Many societies did not follow the social rules and rituals prescribed ...
If we go through the options a,b,c all followed the social rules and rituals prescribed by the Brahmanas. So, by eliminating the options we can get the answer. But the genuine explanation is Kshatriyas performed rituals in the guidance of Brahmanas also vaishyas will perform their duties according to the Brahmanas rules and coming to Sudras they are not allowed to perform sacrifices to the god which is the rule prescribed by the Brahmanas. But coming to tribes they don't follow any of these rules or rituals their livelihood is different from these three,so the answer is D. According to me the explanation is this if I'm wrong please correct me.
Many societies did not follow the social rules and rituals prescribed ...
Explanation:
In ancient Indian society, the Brahmanas, or priestly class, played a significant role in shaping social rules and rituals. They prescribed a hierarchical social structure that divided people into numerous unequal classes based on their birth and occupation. However, not all societies in ancient India followed these prescribed social rules and rituals. These societies, which did not conform to the Brahmanical norms, are often referred to as tribes.
Reasons for not following the prescribed social rules:
There are several reasons why many societies in ancient India did not adhere to the social rules and rituals prescribed by the Brahmanas:
1. Geographical and cultural diversity: Ancient India had a vast and diverse geographical landscape, with different regions having their own distinct cultures and traditions. Some societies, particularly those living in remote and isolated areas, developed their own social customs and practices, which were often different from those prescribed by the Brahmanas.
2. Economic activities: The social structure prescribed by the Brahmanas was primarily based on occupation. However, not all societies engaged in the occupations that were traditionally associated with the four varnas (Brahmins, Kshatriyas, Vaishyas, and Shudras). Tribes, for example, often relied on hunting, gathering, and pastoralism for their livelihoods, which did not fit into the Brahmanical occupational framework.
3. Interactions with other cultures: Ancient India had extensive trade networks and cultural exchanges with other regions, including Central Asia, China, and Southeast Asia. These interactions often led to the blending of different cultural practices, resulting in the emergence of new social norms that were distinct from the Brahmanical traditions.
The term 'tribes':
The term 'tribes' is commonly used to refer to these societies that did not follow the social rules and rituals prescribed by the Brahmanas. However, it is essential to note that the term 'tribe' is a colonial construct and can be problematic. It tends to homogenize diverse communities and overlook their unique cultural practices and identities. Therefore, it is crucial to use the term with caution and consider the specific characteristics and traditions of each society.
In conclusion, many societies in ancient India did not conform to the social rules and rituals prescribed by the Brahmanas. These societies, often referred to as tribes, developed their own social customs and practices based on factors such as geographical diversity, economic activities, and interactions with other cultures. It is important to acknowledge the uniqueness and diversity of these societies and avoid generalizations or stereotypes associated with the term 'tribe.'