustaining and expanding territories.
  • Military preparation was always crucial due to the frequent conflicts of the medieval period.
  • During medieval times, states were generally characterized as military and war-focused because survival depended on military strength and the ability to wage wars.

Conquest state 

Mughal Empire: Foreign Conquest to Indigenous Rule:

  • The Mughal Empire initially represented a foreign conquest when Babur invaded India in the 16th century.
  • However, over time, the Mughals became indigenous in various aspects:
  • Political: The Mughals integrated into and eventually dominated the Indian political landscape.
  • Economic: They contributed to and shaped the Indian economy, becoming a fundamental part of it.
  • Social: The Mughals influenced and adapted to Indian social structures and norms.
  • Cultural: They blended with and enriched Indian culture, becoming a vital part of it.

Military state 

Mansab System and Militarization:

  • The Mansab system was a key feature of the Mughal state, representing the militarization of services.
  • Under this system, everyone was placed under military payroll, with the Mansab essentially serving as a military rank.

Integration of Services:

  • The Mansab system integrated all services within the state, giving it a strong military character.
  • This integration was crucial for the functioning and organization of the Mughal administration.

Benevolent despotic state 

Akbar's Rule: Benevolent Despotism:

  • Akbar's rule is seen as benevolent despotism due to its high ideals, which continued under his successors, Jahangir and Shah Jahan.
  • Akbar's theory of kingship defined important aspects of state nature.
  • He aimed to create a pan-India polity based on the principle of Sulh-e-kul, promoting harmony among diverse communities.
  • The state had a multi-religious character, reflecting a secular orientation.
  • Divine aspects of kingship were also emphasized.
  • The Mughal state system under Akbar was reformist, impacting political and social fields.
  • It included welfare,secular, and equality elements, showcasing progressive traits of a modern political system.

Centralised state 

State System under the Mughals:

  • The Mughal state was characterized by centralized systems, including central departments and political-administrative units directly under the Mughal emperor.
  • Historian Irfan Habib views the Mughal state as centralized, particularly regarding its economic organization.
  • Mansab-Jagir system: A key aspect of the Mughal administrative structure, involving ranks (mansabs) and land grants (jagirs) to officials.
  • Fiscal system: The land revenue system was a crucial part of the Mughal economy.
  • Monetary system: The coinage system was important for trade and economic stability.
  • Historian Athar Alialso emphasizes the centralization of the Mughal state through the:
    • Mansab-Jagir system
    • Composite nobility: A diverse nobility that included various ethnic and regional groups.
    • Religious ideological approaches: Such as Tauhid-i-Ilahi and Sulh-i-kul, which promoted a unified religious and political ideology.
  • Criticism: Historians like Muzaffar Alam,Chetan Singh, and S. Subramaniam question the idea of a centralized Mughal system. They argue that the Mughal administration was not uniformly imposed and varied significantly from region to region, as seen in their studies of Punjab and Awadh.

Monarchical state 

  • The head of state and government was a monarch.
  • The king held absolute power, with all others being subordinate to him.
  • The king served as the head of justice,commander-in-chief, and supreme legislator.

Patrimonial state 

Peter Hardy and Stephen Blake's Perspective on the Mughal State:

  • Peter Hardy and Stephen Blake draw inspiration from Max Weber's concepts and apply them to analyze the Mughal state.
  • They describe the Mughal state as a household-dominated,patrimonial, and bureaucratic system.

Bureaucratic state 

  • The Suba system (Suba-Sarkar-Pargana) was the foundation of the bureaucratic state system, characterized by various administrative units and officials.
  • Rule-based system: Detailed rules and regulations were established for provincial and district-level administration. New rules were continually introduced through the Dastur-ul-Amal, which contained guidelines on rules, regulations, rents, and more.
  • An important feature was the principle of separation of powers and checks and balances. This principle was implemented from the top down and existed at the central, provincial, and district levels. It aimed to prevent the abuse of power.

Paper Government 

By Jadunath Sarkar.

