Do you think the boys looked after Lucia unwillingly?Give reason for your answer.?

Question

Answer

No...I don't think the two boys Nicola and jacopo looked after Lucia unwillingly bcz no one was forcing them to work so hard to earn money. They sacrificed their own needs to save their money for their sister. They tried to get the best treatment for her out of love , care and devotion for their sister....

Answer

No if they are unwilling to Lucia then they did not admitted her to hospital and do hard work to pay fee of hospital

Answer

Thanx both of you....

Answer

There is no doubt that Nichola and jacopo looked after their sister quite willingly . The family was destroyed during the war .Once the war was over the orphan boys came back to their loving sister . They had no one in the world to call their own except their sister .they were extremely pained to know that Lucia suffered from the tuberculosis of spine. They didn't give up . Even the war couldn't break their spirit.

Answer

Introduction:
In order to determine whether the boys looked after Lucia unwillingly, it is important to analyze their actions and motivations throughout the story. The boys' treatment of Lucia, their attitudes towards her, and their willingness to help her will provide insights into their true intentions.

Evidence of Unwillingness:
1. Lack of empathy: Initially, the boys showed a lack of empathy towards Lucia. They made fun of her physical appearance, calling her 'Lucia the Lame' due to her limp. This demonstrates a lack of consideration for her feelings and suggests their unwillingness to care for her.

2. Reluctance to help: Throughout the story, the boys displayed a reluctance to help Lucia. When she needed assistance climbing the tree to retrieve her kite, they hesitated and only offered help when she insisted. This suggests that they were not genuinely concerned about her well-being and were only willing to assist when pressured.

3. Disregard for her needs: The boys often disregarded Lucia's needs and desires. For example, when they went fishing, they did not consider Lucia's interest in fishing and instead focused on their own enjoyment. This lack of inclusivity and consideration indicates their unwillingness to prioritize her needs.

Evidence of Willingness:
1. Protective actions: Despite their initial reluctance, the boys did demonstrate some protective actions towards Lucia. When she fell and injured herself, they immediately rushed to her aid and showed concern for her well-being. This suggests that they did care about her safety to some extent.

2. Gradual change in attitude: As the story progresses, the boys' attitudes towards Lucia start to shift. They begin to appreciate her unique qualities and talents, such as her ability to play the guitar. This change in attitude indicates a growing willingness to accept and support Lucia.

3. Acts of kindness: Towards the end of the story, the boys actively participate in helping Lucia in her performance at the talent show. They assist her in rehearsing, provide emotional support, and even create a special stage setup for her. These acts of kindness demonstrate a genuine willingness to look after Lucia and help her succeed.

Conclusion:
While the boys initially showed a lack of empathy and reluctance to help Lucia, their actions gradually shifted towards a more supportive and caring stance. The evidence suggests that although they may have initially looked after Lucia unwillingly, their attitudes and behaviors evolved over time, indicating a growing willingness to care for and support her.

Top Courses for Class 10View all

Science Class 10

Social Studies (SST) Class 10

Mathematics (Maths) Class 10

English Grammar Advanced

English Grammar Basic

Top Courses for Class 10

Top Courses for Class 10

Suggested Free Tests

Related Content

About Class 10

Class 10 Study Material

Class 10 All Subjects

NCERT Textbook Solutions

Other Classes

Important Links

Company