Why law of independent assortment is not universally accepted ?
•The law of independent assortments states that when two pairs of traits are combined in a hybrid, one pair of character segregates independent of the other pair of character.
•However, there are many genes that are located on a single chromosome and are linked to each other and are passed as such from parents to offspring.
•Hence, the Law of independent assortment is valid only for those traits that are not linked.
Why law of independent assortment is not universally accepted ?
Introduction:
The law of independent assortment, also known as Mendel's second law, states that the alleles for different traits segregate independently during the formation of gametes. This means that the inheritance of one trait does not affect the inheritance of another trait. While this law has been widely accepted and forms the basis of modern genetics, there are some reasons why it is not universally accepted.
Lack of understanding during Mendel's time:
1. Limited technology: During Gregor Mendel's time, the technology and knowledge in the field of genetics were limited. Mendel conducted his experiments on pea plants in the mid-19th century, and his work was not widely recognized until many years later. The lack of advanced tools and techniques hindered the full understanding and acceptance of the law of independent assortment.
Exceptions to the law:
2. Linked genes: The law of independent assortment assumes that genes for different traits assort independently, but this is not always the case. Sometimes, genes are located close to each other on the same chromosome, and they tend to be inherited together. These genes are said to be linked, and their inheritance violates the law of independent assortment.
3. Epistasis: Epistasis is a phenomenon where one gene masks or modifies the expression of another gene. In such cases, the inheritance of one trait depends on the presence or absence of another gene, breaking the principle of independent assortment.
4. Environmental factors: The law of independent assortment assumes that the inheritance of traits is solely determined by the genetic makeup. However, environmental factors can also influence the expression of genes, leading to variations in phenotypes that do not follow the expected patterns of independent assortment.
Complexity of genetics:
5. Multiple genes: Many traits are controlled by multiple genes, and their interactions can be complex. The law of independent assortment simplifies inheritance patterns by considering only one gene at a time, which may not accurately reflect the true complexity of genetic inheritance.
6. Exceptions in other organisms: While Mendel's experiments were primarily conducted on pea plants, the law of independent assortment does not always hold true for all organisms. Different organisms may have different genetic mechanisms and inheritance patterns, leading to exceptions to the law.
Conclusion:
Although the law of independent assortment is a fundamental principle in genetics, it is not universally accepted due to the limitations of understanding during Mendel's time, exceptions to the law, and the complexity of genetic interactions. Advances in technology and further research have provided a more nuanced understanding of genetic inheritance, highlighting the need to consider various factors beyond the simple principles outlined by Mendel.
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed Class 10 study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in Class 10.