Alan: Industrialization helps in achieving a variety of social objectives such as employment, gender equality and poverty eradication. Thus, extensive industrialization must be promoted for the welfare of a nation.Charlie: But you must also take into consideration that extensive industrial processes can have negative environmental impacts such as climate change, loss of natural resources and extinction of species. These threaten the economic and social welfare of a nation. Thus, a nation should promote the positive impacts of industrial development while limiting or eliminating its negative impacts.Charlie objects to Alans argument bya)claiming that Alan has exaggerated the positive impacts of industrialization.b)showing that Alan has based his argument on a limited understanding of the impact of industrialization.c)rejecting Alans argument as flawed.d)contradicting the evidence that Alan has used to support his argument.e)suggesting that the positive impacts of industrialization have severe drawbacks that Alan has not taken into account.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?

Explore Courses UPSC Exam UPSC Test Series Free Notes EduRev Infinity

Open App

GMAT Exam > GMAT Questions > Alan: Industrialization helps in achieving a ...

Join the Discussion on the App

Charlie: But you must also take into consideration that extensive industrial processes can have negative environmental impacts such as climate change, loss of natural resources and extinction of species. These threaten the economic and social welfare of a nation. Thus, a nation should promote the positive impacts of industrial development while limiting or eliminating its negative impacts.

Charlie objects to Alan’s argument by

a)
claiming that Alan has exaggerated the positive impacts of industrialization.
b)
showing that Alan has based his argument on a limited understanding of the impact of industrialization.
c)
rejecting Alan’s argument as flawed.
d)
contradicting the evidence that Alan has used to support his argument.
e)
suggesting that the positive impacts of industrialization have severe drawbacks that Alan has not taken into account.

Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?

FREE This question is part of

Test: Flaw Questions

Attempt Test

Attempt this Test

Verified Answer

Alan: Industrialization helps in achieving a variety of social objecti...

Argument Analysis

Pre-Thinking

In order to see how Charlie objected to Alan’s argument, we will look at the logical structure, focusing on the reasoning in both the arguments.

We would first look at the argument presented by Alan and then see which strategy Charlie has used in his objection. Let’s look at both the arguments:

Alan’s Argument

Conclusion: Extensive industrialization must be promoted for the welfare of a nation.

Reasoning: Industrialization helps in achieving a variety of social objectives.

Charlie’s Argument

Conclusion: A nation should promote the positive impacts of industrial development while limiting or eliminating its negative impacts.

Reasoning: Extensive industrial processes can have negative environmental impacts which threaten the economic and social welfare of a nation.

Charlie’s reasoning suggests that Alan should also consider the negative impacts of extensive industrialization. Note: While drawing his conclusion, Alan has only considered positive impacts of industrialization.

With this pre-thinking in mind, let’s evaluate the answer choices.

Answer Choices

claiming that Alan has exaggerated the positive impacts of industrialization.

Incorrect - Irrelevant

Charlie doesn’t dispute the extent of the positive impacts stated by Alan.

showing that Alan has based his argument on a limited understanding of the impact of industrialization.

Correct

This option is written along the lines of pre-thinking.

rejecting Alan’s argument as flawed.

Incorrect - Irrelevant

Charlie neither disputes the positive impacts indicated nor the conclusion drawn by Alan. He only raises a consideration that should be accounted for while implementing Alan’s suggestion.

contradicting the evidence that Alan has used to support his argument.

Incorrect - Irrelevant

As stated earlier, Charlie doesn’t dispute the positive effects listed by Alan.

suggesting that the positive impacts of industrialization have severe drawbacks that Alan has not taken into account.

Incorrect - Irrelevant

Charlie does not suggest severe drawbacks of the positive effects listed by Alan. Instead, he brings forth certain separate negative impacts of extensive industrialization.

View all questions of this test

View all answers Start learning for free

< Previous Question Next Question >

Explore Courses for GMAT exam

Similar GMAT Doubts

Globally, about a third of the food produced for human consumption goes to waste, implying that a third of the water, land use, energy and financial resources that go into producing it are also squandered. Yet people often think of food as environmentally benign because it is biodegradable, while label food packaging as a wasteful use of resources leading to nothing but more pollution, despite the reality that the energy that goes into packaging makes up a mere 10% of the total energy that goes into producing, transporting, storing and preparing food. Needless to say, their view ignores the negative impact of food production, supply, and consumption, and the benefits possible from the right kind of food packaging.Indeed the dislike for food packaging is not all baseless. There is a lot of bad and wasteful packaging out there. But any assessment of its impact on the environment must take into account the benefits one can derive from packaging in the shape of reduced food waste that can be realized by protecting and dispensing food properly. For instance, two percent of the milk produced in the US goes bad on supermarket shelves before it can be purchased. This dairy waste can be avoided with packaging technology such as Tetra Pak that saves milk from spoiling, even without refrigeration. However, environmentally aware consumers tend to dislike Tetra Pak material because they think it cannot be recycled. The truth, however, is that it can be recycled, but the process is rather complicated. Irrespective of the recycling aspect, Tetra Pak is a good environmental bet because it can extend the shelf life of milk up to nine months, reducing the need for refrigeration and reducing the amount of milk that goes bad on retail shelves. Clearly, the environmental benefit of the food-protection technology outweighs the negative impact of the packaging itself.Which of the following statement can be derived from the passage?

