CLAT Exam  >  CLAT Questions  >   Directions: The question consists of two sta... Start Learning for Free
Directions: The question consists of two statements, one labelled as Principle(s) and the other as Facts. You are to examine the Principle(s) and apply it/them to the given Facts carefully, and select the best option.
Principle: An employer is liable for the negligence of his employee done during his course of employment.
Facts: Batman was a billionaire businessman in the city of Gotham and the owner of Wayne Enterprises. Alfred and Robin were two of his employees. One day, Batman asked Robin and Alfred to carry some piece of technology with all the care to Amanda Waller, the chief of ARGUS. They were told that any negligence could be fatal and they should go to the destination directly. While going there, Robin encountered Riddler, a criminal, and started chasing him with the van which was carrying the piece of technology. Alfred asked him not to do so, but he did not listen. He hit the van in a house, and the device in the van exploded, causing massive damage to the house.
Decide.
  • a)
    Batman is liable for the negligence as it happened during the course of employment.
  • b)
    Batman is not liable but Robin is, because chasing the Riddler was not the part of his employment.
  • c)
    Both Robin and Alfred are liable.
  • d)
    Batman and Robin are heroes, and they shouldn't be tried for mistakes.
Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?
Most Upvoted Answer
Directions: The question consists of two statements, one labelled as ...
Robin was going with Batman's business, but he engaged in chasing Riddler on his own, which was outside the course of his employment. So, the correct answer is option two.
Free Test
Community Answer
Directions: The question consists of two statements, one labelled as ...
Principle Application:

Principle: An employer is liable for the negligence of his employee done during his course of employment.

Facts Analysis:
- Batman is the employer of Alfred and Robin.
- Batman instructed Alfred and Robin to deliver a piece of technology to Amanda Waller with utmost care and warned them about the consequences of any negligence.
- Robin, one of the employees, deviated from the given instructions and started chasing a criminal, Riddler, with the van carrying the technology.
- The chase led to an accident where the device exploded, causing significant damage to a house.

Explanation:
- According to the principle stated, an employer is liable for the negligence of his employee during the course of employment.
- In this case, Batman, being the employer of Robin, can be held liable for the negligence of Robin as it occurred while Robin was carrying out the task assigned by Batman.
- However, Alfred, the other employee, did not participate in the negligent act and therefore cannot be held liable.
- Robin, on the other hand, deviated from his employment duties by chasing the criminal, which was not part of the assigned task. Therefore, Robin can be held personally liable for the damages caused due to his negligence.
Therefore, the correct option is:

Option B: Batman is not liable but Robin is, because chasing the Riddler was not part of his employment.
Explore Courses for CLAT exam

