Can you explain the answer of this question below:Which sentence makes...
Simple Past sentence is the more relevant.
What did you do when the dog ran into the room? - I jumped out of the window.
View all questions of this test
Can you explain the answer of this question below:Which sentence makes...
Analysis of the sentences:
The two sentences provided are both grammatically correct, but they have slightly different meanings. To determine which sentence makes more sense, we need to analyze the context and the tense used in each sentence.
Sentence A: "What did you do when the dog ran into the room? - I jumped out of the window."
This sentence is in the past simple tense, indicating that the action of jumping out of the window occurred at a specific point in the past. The question is asking about the person's action immediately after the dog ran into the room.
Sentence B: "What were you doing when the dog ran into the room? - I was jumping out of the window."
This sentence is in the past continuous tense, indicating that the action of jumping out of the window was in progress when the dog ran into the room. The question is asking about the person's ongoing action at the time the dog entered the room.
Determining the more sensible sentence:
Based on the context provided, sentence A ("What did you do when the dog ran into the room? - I jumped out of the window.") makes more sense. This is because the question is asking for a specific action in response to the dog entering the room, and the past simple tense accurately conveys this meaning.
In contrast, sentence B ("What were you doing when the dog ran into the room? - I was jumping out of the window.") implies that the person was already in the process of jumping out of the window before the dog entered the room. This does not align with the context of the question, which is asking for the immediate response to the dog's entry.
Therefore, sentence A is the more appropriate and sensible choice in this scenario.