The object of the Butler Committee of 1927 was toa)Define the jurisdi...
Butler Committee of 1927: - The object of the Butler Committee of 1927 was to improve the relationship between the Government of India and the Indian States.
- Butler Committee of 1927 was also known as the Indian states committee.
- The committee submitted its report in 1929.
Important Recommendations: - The Committee advises that the Viceroy should represent the Crown in all dealings with the States. This proposed change is comparable with the new Imperial arrangement by which the Governor-General of a Dominion is High Commissioner for the Dominion's Protectorates.
- It says that paramountcy must remain supreme.
- It says that British paramountcy preserves the princely state.
- The Committee sympathize with the fear of the Native Princes that their States might pass without their consent under a new Government in British India responsible to an Indian Legislature, and they plainly express the opinion that no such transference should be made without the consent of the Princes.
- It also says that the state should not be transferred without its own agreement.
View all questions of this test
The object of the Butler Committee of 1927 was toa)Define the jurisdi...
The correct answer is option 'D', which states that the object of the Butler Committee of 1927 was to improve the relationship between the Government of India and the Indian States. The committee, officially known as the Indian States Committee, was appointed by the British Government to examine and report on the relationship between the Indian states and the Central Government of India.
The Butler Committee was formed in response to growing demands for reforms in the relationship between the princely states and the British Government. The princely states were semi-autonomous entities within British India, and their relationship with the Central Government was often complex and characterized by a lack of clarity and coordination.
The committee was chaired by Richard Butler, who was a senior British civil servant. The committee consisted of both British and Indian members, including representatives from the princely states. The committee's main objective was to examine the existing relationship between the princely states and the Central Government and make recommendations for its improvement.
The committee's report, commonly known as the Butler Report, was published in 1928. It made several important recommendations aimed at improving the relationship between the princely states and the Central Government. Some of the key recommendations included:
1. Creation of a central agency: The committee recommended the establishment of a central agency to act as a mediator between the princely states and the Central Government. This agency would be responsible for resolving disputes, coordinating policies, and facilitating communication between the two entities.
2. Strengthening of the Chamber of Princes: The committee recommended the expansion and strengthening of the Chamber of Princes, which was an advisory body representing the princely states. The committee suggested that the chamber should have a greater role in the decision-making process and should be given more powers to protect the interests of the princely states.
3. Devolution of powers: The committee recommended the devolution of certain powers to the princely states, allowing them to have more control over their internal affairs. This would help in promoting a greater sense of autonomy and self-governance among the princely states.
4. Financial arrangements: The committee proposed the establishment of a financial relationship between the princely states and the Central Government that would be based on fair and equitable principles. This would ensure that the princely states receive a fair share of the resources and revenues generated within British India.
Overall, the Butler Committee aimed to address the grievances and concerns of the princely states and establish a more harmonious and cooperative relationship between them and the Central Government. The committee's recommendations played a significant role in shaping the subsequent reforms in the relationship between the princely states and the Central Government in India.
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed UPSC study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in UPSC.