View answer

Globally, about a third of the food produced for human consumption goes to waste, implying that a third of the water, land use, energy and financial resources that go into producing it are also squandered. Yet people often think of food as environmentally benign because it is biodegradable, while label food packaging as a wasteful use of resources leading to nothing but more pollution, despite the reality that the energy that goes into packaging makes up a mere 10% of the total energy that goes into producing, transporting, storing and preparing food. Needless to say, their view ignores the negative impact of food production, supply, and consumption, and the benefits possible from the right kind of food packaging.Indeed the dislike for food packaging is not all baseless. There is a lot of bad and wasteful packaging out there. But any assessment of its impact on the environment must take into account the benefits one can derive from packaging in the shape of reduced food waste that can be realized by protecting and dispensing food properly. For instance, two percent of the milk produced in the US goes bad on supermarket shelves before it can be purchased. This dairy waste can be avoided with packaging technology such as Tetra Pak that saves milk from spoiling, even without refrigeration. However, environmentally aware consumers tend to dislike Tetra Pak material because they think it cannot be recycled. The truth, however, is that it can be recycled, but the process is rather complicated. Irrespective of the recycling aspect, Tetra Pak is a good environmental bet because it can extend the shelf life of milk up to nine months, reducing the need for refrigeration and reducing the amount of milk that goes bad on retail shelves. Clearly, the environmental benefit of the food-protection technology outweighs the negative impact of the packaging itself.Which of the following is the function of the first paragraph in the passage?

View answer

PerarecentsurveycarriedoutinRamboCity, capital of Papula country, an average middle-aged person drives his or her car for two thousand milesinayear and 99% of these people ownagasoline-run car.Inaddition, thesurveysuggested that if offered an economical option to switch to electric cars, most of these people would change their gasoline-run cars. The government of Papula is impressed with the environmental considerations shown by the citizens of Papula and is planning to implementaplan that would allow all the current owners of gasoline-run cars to switch to electric cars ataminimal cost.Which of the following statements casts the most doubt on the ability of the plan to meet its required objective of reducing air pollutioninPapula by 20%inthe next 5 years?

View answer

Direction: Read the following Passage and Answer the following Question.As urban landscapes continue to expand, the rise of vertical farming is becoming a crucial element in the quest for sustainable city living. Vertical farms, which grow crops in stacked layers within a controlled environment, offer a revolutionary approach to agriculture in urban settings. This innovative method of farming is not just about saving space; its about reimagining how we produce food in the face of growing environmental challenges.One of the key advantages of vertical farming is its minimal use of water and pesticides. Unlike traditional agriculture, which relies heavily on these resources, vertical farms use hydroponic systems that circulate water efficiently and eliminate the need for soil and large-scale pesticide use. This approach significantly reduces the environmental impact of farming.Another significant benefit is the reduction in food miles. Vertical farms can be established within urban areas, drastically cutting down the distance food travels from farm to consumer. This not only ensures fresher produce but also reduces transportation emissions, contributing to lower carbon footprints.However, vertical farming faces its own set of challenges. The initial setup and operational costs can be high, making it difficult for these farms to compete with traditional agriculture in terms of cost. Additionally, the energy requirements for maintaining controlled environments, such as lighting and temperature control, are substantial. Critics argue that unless renewable energy sources power these farms, they may not be as sustainable as they seem.Despite these challenges, the potential of vertical farming in reshaping urban agriculture remains immense. As technology advances, the efficiency of these farms is expected to improve, making them a vital component in the development of sustainable cities.Q.Based on the passage, which of the following can be inferred about vertical farms compared to traditional farms?

