Difference Between nation-state and modern-state?
Nation states emerged after overthrowing monarchy and dynasty rule in Europe. While modern states have been developing since then. Modern states are ruled by a centralised power and authority.
In a nation state, citizens came to develop a common identity based on shared language, traditions and cutoms. In modern states, people speaking different languages, following various traditions and cultures live together. Nations states have now developed as modern states.
This question is part of UPSC exam. View all Class 10 courses
Difference Between nation-state and modern-state?
Nation-State
A nation-state is a political entity that encompasses both a nation (a group of people who share a common culture, language, history, and identity) and a state (a defined territory with a government). It is characterized by the idea that the political boundaries of a state should correspond to the cultural boundaries of a nation.
Key Points:
- Definition: A nation-state is a political entity that combines a nation and a state.
- Nation: A nation refers to a group of people who share common cultural, linguistic, historical, and identity traits.
- State: A state is a defined territory with a government that exercises sovereignty over its population and territory.
- Correspondence: In a nation-state, the political boundaries of the state are intended to align with the cultural boundaries of the nation.
- Homogeneity: The nation-state model assumes a high degree of homogeneity within the nation in terms of culture, language, and identity.
- Examples: Examples of nation-states include Japan, Iceland, and South Korea.
Modern-State
A modern-state, also known as a sovereign state or nation-state, is a political entity that exercises full sovereignty over a defined territory. It is characterized by the presence of a centralized government that has the authority to make and enforce laws within its territory.
Key Points:
- Definition: A modern-state is a political entity with full sovereignty over a defined territory.
- Sovereignty: A modern-state has the authority to govern itself without interference from external powers.
- Centralized Government: It has a centralized government that exercises power and authority over the territory and population.
- Territory: A modern-state has clearly defined boundaries that separate it from other states.
- Legal Authority: The government of a modern-state has the power to make and enforce laws within its territory.
- Examples: Examples of modern-states include the United States, France, and Brazil.
Differences:
- Concept: The main difference between a nation-state and a modern-state lies in their conceptualization. A nation-state emphasizes the alignment of political and cultural boundaries, whereas a modern-state focuses on the exercise of sovereignty and governance.
- Homogeneity vs. Diversity: Nation-states assume a high degree of cultural homogeneity within the nation, while modern-states can have diverse populations with various cultural, linguistic, and ethnic backgrounds.
- Correspondence vs. Territorial Sovereignty: Nation-states aim for political boundaries that correspond to cultural boundaries, whereas modern-states prioritize territorial sovereignty and effective governance within their defined boundaries.
- Examples: The examples of nation-states tend to be countries with relatively homogeneous populations, while modern-states can be more diverse in terms of their population composition.
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed Class 10 study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in Class 10.