  • Based on the functioning of the Mughal state, which was marked by written practices.
  • Contemporary records indicate that directions and orders were not given verbally.
  • The issuance of farmans, maintenance of state accounts, and receipt of messages from spies reflect this pattern.

Nature of State in western writing 

Influence of Bernier's Descriptions on Western Theorists:

  • Bernier's observations had a significant impact on Western thinkers starting from the eighteenth century.

Montesquieu's Interpretation:

  • The French philosopher Montesquieu drew from Bernier's account to formulate the concept of oriental despotism.
  • He believed that rulers in Asia held absolute power over their subjects, who lived in subjugation and poverty.

Karl Marx and the Asiatic Mode of Production:

  • In the nineteenth century, Karl Marx expanded upon this idea by introducing the Asiatic mode of production.
  • He claimed that in pre-colonial India, the state was responsible for appropriating surplus wealth.

Characteristics of the Pre-Colonial State:

  • Marx described the state as strongcentralizedcoercivedespoticstatic, and stagnant.

Diverse Interpretations of the Mughal State:

  • The nature of the Mughal state has been interpreted in various ways by different scholars.
  • Each interpretation has its limitations, making it challenging to categorize the state definitively.
The document Nature of Mughal State | History Optional for UPSC (Notes) is a part of the UPSC Course History Optional for UPSC (Notes).
All you need of UPSC at this link: UPSC
70 videos|815 docs

Top Courses for UPSC

FAQs on Nature of Mughal State - History Optional for UPSC (Notes)

1. What are the key characteristics of the Mughal state as a war state?
Ans. The Mughal state can be classified as a war state due to its reliance on military power for expansion and control. Key characteristics include a strong standing army, focus on conquest to expand territory, and the use of military campaigns to suppress rebellions. The emperors, like Akbar and Aurangzeb, emphasized military prowess and established a centralized system to maintain order and authority through force if necessary.
2. How does the Mughal state function as a benevolent despotic state?
Ans. The Mughal state exemplifies a benevolent despotic state through its emphasis on the welfare of its subjects while maintaining absolute power. Emperors like Akbar implemented policies of religious tolerance, cultural integration, and economic prosperity. They aimed to create a harmonious society, thus justifying their rule and central authority while still exercising despotism.
3. In what ways was the Mughal state a bureaucratic state?
Ans. The Mughal state functioned as a bureaucratic state through a complex administrative system that managed various aspects of governance, taxation, and law. The establishment of a detailed revenue system, appointment of officials (nawabs), and reliance on written records for administration reflect the bureaucratic nature. This system allowed for effective governance over a vast empire, ensuring stability and revenue collection.
4. What role did the monarchical state play in the governance of the Mughal Empire?
Ans. The Mughal Empire was fundamentally a monarchical state where the emperor held supreme authority. This centralized power structure allowed emperors to implement policies directly and maintain control over vast territories. The legitimacy of the monarchy was often reinforced through lineage, divine right, and the emperor's role as a protector of the realm, contributing to the stability of the state.
5. How did the concept of a paper government manifest in the Mughal state?
Ans. The term "paper government" refers to the reliance on written laws and documents for governance. In the Mughal state, this was evident through the extensive use of administrative records, legal codes, and formal treaties. The emphasis on documentation facilitated the management of the empire's vast resources and diverse population, ensuring that policies were implemented uniformly and that the emperor's commands were clear and actionable.
70 videos|815 docs
Download as PDF
Explore Courses for UPSC exam

Top Courses for UPSC

Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev
Related Searches

Free

,

Semester Notes

,

Nature of Mughal State | History Optional for UPSC (Notes)

,

Extra Questions

,

video lectures

,

Viva Questions

,

Nature of Mughal State | History Optional for UPSC (Notes)

,

shortcuts and tricks

,

mock tests for examination

,

practice quizzes

,

Previous Year Questions with Solutions

,

Exam

,

study material

,

ppt

,

Important questions

,

Objective type Questions

,

Summary

,

Sample Paper

,

pdf

,

past year papers

,

MCQs

,

Nature of Mughal State | History Optional for UPSC (Notes)

;