Top Courses for CLAT

Directions: The question consists of two statements, one labelled as Principle(s) and the other as Facts. You are to examine the Principle(s) and apply it/them to the given Facts carefully, and select the best option.Principle: An employer is liable for the negligence of his employee done during his course of employment.Facts: Batman was a billionaire businessman in the city of Gotham and the owner of Wayne Enterprises. Alfred and Robin were two of his employees. One day, Batman asked Robin and Alfred to carry some piece of technology with all the care to Amanda Waller, the chief of ARGUS. They were told that any negligence could be fatal and they should go to the destination directly. While going there, Robin encountered Riddler, a criminal, and started chasing him with the van which was carrying the piece of technology. Alfred asked him not to do so, but he did not listen. He hit the van in a house, and the device in the van exploded, causing massive damage to the house.Decide.a)Batman is liable for the negligence as it happened during the course of employment.b)Batman is not liable but Robin is, because chasing the Riddler was not the part of his employment.c)Both Robin and Alfred are liable.d)Batman and Robin are heroes, and they shouldn't be tried for mistakes.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?
Question Description
Directions: The question consists of two statements, one labelled as Principle(s) and the other as Facts. You are to examine the Principle(s) and apply it/them to the given Facts carefully, and select the best option.Principle: An employer is liable for the negligence of his employee done during his course of employment.Facts: Batman was a billionaire businessman in the city of Gotham and the owner of Wayne Enterprises. Alfred and Robin were two of his employees. One day, Batman asked Robin and Alfred to carry some piece of technology with all the care to Amanda Waller, the chief of ARGUS. They were told that any negligence could be fatal and they should go to the destination directly. While going there, Robin encountered Riddler, a criminal, and started chasing him with the van which was carrying the piece of technology. Alfred asked him not to do so, but he did not listen. He hit the van in a house, and the device in the van exploded, causing massive damage to the house.Decide.a)Batman is liable for the negligence as it happened during the course of employment.b)Batman is not liable but Robin is, because chasing the Riddler was not the part of his employment.c)Both Robin and Alfred are liable.d)Batman and Robin are heroes, and they shouldn't be tried for mistakes.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? for CLAT 2025 is part of CLAT preparation. The Question and answers have been prepared according to the CLAT exam syllabus. Information about Directions: The question consists of two statements, one labelled as Principle(s) and the other as Facts. You are to examine the Principle(s) and apply it/them to the given Facts carefully, and select the best option.Principle: An employer is liable for the negligence of his employee done during his course of employment.Facts: Batman was a billionaire businessman in the city of Gotham and the owner of Wayne Enterprises. Alfred and Robin were two of his employees. One day, Batman asked Robin and Alfred to carry some piece of technology with all the care to Amanda Waller, the chief of ARGUS. They were told that any negligence could be fatal and they should go to the destination directly. While going there, Robin encountered Riddler, a criminal, and started chasing him with the van which was carrying the piece of technology. Alfred asked him not to do so, but he did not listen. He hit the van in a house, and the device in the van exploded, causing massive damage to the house.Decide.a)Batman is liable for the negligence as it happened during the course of employment.b)Batman is not liable but Robin is, because chasing the Riddler was not the part of his employment.c)Both Robin and Alfred are liable.d)Batman and Robin are heroes, and they shouldn't be tried for mistakes.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? covers all topics & solutions for CLAT 2025 Exam. Find important definitions, questions, meanings, examples, exercises and tests below for Directions: The question consists of two statements, one labelled as Principle(s) and the other as Facts. You are to examine the Principle(s) and apply it/them to the given Facts carefully, and select the best option.Principle: An employer is liable for the negligence of his employee done during his course of employment.Facts: Batman was a billionaire businessman in the city of Gotham and the owner of Wayne Enterprises. Alfred and Robin were two of his employees. One day, Batman asked Robin and Alfred to carry some piece of technology with all the care to Amanda Waller, the chief of ARGUS. They were told that any negligence could be fatal and they should go to the destination directly. While going there, Robin encountered Riddler, a criminal, and started chasing him with the van which was carrying the piece of technology. Alfred asked him not to do so, but he did not listen. He hit the van in a house, and the device in the van exploded, causing massive damage to the house.Decide.a)Batman is liable for the negligence as it happened during the course of employment.b)Batman is not liable but Robin is, because chasing the Riddler was not the part of his employment.c)Both Robin and Alfred are liable.d)Batman and Robin are heroes, and they shouldn't be tried for mistakes.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?.
Solutions for Directions: The question consists of two statements, one labelled as Principle(s) and the other as Facts. You are to examine the Principle(s) and apply it/them to the given Facts carefully, and select the best option.Principle: An employer is liable for the negligence of his employee done during his course of employment.Facts: Batman was a billionaire businessman in the city of Gotham and the owner of Wayne Enterprises. Alfred and Robin were two of his employees. One day, Batman asked Robin and Alfred to carry some piece of technology with all the care to Amanda Waller, the chief of ARGUS. They were told that any negligence could be fatal and they should go to the destination directly. While going there, Robin encountered Riddler, a criminal, and started chasing him with the van which was carrying the piece of technology. Alfred asked him not to do so, but he did not listen. He hit the van in a house, and the device in the van exploded, causing massive damage to the house.Decide.a)Batman is liable for the negligence as it happened during the course of employment.b)Batman is not liable but Robin is, because chasing the Riddler was not the part of his employment.c)Both Robin and Alfred are liable.d)Batman and Robin are heroes, and they shouldn't be tried for mistakes.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? in English & in Hindi are available as part of our courses for CLAT. Download more important topics, notes, lectures and mock test series for CLAT Exam by signing up for free.
