CLAT Exam > CLAT Questions > Direction: In this section every question is...
Start Learning for Free
Direction: In this section every question is appended with facts and principles, and multiple choice answers.
You are required to read the facts carefully, then read the principles, apply the principles to the given facts and make a select one the option which is the most appropriate answer from the given choices.
Principle: For defamation the defamatory
statement needs to be published.
Facts: The defendant sent a defamatory telegram to the plaintiff saying, “You liar, you thief; you deserve to be jailed.” The plaintiff received the telegram and wants to sue the defendant since he believes these statements are baseless. Can he do so?
- a)The telegram is addressed to the plaintiff and it hasn’t been published.
- b)The message in the telegram is not defamatory hence publication does not matter.
- c)The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.
- d)None of the above
Correct answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?
Most Upvoted Answer
Direction: In this section every question is appended with facts and ...
The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.
Free Test
FREE
| Start Free Test |
Community Answer
Direction: In this section every question is appended with facts and ...
Answer:
Facts:
- The defendant sent a defamatory telegram to the plaintiff saying, “You liar, you thief; you deserve to be jailed.”
- The plaintiff received the telegram and wants to sue the defendant since he believes these statements are baseless.
Principle:
For defamation, the defamatory statement needs to be published.
Explanation:
Defamation is a civil wrong that occurs when a false statement is communicated to a third party, which harms the reputation of an individual or entity. In order for a defamation claim to be successful, two key elements need to be established - a false statement and publication of that false statement.
In this case, the defendant sent a defamatory telegram directly to the plaintiff. However, the principle states that for a statement to be considered defamatory, it needs to be published. Publication refers to the communication of the defamatory statement to a third party who is not the plaintiff or the defendant. Therefore, in order for the plaintiff to successfully sue the defendant for defamation, the statement in the telegram must have been published to a third party.
Applying the principle to the facts:
- Option a) The telegram is addressed to the plaintiff and it hasn’t been published.
According to the principle, for defamation, publication is required. In this case, the telegram was addressed to the plaintiff, indicating that it was not intended to be communicated to a third party. Therefore, the defamatory statement has not been published.
- Option b) The message in the telegram is not defamatory hence publication does not matter.
The facts state that the telegram contains a defamatory statement. Therefore, this option is not applicable.
- Option c) The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.
There is no information in the facts to suggest that the telegram was seen by postal authorities or any other third party. Therefore, this option is not applicable.
- Option d) None of the above.
This option is not the correct answer as option a) is the most appropriate answer based on the principle and facts provided.
Conclusion:
Based on the principle that for defamation, the defamatory statement needs to be published, the plaintiff cannot sue the defendant in this case as the defamatory telegram was not published to a third party. Therefore, option a) is the most appropriate answer.
Facts:
- The defendant sent a defamatory telegram to the plaintiff saying, “You liar, you thief; you deserve to be jailed.”
- The plaintiff received the telegram and wants to sue the defendant since he believes these statements are baseless.
Principle:
For defamation, the defamatory statement needs to be published.
Explanation:
Defamation is a civil wrong that occurs when a false statement is communicated to a third party, which harms the reputation of an individual or entity. In order for a defamation claim to be successful, two key elements need to be established - a false statement and publication of that false statement.
In this case, the defendant sent a defamatory telegram directly to the plaintiff. However, the principle states that for a statement to be considered defamatory, it needs to be published. Publication refers to the communication of the defamatory statement to a third party who is not the plaintiff or the defendant. Therefore, in order for the plaintiff to successfully sue the defendant for defamation, the statement in the telegram must have been published to a third party.
Applying the principle to the facts:
- Option a) The telegram is addressed to the plaintiff and it hasn’t been published.
According to the principle, for defamation, publication is required. In this case, the telegram was addressed to the plaintiff, indicating that it was not intended to be communicated to a third party. Therefore, the defamatory statement has not been published.
- Option b) The message in the telegram is not defamatory hence publication does not matter.
The facts state that the telegram contains a defamatory statement. Therefore, this option is not applicable.
- Option c) The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.
There is no information in the facts to suggest that the telegram was seen by postal authorities or any other third party. Therefore, this option is not applicable.
- Option d) None of the above.
This option is not the correct answer as option a) is the most appropriate answer based on the principle and facts provided.
