Consider the following carbocations is most stable:a)C6H5CH2+b)C6H5CH2CH2+c)C6H5CH+CH3d)C6H5C+ (CH3)2Correct answer is option 'D'. Can you explain this answer?

Question

Answer

Correct answer is D
because the outside groups are electron donating groups. This CH3 group donate their electron or bond pair toward carbocation and carbocation possess stablity Due to those bulk groups atoms...
And 3 carbocation also stable by hyperconjugation effect...

Answer

Stability of Carbocations

Carbocation stability is determined by the number of alkyl groups attached to the positively charged carbon atom. The more the number of alkyl groups, the more stable the carbocation is.

Explanation of Options

a) C6H5CH2 carbocation has only one alkyl group attached to it, making it less stable.
b) C6H5CH2CH2 carbocation has two alkyl groups attached to it, making it more stable than option a) but less stable than option c) and d).
c) C6H5CH CH3 carbocation has one alkyl group and one aryl group attached to it. The aryl group stabilizes the carbocation to some extent, but it is still less stable than option d).
d) C6H5C (CH3)2 carbocation has two alkyl groups attached to it, making it the most stable among the given options.

Conclusion

Hence, option d) C6H5C (CH3)2 is the most stable carbocation among the given options due to the presence of two alkyl groups, making it more stable than the other options.

Answer

Stability of Carbocations

Carbocations are species having a positively charged carbon atom with an empty p orbital. They are highly reactive and unstable, but their stability can be assessed based on the following factors:

1. Electron-donating groups: Groups that release electrons towards the carbocation increase its stability.

2. Electron-withdrawing groups: Groups that draw electrons away from the carbocation reduce its stability.

3. Resonance: Resonance structures stabilize the carbocation by delocalizing the positive charge.

4. Hyperconjugation: This refers to the overlap of an empty p orbital on the carbocation with adjacent C-H bonds, which stabilizes the carbocation by donating electrons.

Based on these factors, the most stable carbocation is:

D) C6H5C(CH3)2

Reasoning

1. Electron-donating groups: The two methyl groups on the carbocation in option D are electron-donating, which increases its stability.

2. Electron-withdrawing groups: None of the options have any electron-withdrawing groups.

3. Resonance: None of the options have any resonance structures.

4. Hyperconjugation: The carbocation in option D has two adjacent C-H bonds, which can overlap with the empty p orbital, increasing its stability.

Therefore, the most stable carbocation is option D, C6H5C(CH3)2.

Answer

But i guess benzyl carbocation is even more stable than tertiary carbocation

Answer

D

Similar Chemistry Doubts

Consider the following carbocations is most stable

Which among the following carbocations is most stable

Which of the following carbocations is the most stable?

Which of the following carbocations is the most stable?

List the following carbocations in order of decreasing stability (starting with the most stabl e)

Top Courses for Chemistry

Suggested Free Tests

Related Content

Schools

Competitive Examinations

Quick Access Links

Technical Exams