Here you can find the meaning of Directions: The question consists of two statements, one labelled as Principle(s) and the other as Facts. You are to examine the Principle(s) and apply it/them to the given Facts carefully, and select the best option.Principle: An employer is liable for the negligence of his employee done during his course of employment.Facts: Batman was a billionaire businessman in the city of Gotham and the owner of Wayne Enterprises. Alfred and Robin were two of his employees. One day, Batman asked Robin and Alfred to carry some piece of technology with all the care to Amanda Waller, the chief of ARGUS. They were told that any negligence could be fatal and they should go to the destination directly. While going there, Robin encountered Riddler, a criminal, and started chasing him with the van which was carrying the piece of technology. Alfred asked him not to do so, but he did not listen. He hit the van in a house, and the device in the van exploded, causing massive damage to the house.Decide.a)Batman is liable for the negligence as it happened during the course of employment.b)Batman is not liable but Robin is, because chasing the Riddler was not the part of his employment.c)Both Robin and Alfred are liable.d)Batman and Robin are heroes, and they shouldn't be tried for mistakes.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? defined & explained in the simplest way possible. Besides giving the explanation of Directions: The question consists of two statements, one labelled as Principle(s) and the other as Facts. You are to examine the Principle(s) and apply it/them to the given Facts carefully, and select the best option.Principle: An employer is liable for the negligence of his employee done during his course of employment.Facts: Batman was a billionaire businessman in the city of Gotham and the owner of Wayne Enterprises. Alfred and Robin were two of his employees. One day, Batman asked Robin and Alfred to carry some piece of technology with all the care to Amanda Waller, the chief of ARGUS. They were told that any negligence could be fatal and they should go to the destination directly. While going there, Robin encountered Riddler, a criminal, and started chasing him with the van which was carrying the piece of technology. Alfred asked him not to do so, but he did not listen. He hit the van in a house, and the device in the van exploded, causing massive damage to the house.Decide.a)Batman is liable for the negligence as it happened during the course of employment.b)Batman is not liable but Robin is, because chasing the Riddler was not the part of his employment.c)Both Robin and Alfred are liable.d)Batman and Robin are heroes, and they shouldn't be tried for mistakes.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?, a detailed solution for Directions: The question consists of two statements, one labelled as Principle(s) and the other as Facts. You are to examine the Principle(s) and apply it/them to the given Facts carefully, and select the best option.Principle: An employer is liable for the negligence of his employee done during his course of employment.Facts: Batman was a billionaire businessman in the city of Gotham and the owner of Wayne Enterprises. Alfred and Robin were two of his employees. One day, Batman asked Robin and Alfred to carry some piece of technology with all the care to Amanda Waller, the chief of ARGUS. They were told that any negligence could be fatal and they should go to the destination directly. While going there, Robin encountered Riddler, a criminal, and started chasing him with the van which was carrying the piece of technology. Alfred asked him not to do so, but he did not listen. He hit the van in a house, and the device in the van exploded, causing massive damage to the house.Decide.a)Batman is liable for the negligence as it happened during the course of employment.b)Batman is not liable but Robin is, because chasing the Riddler was not the part of his employment.c)Both Robin and Alfred are liable.d)Batman and Robin are heroes, and they shouldn't be tried for mistakes.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? has been provided alongside types of Directions: The question consists of two statements, one labelled as Principle(s) and the other as Facts. You are to examine the Principle(s) and apply it/them to the given Facts carefully, and select the best option.Principle: An employer is liable for the negligence of his employee done during his course of employment.Facts: Batman was a billionaire businessman in the city of Gotham and the owner of Wayne Enterprises. Alfred and Robin were two of his employees. One day, Batman asked Robin and Alfred to carry some piece of technology with all the care to Amanda Waller, the chief of ARGUS. They were told that any negligence could be fatal and they should go to the destination directly. While going there, Robin encountered Riddler, a criminal, and started chasing him with the van which was carrying the piece of technology. Alfred asked him not to do so, but he did not listen. He hit the van in a house, and the device in the van exploded, causing massive damage to the house.Decide.a)Batman is liable for the negligence as it happened during the course of employment.b)Batman is not liable but Robin is, because chasing the Riddler was not the part of his employment.c)Both Robin and Alfred are liable.d)Batman and Robin are heroes, and they shouldn't be tried for mistakes.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? theory, EduRev gives you an ample number of questions to practice Directions: The question consists of two statements, one labelled as Principle(s) and the other as Facts. You are to examine the Principle(s) and apply it/them to the given Facts carefully, and select the best option.Principle: An employer is liable for the negligence of his employee done during his course of employment.Facts: Batman was a billionaire businessman in the city of Gotham and the owner of Wayne Enterprises. Alfred and Robin were two of his employees. One day, Batman asked Robin and Alfred to carry some piece of technology with all the care to Amanda Waller, the chief of ARGUS. They were told that any negligence could be fatal and they should go to the destination directly. While going there, Robin encountered Riddler, a criminal, and started chasing him with the van which was carrying the piece of technology. Alfred asked him not to do so, but he did not listen. He hit the van in a house, and the device in the van exploded, causing massive damage to the house.Decide.a)Batman is liable for the negligence as it happened during the course of employment.b)Batman is not liable but Robin is, because chasing the Riddler was not the part of his employment.c)Both Robin and Alfred are liable.d)Batman and Robin are heroes, and they shouldn't be tried for mistakes.Correct answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer? tests, examples and also practice CLAT tests.
Explore Courses for CLAT exam

Top Courses for CLAT

Explore Courses
Signup for Free!
Signup to see your scores go up within 7 days! Learn & Practice with 1000+ FREE Notes, Videos & Tests.
10M+ students study on EduRev