Conclusion:
Based on the principle that for defamation, the defamatory statement needs to be published, the plaintiff cannot sue the defendant in this case as the defamatory telegram was not published to a third party. Therefore, option a) is the most appropriate answer.
|
Explore Courses for CLAT exam
|
|
Top Courses for CLATView all
Direction: In this section every question is appended with facts and principles, and multiple choice answers.You are required to read the facts carefully, then read the principles, apply the principles to the given facts and make a select one the option which is the most appropriate answer from the given choices.Principle: For defamation the defamatorystatement needs to be published.Facts: The defendant sent a defamatory telegram to the plaintiff saying, “You liar, you thief; you deserve to be jailed.” The plaintiff received the telegram and wants to sue the defendant since he believes these statements are baseless. Can he do so?a)The telegram is addressed to the plaintiff and it hasn’t been published.b)The message in the telegram is not defamatory hence publication does not matter.c)The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.d)None of the aboveCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?
Question Description
Direction: In this section every question is appended with facts and principles, and multiple choice answers.You are required to read the facts carefully, then read the principles, apply the principles to the given facts and make a select one the option which is the most appropriate answer from the given choices.Principle: For defamation the defamatorystatement needs to be published.Facts: The defendant sent a defamatory telegram to the plaintiff saying, “You liar, you thief; you deserve to be jailed.” The plaintiff received the telegram and wants to sue the defendant since he believes these statements are baseless. Can he do so?a)The telegram is addressed to the plaintiff and it hasn’t been published.b)The message in the telegram is not defamatory hence publication does not matter.c)The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.d)None of the aboveCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? for CLAT 2025 is part of CLAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CLAT exam syllabus. Information about Direction: In this section every question is appended with facts and principles, and multiple choice answers.You are required to read the facts carefully, then read the principles, apply the principles to the given facts and make a select one the option which is the most appropriate answer from the given choices.Principle: For defamation the defamatorystatement needs to be published.Facts: The defendant sent a defamatory telegram to the plaintiff saying, “You liar, you thief; you deserve to be jailed.” The plaintiff received the telegram and wants to sue the defendant since he believes these statements are baseless. Can he do so?a)The telegram is addressed to the plaintiff and it hasn’t been published.b)The message in the telegram is not defamatory hence publication does not matter.c)The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.d)None of the aboveCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for CLAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Direction: In this section every question is appended with facts and principles, and multiple choice answers.You are required to read the facts carefully, then read the principles, apply the principles to the given facts and make a select one the option which is the most appropriate answer from the given choices.Principle: For defamation the defamatorystatement needs to be published.Facts: The defendant sent a defamatory telegram to the plaintiff saying, “You liar, you thief; you deserve to be jailed.” The plaintiff received the telegram and wants to sue the defendant since he believes these statements are baseless. Can he do so?a)The telegram is addressed to the plaintiff and it hasn’t been published.b)The message in the telegram is not defamatory hence publication does not matter.c)The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.d)None of the aboveCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?.
Direction: In this section every question is appended with facts and principles, and multiple choice answers.You are required to read the facts carefully, then read the principles, apply the principles to the given facts and make a select one the option which is the most appropriate answer from the given choices.Principle: For defamation the defamatorystatement needs to be published.Facts: The defendant sent a defamatory telegram to the plaintiff saying, “You liar, you thief; you deserve to be jailed.” The plaintiff received the telegram and wants to sue the defendant since he believes these statements are baseless. Can he do so?a)The telegram is addressed to the plaintiff and it hasn’t been published.b)The message in the telegram is not defamatory hence publication does not matter.c)The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.d)None of the aboveCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? for CLAT 2025 is part of CLAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CLAT exam syllabus. Information about Direction: In this section every question is appended with facts and principles, and multiple choice answers.You are required to read the facts carefully, then read the principles, apply the principles to the given facts and make a select one the option which is the most appropriate answer from the given choices.Principle: For defamation the defamatorystatement needs to be published.Facts: The defendant sent a defamatory telegram to the plaintiff saying, “You liar, you thief; you deserve to be jailed.” The plaintiff received the telegram and wants to sue the defendant since he believes these statements are baseless. Can he do so?a)The telegram is addressed to the plaintiff and it hasn’t been published.b)The message in the telegram is not defamatory hence publication does not matter.c)The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.d)None of the aboveCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for CLAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Direction: In this section every question is appended with facts and principles, and multiple choice answers.You are required to read the facts carefully, then read the principles, apply the principles to the given facts and make a select one the option which is the most appropriate answer from the given choices.Principle: For defamation the defamatorystatement needs to be published.Facts: The defendant sent a defamatory telegram to the plaintiff saying, “You liar, you thief; you deserve to be jailed.” The plaintiff received the telegram and wants to sue the defendant since he believes these statements are baseless. Can he do so?a)The telegram is addressed to the plaintiff and it hasn’t been published.b)The message in the telegram is not defamatory hence publication does not matter.c)The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.d)None of the aboveCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for Direction: In this section every question is appended with facts and principles, and multiple choice answers.You are required to read the facts carefully, then read the principles, apply the principles to the given facts and make a select one the option which is the most appropriate answer from the given choices.Principle: For defamation the defamatorystatement needs to be published.Facts: The defendant sent a defamatory telegram to the plaintiff saying, “You liar, you thief; you deserve to be jailed.” The plaintiff received the telegram and wants to sue the defendant since he believes these statements are baseless. Can he do so?a)The telegram is addressed to the plaintiff and it hasn’t been published.b)The message in the telegram is not defamatory hence publication does not matter.c)The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.d)None of the aboveCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for CLAT.
Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for CLAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of Direction: In this section every question is appended with facts and principles, and multiple choice answers.You are required to read the facts carefully, then read the principles, apply the principles to the given facts and make a select one the option which is the most appropriate answer from the given choices.Principle: For defamation the defamatorystatement needs to be published.Facts: The defendant sent a defamatory telegram to the plaintiff saying, “You liar, you thief; you deserve to be jailed.” The plaintiff received the telegram and wants to sue the defendant since he believes these statements are baseless. Can he do so?a)The telegram is addressed to the plaintiff and it hasn’t been published.b)The message in the telegram is not defamatory hence publication does not matter.c)The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.d)None of the aboveCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of
Direction: In this section every question is appended with facts and principles, and multiple choice answers.You are required to read the facts carefully, then read the principles, apply the principles to the given facts and make a select one the option which is the most appropriate answer from the given choices.Principle: For defamation the defamatorystatement needs to be published.Facts: The defendant sent a defamatory telegram to the plaintiff saying, “You liar, you thief; you deserve to be jailed.” The plaintiff received the telegram and wants to sue the defendant since he believes these statements are baseless. Can he do so?a)The telegram is addressed to the plaintiff and it hasn’t been published.b)The message in the telegram is not defamatory hence publication does not matter.c)The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.d)None of the aboveCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for Direction: In this section every question is appended with facts and principles, and multiple choice answers.You are required to read the facts carefully, then read the principles, apply the principles to the given facts and make a select one the option which is the most appropriate answer from the given choices.Principle: For defamation the defamatorystatement needs to be published.Facts: The defendant sent a defamatory telegram to the plaintiff saying, “You liar, you thief; you deserve to be jailed.” The plaintiff received the telegram and wants to sue the defendant since he believes these statements are baseless. Can he do so?a)The telegram is addressed to the plaintiff and it hasn’t been published.b)The message in the telegram is not defamatory hence publication does not matter.c)The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.d)None of the aboveCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of Direction: In this section every question is appended with facts and principles, and multiple choice answers.You are required to read the facts carefully, then read the principles, apply the principles to the given facts and make a select one the option which is the most appropriate answer from the given choices.Principle: For defamation the defamatorystatement needs to be published.Facts: The defendant sent a defamatory telegram to the plaintiff saying, “You liar, you thief; you deserve to be jailed.” The plaintiff received the telegram and wants to sue the defendant since he believes these statements are baseless. Can he do so?a)The telegram is addressed to the plaintiff and it hasn’t been published.b)The message in the telegram is not defamatory hence publication does not matter.c)The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.d)None of the aboveCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an
ample number of questions to practice Direction: In this section every question is appended with facts and principles, and multiple choice answers.You are required to read the facts carefully, then read the principles, apply the principles to the given facts and make a select one the option which is the most appropriate answer from the given choices.Principle: For defamation the defamatorystatement needs to be published.Facts: The defendant sent a defamatory telegram to the plaintiff saying, “You liar, you thief; you deserve to be jailed.” The plaintiff received the telegram and wants to sue the defendant since he believes these statements are baseless. Can he do so?a)The telegram is addressed to the plaintiff and it hasn’t been published.b)The message in the telegram is not defamatory hence publication does not matter.c)The telegram must have been seen by postal authorities hence publication has taken place.d)None of the aboveCorrect answer is option 'A'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice CLAT tests.
|
|
Explore Courses for CLAT exam
|
|
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
|
© EduRev
|
Education Revolution
|
|
Signup to see your scores
go up within 7 days!
Access 1000+ FREE Docs, Videos and Tests
Takes less than 10 seconds to signup