How is judicial activism can lead to a conflict between the judiciary and the legislature? Why?

Question

Answer

Because judiciary enters the jurisdiction area of legislature. that's why legislature gets offend.

Answer

Bcoz judiciary takes up.issues which belongs to leg. like bringing up eloctoral reforms, eradicating corruption and these are the issues to be resolved by legislature. it has lead to the balance among the three organs of government become very delicate. as power of every organ of government is mentioned in constn. and it should be respected. but judiciary taking up these issue might create strains on the democracy and basics of constitution

Answer

Judicial Activism and Conflict between the Judiciary and Legislature

Introduction:
Judicial activism refers to the tendency of judges to interpret laws in a way that promotes their own personal or political beliefs. While it is essential for judges to interpret and apply laws, excessive activism can lead to conflicts with the legislature. This essay will explore the reasons why judicial activism can lead to conflicts between the judiciary and the legislature.

1. Interference with Legislative Powers:
One of the main reasons for conflicts between the judiciary and the legislature due to judicial activism is the interference with legislative powers. When judges engage in activism, they may overstep their boundaries by making policy decisions that are traditionally the role of the legislature. This can lead to a clash between the two branches of government as the legislature may feel that their authority is being undermined.

2. Legislative Intent vs. Judicial Interpretation:
Another factor contributing to conflicts is the difference between legislative intent and judicial interpretation. Legislatures pass laws with a specific purpose in mind, which may be based on public opinion, societal needs, or political considerations. However, when judges engage in activism, they may interpret these laws in a way that goes against the original intent of the legislature. This can lead to a clash as the legislature may argue that judges are overstepping their authority and disregarding the will of the people.

3. Challenging Popular Legislation:
Judicial activism can also lead to conflicts when judges challenge popular legislation. Sometimes, legislatures pass laws that reflect the will of the majority and are supported by the public. However, when judges engage in activism, they may strike down or modify these laws based on their own personal or political beliefs. This can create a conflict between the judiciary and the legislature as the latter may feel that their decisions are being undermined and the democratic process is being subverted.

4. Impact on Separation of Powers:
Conflicts between the judiciary and the legislature can arise due to the impact of judicial activism on the separation of powers. The principle of separation of powers is a fundamental aspect of democratic governance, ensuring a system of checks and balances. However, when judges engage in activism, they may encroach upon the legislative domain, blurring the lines between the branches of government. This can lead to conflicts as the legislature may argue that the judiciary is exceeding its constitutional mandate.

Conclusion:
In conclusion, judicial activism can lead to conflicts between the judiciary and the legislature due to interference with legislative powers, differences in interpreting legislative intent, challenging popular legislation, and impacting the separation of powers. It is crucial for judges to strike a balance between interpreting laws and respecting the authority of the legislature to avoid such conflicts and maintain a harmonious functioning of the democratic system.

Similar Humanities/Arts Doubts

The executive plays a crucial role; the legislature has the powers of removal. This has ensured…

Which of the following is a feature of the Parliamentary form of government?

Top Courses for Humanities/ArtsView all

Chapter Notes for Humanities

NCERT Books & Solutions for Humanities

Online MCQ Tests for Humanities

Short & Long Question Answers for Humanities

Geography Class 11

Top Courses for Humanities/Arts

Top Courses for Humanities/Arts

Suggested Free Tests

Related Content

Humanities Courses

Other Courses

How To Prepare?

Other Exams

Company