Do u think the end was justified (the frog and the nightingale)?

Question

Answer

This question can have two answers....on one hand we can say the end is justified coz nightingale was a dumb creature who didn't have self confidence and that resulted in her own downfall....but on the other hand we can also say that she was too innocent so that the cunning frog befooled her ...but I think the end is justified .One must have full faith in oneself.One shouldn't be a dumb driven cattle like the nightingale

Answer

Yes ,I think...Because in reality too it is evil and manipulative who wins .Those who are weak and docile often end up falling in the trap of wrong people.Moreover the end is justified cause the nightingale was a stupid creature she herself was responsible for her downfall.She was not confident of her singing.She practised  and sang against her wishes .she was not sensible enough to think about finding a solution or flying away if she was not happy there.

Answer

The End of 'The Frog and the Nightingale'

'The Frog and the Nightingale' is a poem written by Vikram Seth that tells the story of a frog who bullies and eventually kills a nightingale for her beautiful singing. The poem ends with the frog gloating over his victory, while the other animals in the forest mourn the loss of the nightingale. The question of whether the end of the poem was justified or not can be answered in different ways.

Arguments for the end being justified:

1. The frog was simply following his natural instincts: Frogs are predators, and it is only natural for them to hunt and kill smaller animals. In this sense, one could argue that the frog was simply doing what frogs do, and that the nightingale was unlucky to cross his path.

2. The nightingale was naive and should have known better: Throughout the poem, the nightingale is portrayed as naive and trusting, believing the frog's flattery and ignoring the warnings of the other animals. One could argue that she should have been more cautious and aware of the dangers around her.

3. The poem is a cautionary tale: The poem can be seen as a warning against blindly following those who flatter and praise us, and against naively trusting those who may have ulterior motives. In this sense, the end of the poem serves as a cautionary tale for the reader.

Arguments against the end being justified:

1. The frog's behavior was cruel and unnecessary: While it may be natural for frogs to hunt and kill, the way the frog in the poem bullies and torments the nightingale is cruel and unnecessary. He could have simply caught her and killed her quickly, but instead he toys with her and makes her suffer.

2. The nightingale was a victim of bullying: The nightingale is clearly a victim in the poem, and the way the frog bullies and belittles her is reminiscent of the behavior of human bullies. In this sense, the end of the poem can be seen as a commentary on the dangers of bullying and the need to stand up to bullies.

3. The poem is a tragedy: The end of the poem is tragic, as the beautiful singing of the nightingale is silenced forever. While it may be a cautionary tale, it is also a sad and poignant reminder of the fragility of life and the need to cherish and protect what is beautiful and precious.

Conclusion:

In conclusion, the question of whether the end of 'The Frog and the Nightingale' was justified or not is a complex one. While there are arguments on both sides, it is ultimately up to the reader to decide how they feel about the poem and its message. Whether seen as a cautionary tale, a commentary on bullying, or a tragic reminder of the fragility of life, 'The Frog and the Nightingale' is a powerful and thought-provoking poem that continues to resonate with readers today.

Answer

Bcoz at the end we saw that Nightingale died because of her fault she lacked confidence she don't have trust on herself she also use to come in trap of others easily... so we can say that Se herself is responsible for her death at last...So we can say that end is justified here..

Answer

S, the end was justified.

Answer

I am sorry Avantika mujhse galti se block ka function press ho Gaya tha

Answer

How?? can u explain it...???

Answer

Yes, the end of the frog and the nightingale is justified,, for know how.., pls read the message of poem

Answer

Yup

Similar Class 10 Doubts

Caesar had done a lot of good things for the people of Rome . yet he got nothing but death. Do you think his end was justified ? Explain .?

What do you think the frog is smarter than nightingale?

do you think the end is justified according to nightangle poem

Do you think that the nightingale should also be blamed for her tragic end? What values can you draw from the story?

why the title of the poem was the frog and nightingale why not the nightingale and frog

Top Courses for Class 10View all

Science Class 10

Social Studies (SST) Class 10

Mathematics (Maths) Class 10

English Grammar Advanced

English Grammar Basic

Top Courses for Class 10

Top Courses for Class 10

Suggested Free Tests

Related Content

About Class 10

Class 10 Study Material

Class 10 All Subjects

NCERT Textbook Solutions

Other Classes

Important Links

Company