One of the employees reports you that Mr X has links with the terrorists and requests you to take immediate action against him. You woulda)immediately suspend himb)secretly enquire about the matter before taking strong actionc)hand him over to the policed)do nothing and neglect himCorrect answer is option 'B'. Can you explain this answer?

Question

Answer

Options (a) and (c) are not valid on ethical and moral grounds as you are not sure about the validity of the information while option (d) shows negligence on your part. In this case, option (b) will be the right course of action.

Answer

Two team members have a persistent conflict that affects their productivity and team morale. As their leader, you need to mediate the situation, ensuring both parties feel heard and working towards a constructive resolution.

Answer

Secretly enquire about the matter before taking strong action

Introduction:
When an employee reports that another employee, Mr. X, has links with terrorists, it is crucial to handle the situation carefully and responsibly. Taking immediate action without proper investigation can have serious consequences, including potential harm to Mr. X's reputation if the allegations are false. Therefore, option B, which suggests secretly enquiring about the matter before taking strong action, is the most appropriate course of action.

Reasoning:

1. Presumption of innocence:
In any legal or disciplinary matter, it is essential to adhere to the principle of 'innocent until proven guilty.' Without concrete evidence, suspending or handing over Mr. X to the police can be seen as a violation of his rights and could lead to legal complications. By secretly enquiring about the matter, we can gather more information to substantiate the allegations before taking any drastic action.

2. Protecting Mr. X's rights:
Mr. X has the right to defend himself and provide an explanation for the allegations made against him. By conducting a secret enquiry, we allow him the opportunity to present his side of the story and potentially clear any misunderstandings. Taking immediate action without proper investigation could potentially harm Mr. X's career and personal life, even if the allegations are baseless.

3. Ensuring accuracy of the allegations:
It is crucial to ensure that the allegations made against Mr. X are accurate and credible before taking any strong action. By secretly enquiring about the matter, we can gather additional evidence, such as surveillance footage, communication records, or witness statements, to verify the claims. This will help in making an informed decision and avoiding any false accusations.

4. Maintaining confidentiality:
By conducting a secret enquiry, we can protect the identity of the employee who reported the issue. This confidentiality is essential to encourage employees to come forward with genuine concerns without fear of retaliation or breach of trust. It also allows the organization to handle the matter discreetly and effectively without causing unnecessary panic or disruption among other employees.

Conclusion:
Secretly enquiring about the matter before taking strong action is the most appropriate response in this situation. It ensures fairness, protects Mr. X's rights, allows for a thorough investigation, and maintains confidentiality. By following this approach, the organization can handle the situation responsibly and mitigate any potential harm or legal complications.

Similar UPSC Doubts

One of the employee’s in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs reports you that Mr. X links with corruption and nepotism. He requests you to take immediate action against him. What action will you take to address the problem? What mechanism should be designed to prevent similar cases for the future?

You have an urgent meeting with CM, as you are a District Magistrate. You get a call about the supply of large quantities of spurious drugs into your city. Now, what will be your immediate step to solve the problem?

What is the proposed role of the media in combatting terrorism, according to the text?

Top Courses for UPSCView all

Current Affairs & Hindu Analysis: Daily, Weekly & Monthly

Lucent for GK

History for UPSC CSE

Indian Polity for UPSC CSE

CSAT Preparation

Top Courses for UPSC

Top Courses for UPSC

Suggested Free Tests

Related Content

About UPSC

UPSC Preparation Material

NCERT Based Study Material

How to Prepare for UPSC Exam?

Famous Books for UPSC Exam

UPSC Subjects

UPSC Optionals

Other Popular Exams

Company