View answer

Direction: Read the following Passage and Answer the following Question.As urban landscapes continue to expand, the rise of vertical farming is becoming a crucial element in the quest for sustainable city living. Vertical farms, which grow crops in stacked layers within a controlled environment, offer a revolutionary approach to agriculture in urban settings. This innovative method of farming is not just about saving space; its about reimagining how we produce food in the face of growing environmental challenges.One of the key advantages of vertical farming is its minimal use of water and pesticides. Unlike traditional agriculture, which relies heavily on these resources, vertical farms use hydroponic systems that circulate water efficiently and eliminate the need for soil and large-scale pesticide use. This approach significantly reduces the environmental impact of farming.Another significant benefit is the reduction in food miles. Vertical farms can be established within urban areas, drastically cutting down the distance food travels from farm to consumer. This not only ensures fresher produce but also reduces transportation emissions, contributing to lower carbon footprints.However, vertical farming faces its own set of challenges. The initial setup and operational costs can be high, making it difficult for these farms to compete with traditional agriculture in terms of cost. Additionally, the energy requirements for maintaining controlled environments, such as lighting and temperature control, are substantial. Critics argue that unless renewable energy sources power these farms, they may not be as sustainable as they seem.Despite these challenges, the potential of vertical farming in reshaping urban agriculture remains immense. As technology advances, the efficiency of these farms is expected to improve, making them a vital component in the development of sustainable cities.Q.Which of the following concerns about vertical farming is mentioned in the passage?

View answer

Top Courses for GMATView all

GMAT Focus Edition Mock Test Series 2024

Quantitative for GMAT

Crash Course for GMAT

Data Insights for GMAT

100 RCs for GMAT

Top Courses for GMAT

View all

Alan: Industrialization helps in achieving a variety of social objectives such as employment, gender equality and poverty eradication. Thus, extensive industrialization must be promoted for the welfare of a nation.Charlie: But you must also take into consideration that extensive industrial processes can have negative environmental impacts such as climate change, loss of natural resources and extinction of species. These threaten the economic and social welfare of a nation. Thus, a nation should promote the positive impacts of industrial development while limiting or eliminating its negative impacts.Charlie objects to Alan’s argument bya)claiming that Alan has exaggerated the positive impacts of industrialization.b)showing that Alan has based his argument on a limited understanding of the impact of industrialization.c)rejecting Alan’s argument as flawed.d)contradicting the evidence that Alan has used to support his argument.e)suggesting that the positive impacts of industrialization have severe drawbacks that Alan has not taken into account.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?

Share with a Friend

Answer this doubt

Question Description
Alan: Industrialization helps in achieving a variety of social objectives such as employment, gender equality and poverty eradication. Thus, extensive industrialization must be promoted for the welfare of a nation.Charlie: But you must also take into consideration that extensive industrial processes can have negative environmental impacts such as climate change, loss of natural resources and extinction of species. These threaten the economic and social welfare of a nation. Thus, a nation should promote the positive impacts of industrial development while limiting or eliminating its negative impacts.Charlie objects to Alan’s argument bya)claiming that Alan has exaggerated the positive impacts of industrialization.b)showing that Alan has based his argument on a limited understanding of the impact of industrialization.c)rejecting Alan’s argument as flawed.d)contradicting the evidence that Alan has used to support his argument.e)suggesting that the positive impacts of industrialization have severe drawbacks that Alan has not taken into account.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? for GMAT 2024 is part of GMAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the GMAT exam syllabus. Information about Alan: Industrialization helps in achieving a variety of social objectives such as employment, gender equality and poverty eradication. Thus, extensive industrialization must be promoted for the welfare of a nation.Charlie: But you must also take into consideration that extensive industrial processes can have negative environmental impacts such as climate change, loss of natural resources and extinction of species. These threaten the economic and social welfare of a nation. Thus, a nation should promote the positive impacts of industrial development while limiting or eliminating its negative impacts.Charlie objects to Alan’s argument bya)claiming that Alan has exaggerated the positive impacts of industrialization.b)showing that Alan has based his argument on a limited understanding of the impact of industrialization.c)rejecting Alan’s argument as flawed.d)contradicting the evidence that Alan has used to support his argument.e)suggesting that the positive impacts of industrialization have severe drawbacks that Alan has not taken into account.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for GMAT 2024 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Alan: Industrialization helps in achieving a variety of social objectives such as employment, gender equality and poverty eradication. Thus, extensive industrialization must be promoted for the welfare of a nation.Charlie: But you must also take into consideration that extensive industrial processes can have negative environmental impacts such as climate change, loss of natural resources and extinction of species. These threaten the economic and social welfare of a nation. Thus, a nation should promote the positive impacts of industrial development while limiting or eliminating its negative impacts.Charlie objects to Alan’s argument bya)claiming that Alan has exaggerated the positive impacts of industrialization.b)showing that Alan has based his argument on a limited understanding of the impact of industrialization.c)rejecting Alan’s argument as flawed.d)contradicting the evidence that Alan has used to support his argument.e)suggesting that the positive impacts of industrialization have severe drawbacks that Alan has not taken into account.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?.

