Why Indians oppose Simon Commission ?

Question

Answer

¶¶ the simon commission was oppose by indians as it did not contain any indian member.
People were outraged by this.
People protested with the slogan 'Simon Go Back'

Answer

Simon commission is form in response to nationalist movement in 1927
it consists of 7 members with their head Sir.john Simon.
for which motive Simon commission was constituted it fails to do so, it was opposed by indian people's as well as by all parties including Congress.

Answer

Indians oppose simon commision because in the simon commission there is no single indians.All the members of the simon commission were Britishers.So Indians react to this with a movement known as Anti- Simon Movement with a slogan 'Go back Simon'.

Answer

In 1927, the British Conservative governement appointed the Simon Commission to consider the situation in India. There were many reasons why the Simon Commission was opposed by Indians.

The main reason was that there was no Indian representative in the commission as all the members were British. This made the Indians feel insulted, and led to a growing belief that the British were again trying to strengthen their control over India. This fact was unacceptable to all Indians.

Since the Indians desired independance from the British, and seeing the after effects of the British reforms in 1919, opposition to the Simon Commission seemed like a good way to show their general opposition to the British.

Answer

Introduction:

The Simon Commission, also known as the Indian Statutory Commission, was appointed by the British Government in 1927 to propose constitutional reforms for India. However, the Commission faced severe opposition from the Indian population. There were several reasons why Indians opposed the Simon Commission:

1. Lack of Indian representation:
- The Simon Commission consisted entirely of British members; there were no Indian members appointed.
- Indians felt that without Indian representation, the Commission would not accurately understand and address the issues and aspirations of the Indian population.

2. Boycott by Indian political parties:
- Major Indian political parties, including the Indian National Congress and Muslim League, boycotted the Simon Commission.
- They believed that participating in the Commission would legitimize British rule and undermine the demand for complete independence.

3. Dissatisfaction with previous commissions:
- Indians had a history of dissatisfaction with previous commissions, such as the Hunter Commission and the Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms, which failed to meet their expectations.
- This led to a lack of trust in the Simon Commission and skepticism about its intentions.

4. Inadequate representation of diverse Indian interests:
- The Simon Commission did not adequately represent the diverse interests of different regions and communities in India.
- Indians felt that their opinions and concerns would not be accurately represented and addressed by the Commission.

5. British political motivations behind the Commission:
- Many Indians believed that the Simon Commission was a mere political tactic by the British government to delay or deflect demands for self-governance and independence.
- The appointment of an all-British Commission reinforced these suspicions.

Conclusion:

In conclusion, the opposition to the Simon Commission by Indians was rooted in several factors, including the lack of Indian representation, a history of dissatisfaction with previous commissions, inadequate representation of diverse Indian interests, and suspicions about the British government's political motivations. The opposition to the Simon Commission further fueled the demand for complete independence and self-governance in India.

Similar Class 10 Doubts

Identify the appropriate reason for the formation of the Swaraj Party from the options given below : (

Simon Commission was greeted with "go back Simon" at arrival in india. Support this reaction of Indians with arguments?

Who died in the Lahore protest against Simon Commission who boycotted Simon commission and Britishers did lathi charge on him and he died?

Who boycotted Simon Commission?

Why was the simon commission sent to india?

Top Courses for Class 10View all

Science Class 10

Social Studies (SST) Class 10

Mathematics (Maths) Class 10

English Grammar Advanced

English Grammar Basic

Top Courses for Class 10

Top Courses for Class 10

Suggested Free Tests

Related Content

About Class 10

Class 10 Study Material

Class 10 All Subjects

NCERT Textbook Solutions

Other Classes

Important Links

Company