Sansad TV: Caste Census in India | Current Affairs & Hindu Analysis: Daily, Weekly & Monthly - UPSC PDF Download

Benefits of Conducting a Caste Census

• Advantages in Policy Making: The purpose of a caste census goes beyond addressing reservations. It helps shed light on the numerous issues that a democratic country must address, particularly the significant number of people who are marginalized, deprived, or engaged in certain occupations.
• Identifying the Marginalized: A caste census effectively identifies individuals who are marginalized, deprived, and engaged in specific occupations. It also reveals the influence that caste-based institutions hold over them.
• Highlighting Privileged Sections of Society: Caste not only brings disadvantages but also confers significant privilege and advantage within our society.
• Addressing Prevalent Inequalities: The unequal distribution of wealth, resources, and education has resulted in a lack of purchasing power among the majority of Indians.
• Constitutional Obligation: Conducting a caste census aligns with our Constitution. Article 340 mandates the appointment of a commission to investigate the conditions of socially and educationally backward classes, along with recommending necessary steps for the government to take.
• Caste is Not Limited to Marginalized: We should move away from the notion that caste only applies to disadvantaged or poor individuals. Caste extends beyond these categories.
• Breaking Caste Rigidity: Counting castes does not perpetuate the caste system. A caste census can debunk myths surrounding caste elitism.
• Dispelling Myths: Various myths deprive a significant number of people, particularly those on the margins.
• Reducing Inclusion and Exclusion Errors: Accurate caste data enables the identification of the most backward castes.
• Judicial Support: Indian courts have consistently emphasized the importance of having adequate caste-related data, especially regarding reservations.

Challenges of Conducting a Caste Census

• Repercussions of a Caste Census: Caste carries emotional weight, leading to political and social repercussions when conducting a caste census.
• Solidifying Identities: There are concerns that caste enumeration may solidify or intensify caste identities.
• Data Availability Issues: Due to the aforementioned repercussions, a considerable amount of data from the SECC remains unreleased or is only partially available, even after nearly a decade.
• Caste is Context-Specific: Caste does not serve as a substitute for class or deprivation in India. It represents a distinct form of entrenched discrimination that often surpasses class boundaries.
• Breach of the 50% Reservation Cap: A Socio-Economic Caste Census is seen as the way to argue for breaching the 50% reservation limit and rationalizing the reservation system in the country.
• Increasing Assertiveness: Neglecting caste-related issues leads to the preservation and protection of caste. This trend has been observed in many states.
• Chaos: Gathering caste-related data poses a significant challenge as it can be invasive. However, a balance must be struck to empower individuals and ensure equal citizenship.
• Social Friction: Identifying castes can create friction among different social classes.

The Way Forward

• India must bravely and decisively tackle caste issues through data and statistics, similar to how the United States addresses race issues. This involves collecting data on race, class, language, inter-race marriages, and other relevant metrics.
• Establishment of a National Data Bank: The Sachar Committee Report recommended the creation of a national data bank.

Conclusion

• With each passing day and increasing social awareness, the urgency to eradicate the caste system becomes more apparent. Dr. BR Ambedkar stated that for India to achieve pride among nations, caste must be eradicated first.
• Improving existing databases is more crucial than debating whether to conduct a caste census. Accurate and timely data is vital for India's efforts to combat poverty, as poor data undermines welfare program design.
• The 21st century presents the ideal opportunity to address India's caste issue. Failure to do so would have significant sociological, political, and economic consequences, causing India to lag behind in development.