Solutions for Alan: Industrialization helps in achieving a variety of social objectives such as employment, gender equality and poverty eradication. Thus, extensive industrialization must be promoted for the welfare of a nation.Charlie: But you must also take into consideration that extensive industrial processes can have negative environmental impacts such as climate change, loss of natural resources and extinction of species. These threaten the economic and social welfare of a nation. Thus, a nation should promote the positive impacts of industrial development while limiting or eliminating its negative impacts.Charlie objects to Alan’s argument bya)claiming that Alan has exaggerated the positive impacts of industrialization.b)showing that Alan has based his argument on a limited understanding of the impact of industrialization.c)rejecting Alan’s argument as flawed.d)contradicting the evidence that Alan has used to support his argument.e)suggesting that the positive impacts of industrialization have severe drawbacks that Alan has not taken into account.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for GMAT. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for GMAT Exam by signing up for free.

Here you can find the meaning of Alan: Industrialization helps in achieving a variety of social objectives such as employment, gender equality and poverty eradication. Thus, extensive industrialization must be promoted for the welfare of a nation.Charlie: But you must also take into consideration that extensive industrial processes can have negative environmental impacts such as climate change, loss of natural resources and extinction of species. These threaten the economic and social welfare of a nation. Thus, a nation should promote the positive impacts of industrial development while limiting or eliminating its negative impacts.Charlie objects to Alan’s argument bya)claiming that Alan has exaggerated the positive impacts of industrialization.b)showing that Alan has based his argument on a limited understanding of the impact of industrialization.c)rejecting Alan’s argument as flawed.d)contradicting the evidence that Alan has used to support his argument.e)suggesting that the positive impacts of industrialization have severe drawbacks that Alan has not taken into account.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of Alan: Industrialization helps in achieving a variety of social objectives such as employment, gender equality and poverty eradication. Thus, extensive industrialization must be promoted for the welfare of a nation.Charlie: But you must also take into consideration that extensive industrial processes can have negative environmental impacts such as climate change, loss of natural resources and extinction of species. These threaten the economic and social welfare of a nation. Thus, a nation should promote the positive impacts of industrial development while limiting or eliminating its negative impacts.Charlie objects to Alan’s argument bya)claiming that Alan has exaggerated the positive impacts of industrialization.b)showing that Alan has based his argument on a limited understanding of the impact of industrialization.c)rejecting Alan’s argument as flawed.d)contradicting the evidence that Alan has used to support his argument.e)suggesting that the positive impacts of industrialization have severe drawbacks that Alan has not taken into account.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for Alan: Industrialization helps in achieving a variety of social objectives such as employment, gender equality and poverty eradication. Thus, extensive industrialization must be promoted for the welfare of a nation.Charlie: But you must also take into consideration that extensive industrial processes can have negative environmental impacts such as climate change, loss of natural resources and extinction of species. These threaten the economic and social welfare of a nation. Thus, a nation should promote the positive impacts of industrial development while limiting or eliminating its negative impacts.Charlie objects to Alan’s argument bya)claiming that Alan has exaggerated the positive impacts of industrialization.b)showing that Alan has based his argument on a limited understanding of the impact of industrialization.c)rejecting Alan’s argument as flawed.d)contradicting the evidence that Alan has used to support his argument.e)suggesting that the positive impacts of industrialization have severe drawbacks that Alan has not taken into account.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of Alan: Industrialization helps in achieving a variety of social objectives such as employment, gender equality and poverty eradication. Thus, extensive industrialization must be promoted for the welfare of a nation.Charlie: But you must also take into consideration that extensive industrial processes can have negative environmental impacts such as climate change, loss of natural resources and extinction of species. These threaten the economic and social welfare of a nation. Thus, a nation should promote the positive impacts of industrial development while limiting or eliminating its negative impacts.Charlie objects to Alan’s argument bya)claiming that Alan has exaggerated the positive impacts of industrialization.b)showing that Alan has based his argument on a limited understanding of the impact of industrialization.c)rejecting Alan’s argument as flawed.d)contradicting the evidence that Alan has used to support his argument.e)suggesting that the positive impacts of industrialization have severe drawbacks that Alan has not taken into account.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice Alan: Industrialization helps in achieving a variety of social objectives such as employment, gender equality and poverty eradication. Thus, extensive industrialization must be promoted for the welfare of a nation.Charlie: But you must also take into consideration that extensive industrial processes can have negative environmental impacts such as climate change, loss of natural resources and extinction of species. These threaten the economic and social welfare of a nation. Thus, a nation should promote the positive impacts of industrial development while limiting or eliminating its negative impacts.Charlie objects to Alan’s argument bya)claiming that Alan has exaggerated the positive impacts of industrialization.b)showing that Alan has based his argument on a limited understanding of the impact of industrialization.c)rejecting Alan’s argument as flawed.d)contradicting the evidence that Alan has used to support his argument.e)suggesting that the positive impacts of industrialization have severe drawbacks that Alan has not taken into account.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice GMAT tests.

Explore Courses for GMAT exam