What is the similarity and difference between Belgium and Sri Lanka wa...
Similarity between Belgium and Sri Lanka's way of power sharing:
1. Both Belgium and Sri Lanka have a complex social structure with diverse ethnic, linguistic, and religious groups. This diversity necessitates the need for power-sharing arrangements to maintain social harmony and political stability.
Difference between Belgium and Sri Lanka's way of power sharing:
1. Approach to power sharing: Belgium has a more accommodative approach to power-sharing, with constitutional provisions that ensure representation and participation of various linguistic and ethnic groups in the government. In contrast, Sri Lanka has had a majoritarian approach, which has led to the marginalization of the Tamil minority and has fueled ethnic tensions.
2. Government structure: Belgium is a federal country with a power-sharing arrangement between the French-speaking Walloons and the Dutch-speaking Flemish communities. Power is divided between the central government and regional governments of the two communities. Sri Lanka, on the other hand, has a unitary form of government with centralization of power, which has been a source of discontent among the Tamil minority.
3. Language policy: Belgium has a bilingual policy that recognizes both Dutch and French as official languages, with the capital Brussels being a bilingual region. This ensures that both linguistic communities have equal status in the country. In Sri Lanka, the Sinhala Only Act of 1956 made Sinhala the sole official language, disregarding the Tamil language and leading to widespread protests and resentment among the Tamil minority.
4. Proportional representation: Belgium follows a system of proportional representation in its electoral system, ensuring that the different linguistic and ethnic groups are fairly represented in the government. Sri Lanka, however, follows a majoritarian electoral system, which has often resulted in underrepresentation of the Tamil minority.
5. Conflict resolution: Belgium has been able to manage its linguistic and ethnic divisions through negotiation, dialogue, and power-sharing arrangements, maintaining peace and stability in the country. Sri Lanka, on the other hand, witnessed a prolonged and violent civil war between the government and the Tamil Tigers, a separatist group fighting for an independent Tamil state. The war lasted from 1983 until 2009 and resulted in significant human rights abuses and loss of life.
This question is part of UPSC exam. View all Class 10 courses
What is the similarity and difference between Belgium and Sri Lanka wa...
Similarity and Difference between Belgium and Sri Lanka Way of Power Sharing
Belgium and Sri Lanka have different forms of power sharing mechanisms. However, some of the similarities and differences between these two countries' power sharing methods are as follows:
Similarities:
1. Both countries have adopted federalism as a way of sharing power between the central government and its sub-national governments.
2. Both countries have multiple ethnic, linguistic and religious groups that have to be accommodated in the power-sharing arrangement.
3. Both countries have a bicameral legislature, with one house representing the people and the other representing the regions.
Differences:
1. Belgium has a consociational model of power sharing, while Sri Lanka has a unitary model.
2. Belgium has three language communities (Dutch, French and German) that have significant autonomy in their respective regions, while Sri Lanka has only two major ethnic communities (Sinhalese and Tamils) that have been in conflict over power sharing.
3. In Belgium, each language community has its own government with extensive powers in education, culture and language policy, while in Sri Lanka, the central government has more powers, and the sub-national governments have less autonomy.
4. Belgium has a complex system of power sharing that involves proportional representation, mandatory power-sharing and veto rights for minority groups, while Sri Lanka has a simpler system of power sharing that involves devolution of powers to the provinces.
Conclusion:
In conclusion, Belgium and Sri Lanka have different models of power sharing. Belgium's consociational model emphasizes power sharing among different language communities, while Sri Lanka's unitary model emphasizes devolution of power to the provinces. Both models have their strengths and weaknesses, and it is up to each country to determine which model best suits their needs.
What is the similarity and difference between Belgium and Sri Lanka wa...
As an AI language model, I do not have personal opinions or beliefs, but I can provide you with some information about the power-sharing systems in Belgium and Sri Lanka.
Similarities:
- Both countries have a federal system of government, with power divided between the central government and regional governments.
- Both countries have a mix of proportional representation and constituency-based electoral systems.
- Both countries have experienced ethnic and linguistic tensions, which have influenced their power-sharing arrangements.
Differences:
- Belgium has a complex system of power-sharing between its Dutch-speaking, French-speaking, and German-speaking communities, while Sri Lanka's power-sharing arrangements are primarily focused on the Sinhalese and Tamil ethnic groups.
- Belgium's federal system is more decentralized than Sri Lanka's, with a greater degree of autonomy granted to the regional governments.
- Sri Lanka has a history of violent conflict between the central government and the Tamil minority, which has led to the creation of a separate Tamil-majority province in the north and east of the country. Belgium does not have a similar situation of violent conflict between its different communities.
To make sure you are not studying endlessly, EduRev has designed Class 10 study material, with Structured Courses, Videos, & Test Series. Plus get personalized analysis, doubt solving and improvement plans to achieve a great score in Class 10.